Pastoralists, ranchers of European descent, conservationists, smallholders, and land investors with political influence converge on the Laikipia plateau in Kenya. Land is claimed by all - the tactics differ. Private property rights are presented, histories of presence are told, charges of immorality are applied, fences are electrified and some resort to violence. The region, marked by enclosures, is left as a tense fragmented frontier.
Marie Gravesen embedded herself in the region prior to a wave of land invasions that swept the plateau leading up to Kenyaâs 2017 general election. Through a rich telling of the history of Laikipiaâs social, political and environmental dynamics, she invites a deeper understanding of the pre-election violence and general tensions as never done before.
The manuscript is a revised version of the author's dissertation accepted by the Faculty of Arts and Humanities at the University of Cologne in 2018.
Marie Ladekjær Gravesen, Ph.D., Cologne University, is a researcher at the Danish Institute for International Studies (DIIS). Historically and anthropologically, her work addresses land contestations, enclosures, social-ecological dynamics and adaptation in East- and West Africa.
Laikipia has seen more violence than any part of Kenya over the past 30 years. Marie Gravesen here tells us why. Political claim-making, ethnic mobilisation, and land invasions set the terms of Laikipiaâs struggles, in a context marked by resource competition and diminishing livelihoods. Patient fieldwork and evocative story-telling brings Laikipiaâs communities to life in this excellent book, but we also learn why the situation is unlikely to improve any time soon. This is by far the best recent study of Kenyaâs violent local politics.
David M Anderson, Professor of African History, University of Warwick
Acknowledgements List of Figures and Tables
1 Introduction
â1.1 The State of Emergency in Laikipia, 2016â17
â1.2 Organisation of Chapters
2 Setting and Thematic Components
â2.1 Setting the Scene
â2.2 Notes on the Sensitivity to Voices in a Fragmented Setting
â2.3 Case Selection and Ecological Overview
â2.4 Thematic Components
ââ2.4.1 Contested Lands
ââ2.4.2 Ethnicity and Autochthony
ââ2.4.3 Fragmentation and Frontiers
ââ2.4.4 Commons and Customary Resources
ââ2.4.5 Plural Perspectives on Sustainable Land Management
â2.5 Concluding Remarks
3 Macro Perspectives: A History of Laikipiaâs Contested Lands
â3.1 Laikipia in the Nineteenth Century
â3.2 Colonial Rule in Laikipia
ââ3.2.1 The Kenya Land Commission, 1932â34
ââ3.2.2 The Land Commission Questions
ââ3.2.3 The African Reaction
ââ3.2.4 The Emergent Urban Population and Trade
â3.3 Independence Politics and the Repercussions of the Mau Mau
ââ3.3.1 Pre-independence Mobility
ââ3.3.2 Transition of Power and Land
ââ3.3.3 Post-independence Politics
ââ3.3.4 Land Reform and Resettlement Schemes
â3.4 Post-colonial Land: Times of Autochthony
ââ3.4.1 Immigration and Land-use Fragmentation
ââ3.4.2 Violence and Political Instrumentalism
â3.5 Concluding Remarks
4 Blaming the Others: Ethnic Identity and Claim-making
â4.1 Historical Grievances
ââ4.1.1 Present-day Grievances: Land, Ethnicity and Politics
â4.2 Meta-Narratives of Claims and Their Repercussions in Lorien
â4.3 Discursive Claims to Land
ââ4.3.1 The Pastoralists
ââ4.3.2 The Smallholders
ââ4.3.3 The Ranchers
ââ4.3.4 The Conservationists
ââ4.3.5 The Absentees
ââ4.3.6 Group Mobility
â4.4 When Claims of Entitlement Are Acted Out
ââ4.4.1 Encroachment and Raiding
ââ4.4.2 Killing of Wildlife
â4.5 Concluding Remarks
5 Enclosing the Land: From Common Land to Freehold Farmland and Back
â5.1 The Construction of Enclosure in Laikipia: The Story of the Dykes
â5.2 Towards Land Enclosures in Ol Moran and Thome
ââ5.2.1 Symbolic Enclosures in Thome
ââ5.2.2 Physically Enacted Enclosures in Ol Moran
â5.3Present-day Enclosures in Laikipia
ââ5.3.1 Practices of Enclosing Space: The Naming of Places
ââ5.3.2 Physical Enclosures: Fencing
â5.4 Concluding Remarks
6 Ambiguous Institutions: Twilight Actions of Land-buying Companies
â6.1 All Things Come to Those Who Wait â or Do They?
â6.2 The History of Land-buying Companies and Land Hunger
â6.3 Institutional Pluralism and Land
â6.4 The Case of Thome Farmers Company
â6.5 The Power Dynamics of Land-buying Companies
â6.6 Repercussions of Private Land Redistribution
ââ6.6.1 Absentee Landlords
ââ6.6.2 Absent Title Deeds and Vernacular Land Markets
â6.7 Concluding Remarks
7 Africanisation or Invasion: Laikipiaâs land-use Change
â7.1 Diachronic Perspectives on Land-use Change in Three Case Study Areas
ââ7.1.1 Lorien
ââ7.1.2 Ol Moran
ââ7.1.3 Thome
â7.2 Historical Perceptions of the Landscape
ââ7.2.1 Travel Writersâ Perceptions of New Land
ââ7.2.2 Rights, Borders and Water: Land-use Practices from the 1930s
ââ7.2.3 The Peak and Transition of European Settlement in the 1960s
â7.3 Present-day Land-use Dynamics of an Africanised Landscape
â7.4 Concluding Remarks
8 Conclusion
â8.1 Understanding Laikipia
ââ8.1.1 Frontiers, Fragmentation and Colonial Residue
ââ8.1.2 Legal Pluralism and Land Rights
ââ8.1.3 Ethnicity and the Politicisation of Land Claims
ââ8.1.4 The Sustainablity of Land-management Practices
â8.2 Resolving the State of Emergency in Laikipia, 2016â17
â8.3 Final Thoughts
âBibliography
âIndex
All concerned with land contestations related to the 2016-17 land invasions in Laikipia, and scholars from African Studies, Anthropology and History interested in land rights, access claims, frontiers and fencing