Paul's inconsistency on the Jewish law is a persistent scholarly problem. He can argue vociferously against circumcision but also acknowledge its potential benefit. He expresses pride in his ancestral law and practices, but also describes them in terms of slavery, curses, and rubbish. What are we to make of this? In this volume, Annalisa Phillips Wilson offers a fresh approach. Her comparison of Paul's texts with Stoic ethical reasoning demonstrates that his discourse on Jewish practices reflects Stoic discourse patterns on neutral selections and activities, discourse designed to establish one category of incommensurable worth.
Annalisa Phillips Wilson, PhD (2021), Durham University, is currently based in London, where she teaches on the New Testament as an adjunct and is continuing comparative research on Pauline texts and ancient philosophical ethics.
"... das Buch ist in ihrer Grundthese überzeugend. Die vergleichende Analyse erhellt die Argumentation des Paulus und macht sie in einem antiken Kontext verständlich." - Stefan Krauter, Zürich, in: Theologische Literaturzeitung 148 (2023) 6
Acknowledgements Abbreviations
1 Introduction
â1âEuthydemus: Socrates and the Stoics
â2âPauline Inconsistency
â3âApproaching Methodology
â4âA Working Methodology
â5âReview of Literature on Paul and Stoicism
â6âA Guide to What Follows
Part 1: Two Patterns of Discourse in Stoic Ethical Reasoning
2 The Intermediates in Stoic Ethical Reasoning
â1âThe ΤÎÎ»Î¿Ï and Virtue
â2âThe Intermediates: The Topoi of the Preferred á¼Î´Î¹Î¬ÏοÏα and the ÎαθήκονÏα
â3âThe Relationship between Virtue and the Intermediates
â4âStoic Social and Political Theory: The Intermediates in Context
â5âConclusion to Stoic Ethics
3 Interlude: Mapping Paulâs Structure Alongside a Stoic Framework
Part 2: Two Patterns of Discourse in Pauline Ethical Reasoning
4 Paulâs First Pattern of Discourse: Establishing the First-Order Value of the Christ-Orientation
â1âIntroduction
â2âPhilippians 3.1â4.1
â3âGalatians 2.1â21
â4âConclusion
5 Paulâs Second Pattern of Discourse: Assessing and Selecting Intermediates in 1 Corinthians 8.1â11.1
â1âIntroduction
â2âPreliminary Matters
â3â1 Corinthians 8.1â11.1
â4âConclusion
6 Conclusion
â1âSummary of the Comparative Argument
â2âThe Application of the Comparison to Stoicism
â3âThe Application of the Argument to Other Pauline Texts
â4âConcluding Thoughts
Bibliography Index of Ancient Sources Index of Subjects
This book will be of interest to academic departments engaged in religious studies, biblical studies, classics, theology, and ethics. It would be of use in libraries associated with these departments or in universities and theological colleges with courses in these fields. Specialists and postgraduates in Pauline studies, ancient Stoicism, and ancient ethics will find this book of interest as would some clergy and authors engaged in the interpretation of Pauline texts in an ecclesial and pastoral context.