This volume provides a set of in-depth case studies about the role of questions and answers (Q&A) in ancient Greek medical writing from its Hippocratic beginnings up to, and including, Late Antiquity. The use of Q&A formulas is widely attested in ancient Greek medical texts, casting an intriguing light on its relevance for the medical art at large, and for ancient medical practice, education, and research in specific (diagnostics, didactics, dialectics). The book aims to break new grounds by exploring, for the first time, the wide complexity of this phenomenon while introducing a coherent approach. In so doing, it not only covers highly specialized medical treatises but also non-canonical authors and texts, including anonymous papyrus fragments and collections of problems.
"The volume provides excellent coverage of the medical papyri and problemata-style texts, with essays on audience, genre, logic, structure and text-critical and papyrological issues cohering closely together. (...) It is generally successful in its aim to use Q&A as a springboard to provide unexpected âwindowsâ onto wider cultural, philosophical, and textual features of ancient medicine. It will certainly be of interest and use not only to those working on ancient medicine more generally but also to scholars interested in wide-angled approaches to genre. It is a well-produced book with a thorough index."
Claire Hall in BMCR 2021.06.41
Acknowledgements Notes on Contributors
Ancient Greek Medicine in Questions and Answers: A Short Introduction
âMichiel Meeusen
2 Peripatetic and Hippocratic Seeds in Pseudo-Aristotle, Problemata 4: Raising Questions about Aristotleâs Rejection of the Pangenesis Theory of Generation
âRobert Mayhew
3 Author(s) and Reader(s) in the Supplementary Problems (Supplementa Problematorum)
âKaterina Oikonomopoulou
4 Ps.-Alexander of Aphrodisias on Unsayable Properties in Medical Puzzles and Natural Problems
âMichiel Meeusen
5 Erotetic Logic, Uncertainty and Therapy: Galen and Alexander on Logic and Medicine
âLuca Gili