Jump to Content
Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo
  • 中文
  • Deutsch
Access via:
Dar Hadith al Hassania
Login to my Brill account Create Brill Account
Browse Our Titles
African Studies
American Studies
Ancient Near East and Egypt
Art History
Asian Studies
Biblical Studies
Biology
Book History and Cartography
Classical Studies
Education
History
Human Rights and Humanitarian Law
International Law
International Relations
Jewish Studies
Languages and Linguistics
Life Sciences
Literature and Cultural Studies
Media Studies
Middle East and Islamic Studies
Musicology
Philosophy
Religious Studies
Slavic and Eurasian Studies
Social Sciences
Theology and World Christianity

Becoming a Brill Author

Publishing Ethics & AI Policy

Publishing Guides

General Open Access Information

For Authors

For Academic Societies

For Librarians

Research Funding

Open Access Pricing

Books

Journals

Specialty Products

Metadata: Title Lists, MARC & KBART Files

Catalogs, Flyers and Price Lists

Accessing Brill Products

About Brill & its History

Imprints

Careers

Organization

Corporate Social Responsibility

News Archive

Sales Contacts

Ordering from Brill

Editorial Contacts

Offices Worlwide

Press & Reviews

Rights & Permissions

Course Adoption

Contact Form

Help
Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo Brill Logo
Access via:
Dar Hadith al Hassania
Login to my Brill account Create Brill Account
  • 中文
  • Deutsch
Browse Our Titles
African Studies Education Media Studies
American Studies History Middle East and Islamic Studies
Ancient Near East and Egypt Human Rights and Humanitarian Law Musicology
Art History International Law Philosophy
Asian Studies International Relations Religious Studies
Biblical Studies Jewish Studies Slavic and Eurasian Studies
Biology Languages and Linguistics Social Sciences
Book History and Cartography Life Sciences Theology and World Christianity
Classical Studies Literature and Cultural Studies  

Becoming a Brill Author

Publishing Ethics & AI Policy

Publishing Guides

General Open Access Information

For Authors

For Academic Societies

For Librarians

Research Funding

Open Access Pricing

Books

Journals

Specialty Products

Metadata: Title Lists, MARC & KBART Files

Catalogs, Flyers and Price Lists

Accessing Brill Products

About Brill & its History

Imprints

Careers

Organization

Corporate Social Responsibility

News Archive

Sales Contacts

Ordering from Brill

Editorial Contacts

Offices Worlwide

Press & Reviews

Rights & Permissions

Course Adoption

Contact Form

Help

Index

In: Threshold Concepts in the Moment
Access via:
Dar Hadith al Hassania
  • Full Text

Index

Index

Note: figure and table locators are in bold

Abdulwahed, M. 460
academic/educational developers 4–13, 9, 32–33, 36, 174, 353, 407
action poetry 476, 478
Adam, B. 34, 35
adaptive cycles 35–37, 39
Adendorff, H. 399
affect 126–128, 127, 142–149, 158, 159
liminality and 129–135, 136, 137, 146–149
loneliness 142–143, 152
management of 24, 392, 393
negative 96, 97
ontological shifts and 447
and pedagogy 98–100
in post-liminality 333, 334
transition to HE and 329–331
anxiety ; excitement ; fear ; frustration
agency, development of 157, 161, 333
Åkerlind, G. 49, 399, 400
Akkerman, S. F. 90, 92, 93
alterity 479
anticolonialism 310
anxiety 161, 329, 443, 448, 480
about technology 311, 312, 318, 318, 319, 320
alleviation of 181, 193
peer learning and 161
provocation of 121
spatial 133
student accounts of 142–143, 146–147
Appling, J. 343
apprenticeships. see graduate apprentices/apprenticeships
architecture education 109, 121–123, 125–135
articulation 121–122, 160–161, 167, 211–223
difficulties with 140, 212–213
in liminality 93, 94–95, 99, 100
of teaching values 181–182
Asad, T. 75–77
Ashwin, A. 18
assessment 15, 21–23
ePortfolios 343–353
formative 17, 215
journal writing 215–217
presentations 219, 220
qualitative 20–22
quantitative 22
reflective writings 212, 213, 217–219
summative 17, 18
as TC 263, 264, 265–268
TC s-based 15–28
Atherton, J. 45
Atherton, M. C. 213
Auden, W. H. 480
audience 347–350
authentic project method 377–379, 381–390, 391
autonomy
authentic learning and 378–379
development of 442, 446
and motivation 362–363, 372
secularism and 76, 81
as TC 259, 308
Badke, W. 426
Baer, A. 422
Baillie, C. 48, 96, 291, 331, 380
Bain, K. 414, 430
Bair, H. 344, 345, 352
Bakhtin, M. 108, 113, 114
Bakker, A. 90, 92
Ball, J. P. 114, 115
Barlow, C. A. 436
Barnett, R. 39, 111, 113, 477
Barradell, S. 22–23, 44–46, 59, 60, 66, 448, 449, 476
Barrett, F. J. 114–116
Barrie, T. 124
Barton, G. 94
Bass, R. 178, 414, 430
beliefs 18, 19, 21–23, 228
Bell, A. 274
Bennett, D. 44
Bennett, R. E. 17
Berg, M. 171
Bergin, S. 460
Bhabha, H. K. 307
Biesta, G. 110, 113, 115, 260
biology 226, 227, 234, 235
Bloo, R. 283, 291–294, 300
Bonner, J. 346
Booth, C. 420
Booth, S. 438
Boss, P. 8
boundaries 32, 39, 72, 91–93, 227
boundary objects 89, 90, 92–101, 97
boundedness 44, 53, 257, 337, 448
mathematical proving and 277, 281–283
Boyle, R. A. 91
bricolage 140, 149, 151
Brookfield, S. 236, 420
Brown, B. 8
Brown, M. 346
Brown, M. E. L. 38, 43–46, 361
Bruce, C. S. 423
Buber, M. 113
burnout 171–172, 174, 179–181, 188
Calduch, I. 242, 253
Cambridge, D. 344
Cameron, L. 346
Campbell, J. 109, 123, 137
Candlin, C. N. 379
capability 90, 156, 160, 161, 331, 380
capital, psychological 319, 320
capstone courses 212–214
Carless, D. 115
Carmichael, P. 44
categorical shift 228
certainty 476, 477
Chakrabarty, D. 75
change 6, 24, 33, 35–37, 194, 333–334, 415–416
conceptual 91, 226, 228, 236
hero’s journey and 141
long-term 180
Charmaz, K. 244
chemistry 80, 81, 234–237
Chi, M. T. 228
Chick, N. L. 172, 173
Chodron, P. 480
Choi, H. J. 335
Clark, I. 344
classics 82, 83
Coates, H. 212
cognition, hot 91, 98, 99
collaboration 114, 166, 402, 456
co-operative learning 159–161, 166, 167
employer-HEI 402
and graduate apprenticeships 454–464
group work 145, 146, 201, 384–386
in health professions 436, 437
interdisciplinary 92, 93, 269
with learners/students 49, 109, 270, 271, 344
in research 225, 229
in teacher development 416, 417
teacher-librarian 418, 419
Collaborative Online International Learning. Virtual Exchange
communities 77, 145, 146, 399, 400, 414, 415
communities of practice (CoPs) 31, 32, 49, 62
interprofessionality and 441, 442
MOOC s and 307, 308, 311, 312
vs. networks of practice 416
New-to-Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 171, 182, 183
competencies
assessment of 18, 19
in interpreting 359, 360, 363, 365, 366–371
learner/student judgment of 359–371, 365, 378–393, 400
for online learning 320
provocative 114, 115
threshold 284
complexity 96–97, 226, 361–362, 370–371, 393
epistemic 107, 109, 477–481
Conceição, S. 335
concepts
changes of 228
definitions 471, 472, 476, 477
integral (IC s) 478
learners and 18, 19
mapping 226, 229
process of acquisition of 19, 21, 22
transformation 19, 20
web of 226, 227
confidence, learner
increase of 163, 333, 334, 440, 441, 443, 447–449, 463
information literacy and 418, 428
lack of 164, 330
in liminality 111, 115, 122, 123, 145, 220, 221
secularism and 80, 81
trustworthiness and 380, 381, 384, 389
confidence, teacher 399, 400, 406
Conroy, J. C. 113
constructivism 175–178, 176
Continuing Professional Development. see professional development
co-operative learning 159–161, 166, 167
CoPs. see communities of practice
Corrall, S. 284, 420
counselling education 144, 145
counterintuitiveness. see troublesomeness
course/curriculum design 15–16, 181, 214–218
collaboration in 418–419, 422–423
for graduate apprenticeships 455–459
liminality and 155–157
secularism and 77–83
Cousin, G. 58, 95
on oscillation in liminality 115, 241
TC s teaching, work used in 215
transactional curriculum inquiry concept 46, 59–61
on transformation 335
on troublesomeness 161
Cove, M. 259
COVID-19 pandemic
blended learning in 307, 309, 319
doctoral students, impact on 142, 143, 151
and scholarly teaching development model 405–407
SoTL work in 172, 181, 183, 184
CPD. see professional development
Cranton, P. A. 397
creativity 80–81, 96–98, 135, 143, 147, 265, 266
Crichton, J. 379
Crilly, N. 114
criticality 78–81, 148, 151, 402
as TC 262, 264, 265, 265–268
Crookes, P. A. 45, 46
D’Amour, D. 450
data collection 45–46, 51, 261–262, 278, 438–439
focus groups 157, 229, 312
interviews 61, 157, 242–244, 262, 327, 381–382, 438–439
journal writing 327, 330, 381–382
learner discourse 242, 246–247
questionnaires 125–127, 135, 188–189, 260, 262, 283, 292–293
reflective writings 243–244, 278, 312
surveys 179, 188–190, 216, 312, 314–321
“thinking aloud” 347
Davies, J. P. 59
Davies, P. 18, 156, 226
Davis, B. 107
Davis, C. 361
Davis, R. 343, 344
Deci, E. L. 360, 362, 372
‘Decoding the Disciplines’ methodology 421–423, 425
decolonization 59, 307–312, 316
defamiliarization 109, 114, 115
defensiveness 46, 47, 49
degree apprenticeships 455
graduate apprentices/apprenticeships
Deleuze, G. 477
Delphi studies 20, 46, 50, 60, 428, 430
de Sousa Santos, B. 309, 310
De Swart, H. 275
De Villiers, M. 274, 275
Dewey, J. 113, 115
difference 73, 95, 310, 334–335, 462–463
individual 143, 263–266, 472–474
and methodology 22
difficulty. see troublesomeness
disciplinary epistemes 63, 64
disciplinary gaze 162
disciplines
liminality and 107–109
and positivist/constructivist paradigms 177, 178
sense of belonging to 163
and TC s conceptualization 43–45
TC s informed by 475
TC s variety in 58
and teacher identity 177, 178
traditions 65–67
discursiveness 337, 344–345
mathematical proving and 277, 281–283
mediating artefacts and 94, 99
TCFS, introduction to 241
trustworthiness and 379, 382, 392
discussion 156, 157, 167
about SoTL 174, 180
feedback through 402–406
of teaching 171, 172, 174, 180
distance learning 289, 290
diversity 79, 82, 310, 317, 334, 335, 480
D’Mello, S. 19
Doctorow, E. L. 338
Douglas, M. 83
Dunn, M. J. 476
Durkheim, E. 83
DuRose, L. 211
earth/environmental sciences 81, 82, 289, 290
Easdown, D. 273
economics education 155–157
EDI (equality, diversity and inclusion) 79, 82, 317
educational developers see academic/educational developers 10, 11, 32, 33
educational research field 60–63
Edwards, G. 19
Eliade, M. 123, 124
ELT. see English Language Teaching
Embedding Threshold Concepts (ETC) 156
employers 347–349, 351, 352, 454, 455
engagement
learner 19, 78, 79, 96, 144, 163, 164, 212
teacher 171, 172, 400
Engeström, R. 93
Engeström, Y. 93
English Language Teaching (ELT) 259–271, 307–312
‘native speaker’ ideal 311, 314
Entwistle, N. 16
epistemes, threshold 225, 227, 228, 230–237
epistemic shifts 19, 107
and self-determination theory 353, 361, 365, 371
student accounts of 149, 162, 212, 268
epistemic stance
in doctoral studies 140–145, 148–150
secularism and 73, 74
of teachers 145, 146
epistemic violence/epistemicide 59, 60, 67, 309
epistemology 18, 19, 58–68
complexity of 477, 478
disciplinary 416
vs. ontology 109, 112, 146, 147, 372
rupture of 331
and understanding 372
visibility of 309, 310
ePortfolios 343–353
equality 76, 77, 480
equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) 79, 82, 317
ETC (Embedding Threshold Concepts) 156
evidence 50–53, 50
excitement 116, 382–383
in adaptive cycle model 37
competency and 385, 386
in liminality 127, 127, 128, 132
in pre-liminality 330
exclusion 426, 428–430
expertise 17, 18, 23, 175, 400, 407, 416, 417, 419, 421, 422
Eynon, B. 345, 350, 351
facilitation, vs. teaching 157
faculty. see professional development ; see teachers
failure 3–14
constructions of 6, 7, 12
definition 5–7
fear of 385
identity and 7, 9–11
as ‘native informant’ 4, 5, 9–13
productive of learning 5, 10, 11
as TC 9, 10
Fanghanel, J. 399
fear 143, 459
of failure 143, 146, 385
liminality and 106, 109, 132, 459
overcoming 133, 330
student accounts of 132–133, 143, 330, 332, 383, 385
feedback 23
in group settings 144, 145
from learners/students 126, 127, 217, 218
from peers 388–390
from staff 152
through conference discussions 402–406
workplace 443
Felten, P. 48, 49, 258, 270, 271
Fetters, M. D. 51
Filiatrault, A. 352
Flanagan, M. T. 258, 472, 477
“flipped” classroom 167, 314
floating signifier problem 43, 45
focus groups 157, 229, 312
Folk, A. 426
Fortune, T. 44, 399, 436, 448, 449
Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education (ACRL) 412, 413, 417, 418, 427
Freire, P. 111
Freshwater, D. 51
Fricker, M. 68n4
Fuzzard, R. 436
Gadamer, H.-G. 111
Gale, T. 333
Gambino, L. M. 345, 350, 351
Garrison, J. 111, 112
Geiger, J.-M. 22
Gibbons, M. 112
Giesen, B. 108
Gilmore, A. 16
goals 35, 158, 159, 213, 214, 445
graduate apprentices/apprenticeships (GA) 454–464
graduate apprenticeship programmes (GAP s) 454, 458
Gray, J. 480
Gray, L. 344, 346
Green, J. H. 361
Griesemer, J. R. 92, 93
Grosslight, L. 230
group settings 76, 77, 83, 158–167
feedback in 144, 145
safety in 143, 144, 151, 152, 163
trustworthiness in 384, 385, 388, 389
group work 145, 146, 201, 384–386
Guattari, F. 477
Guba, E. G. 440
Gunderson, L. H. 35
Hanick, S. L. 350
Hanna, G. 274
Hardesty, L. 423
Harland, T. 399
Hartnell-Young, E. 344, 346
Harwood, W. 346
Hawkins, B. 19
health professions 435–450
liminality in 436, 437
TC s in 440–447
Hendrawati, R. 45
hero’s journey 140–142, 141, 147, 149–151
higher education (HE)
secularism and 73–77, 79, 80
transition to 329–331
value of 211–213, 218, 219
Hill, S. 436, 437
Hofer, A. R. 350
Holland, K. 436
Holling, C. S. 35
hooks, b. 111
Hopmann, S. 110
Hubert, D. 343
Hurlock, D. 436
Huston, T. 181
Hutchings, P. 178
Hyde, L. 111
IC s (integral concepts) 478
identification
consensus 60, 66
diversity of stakeholders’ voices in 58, 59, 61
shifts of 146, 147
identification problem 45–53
identity, learner/student
development of 361, 362
disciplinary 163
ePortfolios and 344, 345, 347, 349, 350
fragmented 388, 389
in liminality 333
online learning and 329, 333
in post-liminality 333, 334
shifts of 159, 165, 165, 166, 235, 241, 245–253, 333, 334
as TC 334–338
and work-based learning 456, 457
identity, professional
development of 121, 220–223
disciplinary 177, 178
ePortfolios and 347
failure and 7, 9–11
formation 241–243
in health professions 444–446
liminality and 108, 109
of researchers 174, 175, 181, 183, 184
shifts of 399, 400
of teachers 174, 175, 177, 178, 241, 399–400, 413–416
transition to 377–380, 387–390, 391, 436, 449
values and 181, 182
imposter syndrome 143, 399
inclusion 95, 426, 428, 429, 430
incommensurability 5, 58, 62
incorporation 106, 123, 137, 274, 275
individuality 15–17, 24, 76, 77, 83, 472–474
inequalities 60, 76, 77, 309, 310
information literacy (IL) 412–431
perceptions of 423, 426
skills 419, 420, 427–429
TC s in 412, 413, 419–422, 425
teacher development in 417, 422–430, 424, 425
information vs. transformation 9, 10
Initial Teacher Education (ITE) 225–237
innovation 79, 81
integral concepts (IC s) 478
integration 429
of knowledge 461
learner/student perception of 298
mathematical proving and 277, 281–283
online student identity and 337
of research methods 51, 52, 52
secularism and 72
interdisciplinarity 177, 178, 180, 181, 184, 189, 292
boundaries and 92, 227
and learning 213, 214
TC s mastery, support for 298–300, 299, 301
in teacher development 416, 417
value of 218
interiority 12
internationalization 311, 312
internationalization at home (IoH) 307, 310, 311, 319, 320
interpreting 359–373
competencies in 359, 360, 363, 365, 366–371
interprofessional education (IPE) 435, 436, 447, 448
interprofessionality 437, 438
as TC 440–449, 441
irreversibility 257, 406, 407
mathematical proving and 276, 277, 281–283
online student identity and 338
and scholarly teaching 403
secularism and 72
Irvine, N. 44
ITE. see Initial Teacher Education
Jacobson, H. 480
Jahnke, H. N. 274
James, A. 94
Jarrett, K. 115
Johnston, B. 423, 426
journeys 125, 382–390
hero’s 35, 140–142, 141, 147, 149–151
learner/student 109, 158, 158, 159
towards scholarly teaching 397, 400–402, 401, 404
Joyes, G. 344, 346
Juan, A. A. 460
Julien, H. 418
Kanuka, H. 396, 397
Kapur, M. 5
Kärkkäinen, M. 93
Kegan, Robert 3, 9, 10
Kelly, N. 398–400
Keymaker metaphor 110, 111
Kezar, A. 415, 416
Khan, S. 4, 11
Kinchin, I. 40, 226
Kiraly, D. 378
Knight, P. T. 17, 18
knowledge
abyssal lines in 309, 310, 321
acquisition 48, 49
complexity of 109
dissatisfaction with 99
diverse perspectives on 108
expert 23, 400, 407, 416, 417, 421, 422
lack of 386
Mode 1/Mode 2 (Gibbons) 112
pedagogy and 401, 402
reproduction, vs. construction 156
rupture of 331
tacit 420, 421, 428, 429
troublesome 187, 188, 198–202
unproblematic 81
knowledgeability 417
knowledge structures 47–49
Kolar, C. 437
Koopmans, M. 23, 24
Kreber, C. 397, 400
Kuh, G. 343
Kuhn, T. 47, 68n2
Kumar, V. 5–7
Kynigos, C. 93
labyrinths 124–126, 135, 136
Lacković, N. 477, 478
Land, R. 36, 187, 393
on boundaries 91–92
on discursiveness 241
TC s critiques, response to 475–481
TC s definitions 9, 12, 32, 186, 257–258, 276, 291, 345, 350, 413
on TC s as brand 30, 38
and TC s development 40, 213
TC s origins 155
TC s qualities 43
on troublesomeness 284, 350
landscapes 39, 40
landscapes of practice (LoPs) 31, 32, 417
language
conceptual discourse 94, 95
disciplinary 162
English 74, 75
learners/students, spoken by 164, 259–262, 315
pedagogical 398, 399
reducing demands of 99–101
terminology 226, 234, 235, 331
English Language Teaching ; interpreting
Lave, J. 416
leadership 442, 443
Leahy, R. L. 352
learner/student experience 17, 47–49, 215–220, 360, 362
affective 148, 149
of liminality 46, 47, 49, 90, 91, 108–111, 115, 137, 138, 146, 147
learners/students 188, 189, 242–245, 281, 403
adult/older 326–329
as co-creators 143
collaboration with 49, 109, 270, 271, 344
doctoral 140–142
empowering of 110, 111
first semester 121, 125–135
identification problem 45, 46
learner discourse 242, 246, 247
learning, perception of 368, 369
mathematical proving and 276, 278–283
in pre-liminality 142–145
TC s, identification of 226, 269, 270, 294–302, 295–297
TC s, narration of 448, 449
TC s, perception of 282, 283, 290–292
uncertainty tolerance 188
value of education, understanding of 211–213
autonomy ; identity, learner/student ; journeys ; motivation
learning
about learning 158, 159
context/environment for 360–362, 364, 369–372
evidence-informed 401
failure and 5, 10, 11
individual 15, 16, 472–474
informal 414, 415
and interdisciplinarity 213, 214
learner-centred 403
metaphors for 48, 49
mixed methods framework 46–53, 48
student-directed 360
of teachers 397
transformative 212
work-based 455–457
project-based learning
learning bottlenecks 346, 351, 352, 421, 422, 425
learning models 114, 401
learning outcomes 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 213, 214, 216–218, 220, 221
learning preconditions 15, 17, 18, 21–22
learning processes 17, 19, 21
learning strategies 196, 197, 196, 200, 201
Lee, N. 212
Lehman, R. M. 335
Leidl, D. M. 436, 448
Lester, J. 415, 416
Lewis, L. 346
librarians and librarianship 413, 418–420, 427
Light, G. 241
liminality
assessment and 23, 24
and concept transformation 19, 20
definitions 106, 107, 112, 122
disciplines and 107–109, 177, 178
embracing 93, 94, 178, 179, 179
embracing liminality as TC 179, 182
in healthcare education 436, 437
and identity 108, 109, 336
and information literacy 420, 421
learner/student experience of 46, 47, 49, 90, 91, 108–111, 115, 137, 138, 146, 147
learner/student understanding of 220, 221
localization of 21, 22
meaning-making and 122, 123, 138
mediating artefacts and 89, 90, 94–101, 97
of online space 329–331
oscillation in 16, 19, 90, 108, 149, 175, 241
pedagogy of 91, 96, 113, 114, 122, 123
peer learning and 160, 161, 400
post-liminality 90, 149–151, 331–334
pre-liminality 89, 90, 142, 146, 329, 330
reflectiveneness and 421, 422
and scholarly teaching 241, 397–399, 402, 403
scholarship on 53
in simultaneities 107–109
space of 112, 123–125, 136, 137, 137
spatial patterns of 121, 122, 125–138
survival strategies for 332
teacher experience of 147–149, 171, 172, 175–177
teaching in 109–12, 115, 116
thinking with 107, 111, 112
transition to HE and 330, 331
in translator education 378, 379, 385, 386
troublesomeness of 89–91
trustworthiness and 382, 383
uncertainty and 188, 199
value of 39
Lincoln, Y. S. 440
literacy 234, 235
digital 312
media 364, 366, 368–372
information literacy
Lithgow, K. 350
lockdowns 142, 143
LoPs. see landscapes of practice
Loton, D. J. 212
Lotter, C. 346
Lucas, U. 46
Macfarlane, B. 31
Mac Giolla Rí, D. 477, 478
Male, S. A. 44
Malesic, J. 184
Mangan, J. 156
Marquis, E. 398, 399
Mårtensson, K. 415
Martin, J. M. 212
Martindale, L. 436, 448
Marton, F. 17, 438
Marx, R. W. 91
Massive Open Online Courses (MOOC s) 307–309, 311, 312, 314
Masuzawa, Tomoko 73
mathematics 235, 273–284, 457, 458–464
Matsumoto, Y. 399
mazes 124–126, 135, 136
McClurg, C. 419, 420
McCormick, R. 48, 49
McGuinness, C. 426
McGuire, S. Y. 212
Mckenzie, J. A. 399, 400
McLean, N. 400
McTighe, J. 420
meaning-making 7, 122, 123, 138, 160, 161, 211
media literacy 364, 366, 368, 372
medical education 108
mental health 142, 143
mentoring 414–416
Mesirow, J. 420
metacognition 212, 213, 414
metaphors
ambiguity of 29, 30, 39
labyrinths 124
for learning 48, 49
rhizomes 477, 478
for teaching 479, 479
of thresholds 333
methodology. see research methodology
Meulemans, Y. N. 213
Meyer, J. H. F. 187, 476
on boundaries 91–92
on discursiveness 241
TC s critiques, response to 471–474
TC s definitions 9, 12, 32, 186, 257–258, 276, 291, 345, 413
and TC s development 40, 213
TC s origins 155
TC s qualities 43
on transformation 335
on troublesomeness 284, 350
Mezirow, J. 140
Michell, M. 162
Middendorf, J. 346, 421, 422
Miller, S. D. 421, 422
mimicry 95, 173, 179, 235, 318, 385, 447
Mladenovic, R. 46
models 230–233
learning 114
mental 228
Molina-Azorin, J. F. 51
MOOC s. see Massive Open Online Courses
Moorhouse, B. L. 320
Moroney, D. 259
motivating questions 47, 47
motivation 91, 328, 329, 362, 363, 363
Mueller, R. 344, 345, 352
multiculturality 311, 312, 316
multidisciplinarity 192
Murphy, G. 476
networks of practice 414–416
Neve, H. 437, 448
Ney, S. 83
Nicola-Richmond, K. 45, 436, 437
Nolan, M. 114
Novak, J. D. 228
numeracy 235
Oandason, I. 450
objectivity 65, 76
O’Donnell, R. M. 43, 53, 476
O’Leary, M. 346
Olsen, Bjørnar 124
Oman 259–262
online learning 289, 290, 292, 307–321
engagement and 144
learner critique of 317, 319
learner/student identity and 329–333
liminality in 329–331
and peer learning 151
synchronous/asynchronous 314
as TC 334–338
teaching, impact on 405, 406
transitions into 326–338
troublesomeness and 317, 319, 321
Massive Open Online Courses ; Virtual Exchange
ontological shifts 19, 24, 478, 479
in health professions 437, 446, 447
and self-determination theory 353, 361, 365, 371
student accounts of 162, 268
ontological stance 143–149
ontology 18, 19, 112, 146, 147, 372
Orsini-Jones, M. C. 259
Orwell, G. 480
oscillation, liminal 16, 19, 90, 108, 149, 175, 241
Osmond, J. 380
otherness 479
outcomes
learning 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 213, 214, 216–218, 220, 221
personal 35, 158, 159
Pace, D. 346, 421, 422
Pang, M. F. 17
Park, E. J. 241
Park, J.-H. 335
Parker, S. 333
Park Nelson, F. 4, 11, 12
partnership. see collaboration
Patton, M. Q. 35, 36
Peachey, A. 335
pedagogy
and affect 98–100
boundary objects and 92, 94
of capstone courses 212–213
collaborative 166
co-operative learning 159–161, 166, 167
critical reflection on 402
and disciplinary knowledge 401, 402
of ePortfolios 346, 350–352
knowledge and 401, 402
language of 398, 399
learning/teaching orientations 363, 364
of liminality 91, 96, 113, 114, 122, 123
motivation and 362
and online learning 405, 406
of the question 67, 68
recognized approaches 401
reflective 202, 402
of risk 111
semiotic 96
of trustworthiness 393
of uncertainty tolerance 189, 198, 202
peer learning 160–164, 166, 167, 414–417
Pelnar, H. 346
performance 5, 360, 366, 376
Perkins, D. 64, 215, 475
Perrenet, J. 283, 291, 292
Peseta, T. 59
phenomena 18, 20, 21, 22, 23, 35, 36
physics 231–235, 289–291
Pintrich, P. R. 91
positivism 175–178, 176, 476
pre-concepts 19
presumptions, tacit 421
productivity, lack of 95, 96
professional development
collaboration in 416, 417
in doctoral studies 140–142
for ePortfolio use 350, 351
on information literacy 413, 417, 422–430, 424, 425
interdisciplinarity in 416, 417
liminality and 108, 109
in SoTL 172–177
TC s, utility in 220, 221
professional identity. see identity, professional
project-based learning 377–379
authentic project method 377–379, 381–390, 391
proof 74–75
proving, mathematical 273–284, 280
purpose 348–350
Quality Assurance Agency (QAA), Subject Benchmark Statements (SBS) 77–83
Quinlan, K. M. 44, 49
randomness 233, 234
Rattray, J. 17, 253
Reale, M. 420
realism
critical 148
naive 145, 147
‘real-world’ projects 156, 212, 378, 379, 381–390, 391
‘real-world’ questions 158, 162, 187, 188, 201
reconstitution 72, 241, 258, 337
Reeping, D. 43, 44
reflectiveneness 46, 47, 47, 49, 81, 93, 94, 462
‘Decoding the Disciplines’ methodology 421–423
in ELT education 312
ePortfolios and 348, 349
in information literacy 420
in learners/students 147, 211–213, 243, 244
in mathematics 461–463
metareflection 310
pedagogic 202, 402
of teachers 236, 397, 403, 407
troublesomeness of 308
uncertainty tolerance and 188
reflexivity 140, 150, 151, 189, 403
religion 73, 75, 76, 78–80
religious studies 78–80
research methodology 247, 248, 277, 278, 364–366
action research 311–315
bracketing 438
content analysis 61
integration of 51, 52, 52
Interactive Qualitative Analysis (IQA) 157–159
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) 327, 328
jazz 114, 115
phenomenography 49, 58, 61, 62, 437–440, 440
positionality 438
qualitative analysis 189, 244, 245, 278, 293, 294, 312
quantitative analysis 189, 293, 294, 312
rhizomatic analysis 477, 478
for SoTL 178, 179
Systems Influence Diagram (SID) 158, 158, 159, 166
Transactional Curriculum Inquiry (Cousin) 58, 60–62
transparency 45, 46
data collection ; evidence
resilience 90, 320, 334
Riley, D. 30
Ring, G. L. 343
Risjord, M. 407
rites 106, 110
of passage 123–125, 137
Rock, F. E. 379
Rodger, S. 44
Ross, P. M. 227, 236
Rowbottom, D. P. 45, 301, 476
Rowland, S. 77
Roxå, T. 415
Ryan, R. M. 360, 362, 372
safety 143, 144, 150–152, 163
Salwén, H. 45, 53
Sankofa (Adinkra symbol) 479, 479
Saudi Arabia 381
Savin-Baden, M. 40, 46, 47, 53, 115, 332, 426
scale 232, 233
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) 171–184, 396, 397, 399, 419
institutional support for 182, 183
SoTL in Action workbook 174–177, 181, 182
TC s and 173, 174, 402
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) in Action Program 172, 173
Scholtz, K. 350
Schön, D. A. 420
Schwartzman, L. 46, 47, 53, 122, 123, 138, 310, 328, 331
science education
biology 226, 227, 234, 235
chemistry 80, 81, 234, 235
earth/environmental sciences 81, 82, 225–237, 289, 290
medical education 108
physics 231–235, 289–291
Scully, D. 346
secularism 72–84
challenges to 82, 83
characteristics of 76, 77
in QAA Subject Benchmark Statements (SBS) 77–83
in universities 73–77
valorization of 79, 80
secularization 73, 74
Seeber, B. K. 171
Seleskovitch, D. 363, 364
self, shifts of 146, 147, 161, 162, 258
self-awareness 151
self-belief 333, 334
self-determination theory (SDT) 360, 362–364, 363
self-doubt 161
Semetsky, I. 477
Sender, T. 22
separation 106, 123, 137, 142, 436, 450
Serbanescu, R. 291
Sfard, A. 48, 49
Sfintes, A. I. 124
Shinners-Kennedy, D. 301, 302
Shklovsky, V. 114
Shopkow, L. 421
Shulman, L. S. 4, 108, 413, 414
Simmons, N. 174, 175
simultaneities 107–109
situatedness 58–61, 66, 67
skills
information literacy 419, 420, 427–429
threshold 276, 277, 283, 284
Skjoldager-Nilsen, K. 106
space
landscapes of TC s 31–33
liminal 112, 123–125, 136, 137, 137
online 334, 335
real 335
ritual 123–125
sacred/spiritual 123, 124
strategic terrains 32, 33
Third Space 307, 308, 310, 311
spatiality patterns in liminality 125–137
Springfield, E. A. 437
Stacey, G. 437
staff. see teachers
staff-student ratios 148
Star, S. L. 92, 93
Stebelton, M. J. 211
Sterk, H. 291, 292
Stewart, M. 399
Stopford, R. 360, 476
strangemaking 109, 114, 115
Strawser, M. G. 212
Strunk, G. 22
stuckness 47, 95, 96, 110, 163–165, 176, 241, 332
student experience. see learner/student experience
students. see learners/students
Subject Benchmark Statements (SBS). see Quality Assurance Agency
subjectivity 15–17, 62–65, 72
Sutherland, K. A. 5, 6, 9–11
Szakolczai, Arpad 106, 110, 112
taxonomy, learning 175, 176
Taylor, C. E. 226, 234, 236, 237
TCF s. see threshold concepts frameworks
TC s. see threshold concepts
TCPh. see threshold concepts phenomenon
teacher education 241–253, 245
ELT 259–271, 307–312
online learning competencies 320
in science disciplines 225–237
teachers
affect and 42, 148, 149
burnout 171, 172, 180
ePortfolios and 347–352
isolation of 42, 413, 414
in liminality 109–112, 115, 116, 147–149
in pre-liminality 145, 146
professional identity 174, 175, 177, 178, 241, 399, 400, 413–416
reflectiveneness of 236, 397, 403, 407
scholarly 396–408, 401, 404
workload 171, 172, 179, 180
professional development
teaching
alterity/otherness in 479
classroom management 262, 263, 264, 265, 265–268, 266
constraints on 479, 480
evidence-informed 401
vs. facilitation 157
learner-centred 401–403
methods 262, 263, 265, 265–268
mixed methods framework 46–53, 48
online learning, impact on 405, 406
presence 246
recognized approaches 401
research-informed 397
restrained 110
staff (non)-discussion of 171, 172, 174, 180
strategies for 350
student-centred instruction 246, 248–252
uncertainty tolerance, developed by 188, 195–198, 196, 200, 201
teamwork 108, 442, 443, 445, 446
technology
in English language teaching 317, 318, 318
learning bottlenecks 346, 347, 351, 352
and mathematics teaching 460–462, 461, 462
information literacy ; online learning
telecollaboration. see Virtual Exchange
temporality 33–35
cyclicality 35–37
of liminality 112
time, lack of 171, 178, 180
testimonial injustice 59, 60
theology/religious studies 78–80
Thomassen, B. 105–107, 124
Thompson, R. 162
threshold capabilities 48
threshold competences 284
threshold concepts (TC s)
abstract ideas as 227
adaptive cycles and 35
antagonistic 64, 65
characteristics of 22, 23, 187, 188, 240, 241, 406, 407
context-oriented 268, 269
critique of 43–45, 292, 301, 471–474, 476, 477
definitions 4, 5, 11–13, 43, 44, 257–259, 428, 429, 472, 473
dynamic 268, 269
ePortfolios and 345–351
experiential 334–338
first- and second-order typology 58, 66, 67
general vs. individual 300
identification 59–61, 66, 140, 141, 245–253, 262–266, 263, 264, 265
learner/student identification of 226, 269, 270, 294–302, 295, 296, 297
learner/student perception of 282, 283, 290–292
mapping 31
metadisciplinary 74
models of 372
pan-disciplinary 83
potential 30, 31
representation of 94, 95
resilience 39
in scholarly teaching 397–399, 401, 404
in science disciplines 225–228
student-centred instruction 246, 248–252
as TC 217, 236
and teacher identity formation 414
troublesome effect of 19, 21, 22
trustworthiness as 379–381, 392, 393
uncertainty and 187, 188, 198, 199
threshold concepts frameworks (TCF s) 30, 31, 39, 122, 123, 334, 335
adaptive cycles and 35
boundaries in 91, 92
as brand 38
critique of 236
learner/student understanding of 214–217
learners/students taught to use 211–223
non-linearity of 448
potential 39, 40
utility of 218, 221
threshold concepts phenomenon (TCPh) 29–31, 35, 37–40
threshold connections 237
Threshold Connections Project 228, 229
threshold epistemes 225, 227, 228, 230–237
‘threshold rhizome’ (TR) 477, 478
thresholds
as architectural space 124, 125
internet devices as 335
location of 12
metaphors of 29, 30, 333
threshold skills 276, 277, 283, 284
Tierney, A. M. 398, 399, 401, 439
TILT. see Transparency in Learning and Teaching
time. see temporality
timescapes 33–35
Timmermans, J. A. 5–7, 9–11, 40, 93
Tippett, M. 480
Todd, S. 479
Townsend, L. 350, 428
transdisciplinarity 246, 422, 427, 429
transformation 15, 16, 105, 114, 258, 259, 366, 367, 376
and affect 91
cognitive 159–161, 165, 166, 165
of concepts 19, 20
definitions 212
dimensions of 159–166, 165
vs. information 9, 10
interprofessionality and 447–449
learner/student perception of 293, 295, 296, 298
and liminality 105
mathematical proving and 276, 277, 279, 281–283
metacognitive 159, 160, 165, 165, 166
online student identity and 333–335, 336
in post-liminal phase 90
process of 146, 165, 165, 166
professional identity and 121
reading and 219, 220
secularism and 72–74
study of 24, 44
in teacher education 267, 268
unexpected 68
transformativeness 58, 65–68
transitions
assessment of 16
into HE 329–331
of identity 377–380, 387–390, 391, 436, 449
into online learning 326–338
into post-liminal stage 333
rites of passage and 123, 137
threshold 16
translator education 377–393, 391
authentic project method 378, 379, 381–390
liminality in 378, 379
trustworthiness and 379–393
Transparency in Learning and Teaching (TILT) framework 422, 423
trickster figure 110, 111
Tronson, D. A. 236
troublesomeness 47, 216, 217, 258, 259, 277, 281, 480
affect and 241
artefacts, mediated by 94–101
in authentic projects 385, 386
comfort with 151
criticality as 266–268
digital technology and 317, 318, 318
in health professions 441, 442
and information literacy 413, 428–430
of interprofessionality 447, 448
of knowledge 187, 188, 198–202
learner/student perception of 295, 296
mathematical proving and 279, 282, 283
online learning and 317, 321, 336
of reflectiveneness 308
and scholarly teaching 397–399, 403–405, 404
scholarship on 44, 53
and simultaneities 108–109
of TC s 19, 21, 22
in teacher education 266, 267, 308
‘threshold rhizome’ and 478
value of 39
trust 150, 151, 379
loss of 380, 392, 393
professionalism and 443, 444
trustworthiness 379–381, 382–393, 391
in group settings 384, 385, 388, 389
learner/student judgment of 382, 383
in research 440
truth 275, 479
truth claims 73, 77, 79, 231, 232
Tse, C. 350
Turner, V. 109, 110, 137
liminality definition 106, 112, 122, 332
pre-liminality definition 329
Turpin, M. 44
tutorials 156–159, 161, 163–167
uncertainty 187–203, 477
acceptance of 194, 199, 200, 200
in COVID-19 pandemic 405
experimental 291
in health professions 437
human element 189, 190, 191, 199, 200
intellectualization 192, 193, 193
moderation of 192–194
in online learning 329–334
operationalization 193, 194, 199, 200, 200, 202
predictive modelling 193, 194, 199, 200, 200
in science disciplines 233, 234
sectoral management, variation in 199, 200, 200, 201, 202
TC s, characteristic of 187, 188
and troublesome knowledge 198–202
trust and 380, 381
in workplace 188, 189–194, 199, 200, 200
uncertainty tolerance (UT) 187–189
‘underlying game’ concept 215–217
understanding 160, 161
contextual 368–370
and epistemology 372
limitations of 372
refusal of challenge to 478, 479
sympathetic 78–80
universities/higher education institutions (HEI s)
employer collaborations 402
and graduate apprenticeships 454–458
secularism and 73–77
and teacher identity formation 414–416
vagueness 471, 472, 474
value
of education 211–213, 218, 219
professional 443, 444
values 39, 40, 164, 165
failure and 8–10
teaching 181–184
Van Asch, B. 275
Van Dalen, D. 275
van Gennep, A. 105, 106, 109, 122, 123, 137, 329
Van-Gulik-Gulikers, I. 275
Van Hiele, P. 284
van Lankveld, T. 414
variation in learning 472–474
VE. see Virtual Exchange
verbalization 160, 161, 167
Virtual Exchange (VE) 307–311, 317, 318, 320, 321
visual arts 95–97
visualization 230, 233
Vogler, C. 141, 147, 149, 150, 150
Vygotsky, L. S. 147, 148, 160, 162
Watson, C. E. 344
WBL (work-based learning) 455–457
Webb, A. S. 173–175, 178
Webber, S. 423, 426
Webster-Wright, A. 415
Weller, S. 398, 399
Wenger-Trayner, B. 32, 33, 417
Wenger-Trayner, E. 31–33, 393, 416, 417
Westley, Frances 35
Westphal, M. 479
White, B. A. 48, 49
Wiggins, G. 420
Winkelmes, M. 423
work-based learning (WBL) 455–457
Wright, A. L. 16
Zwaneveld, B. 283, 291, 292

Citation Info

  • Save
  • Cite
  • Email this content

    Share link with colleague or librarian


    You can email a link to this page to a colleague or librarian:
    Email this content
    or copy the link directly:
    The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
    Link copied successfully

  • Collapse
  • Expand

Threshold Concepts in the Moment

Series:  Educational Futures, Volume: 77
Cover Threshold Concepts in the Moment
E-Book ISBN:
9789004680661
Publisher:
Brill
Print Publication Date:
18 Apr 2024
  • Subjects
    • Education
      • General
Front Matter
Preliminary Material
Copyright page
Dedication
Foreword
Preface
Acknowledgements
A Tribute to Mick Flanagan
List of Figures and Tables
Part 1 Big Questions
Chapter 1 Failure as a ‘Native Informant’
Chapter 2 Assessment of Student Learning in Threshold Concepts-Oriented Teaching and Learning
Chapter 3 Threshold Concepts – Where Next?
Chapter 4 Intersecting the Identification Problem and Mixed Methods Designs in Threshold Concept Research
Chapter 5 Reframing Threshold Concepts as Open Questions
Chapter 6 Secularism as a Universalising Threshold Concept
Part 2 Journeys through Liminality
Chapter 7 Mediating Liminality
Chapter 8 Thinking with Liminality
Chapter 9 Spatial Response to Liminality
Chapter 10 Step into the Unknown
Chapter 11 Liminality from the Inside
Chapter 12 Embracing Liminality
Chapter 13 The Human Element
Part 3 Learning from & with Students
Chapter 14 Developing a Threshold Concept Curriculum
Chapter 15 Threshold Connections
Chapter 16 Analyzing Written and Oral Learner Discourse
Chapter 17 The True Nature of Threshold Concepts in ELT Teacher Education
Chapter 18 Mathematical Proving as a Threshold
Chapter 19 Threshold Concepts in Higher Education Physics as Identified by Students of Environmental Sciences
Part 4 Students Getting the Hang of It
Chapter 20 Out of the Comfort Zone
Chapter 21 The Light at the End of the Tunnel
Chapter 22 Applying Threshold Concepts and Addressing Bottlenecks in ePortfolio Implementation
Part 5 Becoming a Professional
Chapter 23 The Hidden Threshold
Chapter 24 Trustworthiness as a Practical Threshold in Authentic Translation Project-Based Learning
Chapter 25 Thresholds and Liminal Spaces
Chapter 26 Faculty Thresholds for Information Literacy Teaching
Chapter 27 A Phenomenographic Study of Interprofessionality
Chapter 28 Threshold Concepts in Graduate Apprenticeships
Part 6 The Last Word?
Chapter 29 Twaddle, Conformity, and Variation
Chapter 30 Getting into Trouble
Back Matter
Notes on Contributors
Index

Metrics

All Time Past 365 days Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 31 7 2
PDF Views & Downloads 0 0 0

Product Information

Books

Journals

Specialty Products

Metadata: Title Lists, MARC & KBART Files

Catalogs, Flyers & Price Lists

Accessing Brill Products

Authors

Becoming a Brill Author

Publishing Ethics & AI Policy

Publishing Guides

Contact & Info

Sales Contacts

Ordering

Editorial Contacts

Press & Reviews

Contact Form

Stay Updated

Blog

News Archive

Newsletters

Social Media Overview

Investors

Resources Center

General Resources

For Authors

For Librarians

Rights & Permissions

FAQ

Terms and Conditions 

Privacy Statement 

Cookie Settings 

Accessibility

Legal Notice

Sitemap

Terms and Conditions  |  Privacy Statement  |  Cookie Settings |  Accessibility  |  Legal Notice  |  Sitemap  |  Copyright © 2016-2026

 

 

Access via:
Dar Hadith al Hassania
Powered by PubFactory
  • [216.73.216.78|92.112.192.157]
  • 92.112.192.157
Close
Edit Annotation

Character limit 500/500

@!

Character limit 500/500