Henry Longueville Mansel (1820-1871), Anglican theologian and philosopher, has wrongly been remembered as a Kantian agnostic whose ideas led to those of Herbert Spencer. Francesca Normanâs book provides a thorough revisioning of Manselâs theology in context and reveals the personal basis of Spencerâs animus towards Mansel. Mansel is revealed as an orthodox Anglican theistic personalist whose ideas inspired Newman to write his Grammar of Assent. Located in context, Manselâs personal connections with leading Tory figures such as Lord Carnarvon and Benjamin Disraeli are explored. Key controversies with Frederick Denison Maurice and John Stuart Mill are interpreted with reference to the party political elections of 1859 and 1865. Norman offers a vital vision of nineteenth-century theology, philosophy, and politics.
Francesca Norman, Ph.D., studied Theology and completed her doctoral thesis on Mansel at Canterbury Christ Church University in 2015. She is an Anglican and has keen interests in the history of the Church of England.
2 Manselâs Theological and Philosophical Ideas in Context: Biographical Account of Manselâs Life and Work
â1âIntroduction
â2âFamily Background
â3âHerbert Spencer and Katherine Mansel
â4âLife at Oxford
â5âDean of St Paulâs
â6âConclusion
3 Manselâs Theological and Philosophical Ideas in Context: The Historical Roots of Manselâs Thought
â1âIntroduction
â2âBishop Peter Browne (c.1665â1735)
â3âBishop Joseph Butler (1692â1752)
â4âThomas Reid (1710â1796)
â5âFriedrich Heinrich Jacobi (1743â1819)
â6âSir William Hamilton (1788â1856)
â7âConclusion
4 The Content of Manselâs Philosophical Theology
â1âIntroduction
â2âTheistic Personalism
â3ââI-Thouâ
â4âFree Will
â5âNegative Theology and Analogy
â6âPrayer
â7âPersonal Relation
â8âTheory of Relativity
â9âRejection of the Absolute
â10âLimits of Ethical Knowledge
â11âConclusion
5 Manselâs Theological and Philosophical Ideas in Context: Initial Reception
â1âIntroduction
â2âPositive Responses (Oxford Tories and Alexander Campbell Fraser)
â3âPost-Tractarian and Roman Catholic Responses (William George Ward and John Henry Newman)
â4âReception by âAgnosticsâ (Herbert Spencer and Thomas Henry Huxley)
â5âMetaphysical and Idealist Reactions to Mansel
â6âConclusion
6 Mansel, Political Networks and Personalities
â1âIntroduction
â2âManselâs Religious Politics: Anglican Toryism
â3âLord Carnarvon
â4âGathorne Hardy
â5âSalisbury
â6âConclusion
7 The 1859 Election and the Maurice Controversy
â1âIntroduction
â2âThe Context of the 1859 Election
â3âThe Mansel-Maurice Controversy in Political Context
â4âOutline of a Controversy
â5âMaurice and the Carlylean Doctrine of Certainty
â6âConclusion
8 The 1865 Election and the Mill Controversy
â1âIntroduction
â2âAfter 1859: Gladstone and the Liberal Party
â3âThe Mansel-Mill Controversy in Political Context
â4âOutline of a Controversy
â5âMill and the Comtean Religion of Humanity
â6âConclusion
9 Conclusion
â1âKey Findings
â2âA Reputation Sidelined
â3âSt Peterâs and St Paulâs, Cosgrove
Appendix: Literature Survey
â1âIntroduction
â2âVictorian Biographical Studies
â3âLiterature on Mansel and the Agnostic Tradition
â4âMansel, Kierkegaard and Barth
â5âConclusion
Bibliography
All interested in key thinkers such as Herbert Spencer, Frederick Denison Maurice, John Stuart Mill, and John Henry Newman, and anyone interested in Victorian theology, philosophy, and politics.