While the Security Council has been mandating peacekeepers to protect civilians since 1999, there is still contention on its legal meaning. Even though the concept of âprotectionâ can seem self-evident, as the concept of âprotectionâ is borrowed language, each body of law will perceive âprotectionâ through a different lens. However, as the mandate creates a legal obligation on UN peace missions, a clear understanding of protection is fundamental to ensure performance and accountability.
Tamer Morris, Ph.D. (2021), University of Sydney, is a lecturer in International Law at University of Sydney Law School.
Acknowledgement
Note on Previous Publications and Presentations
Introduction
â1âThe Evolution of the Protection of Civilians Mandate
â2âPeacekeeping Structure and Deployment
â3âMethodology
1âThe Legal Obligation to Protect Civilians
â1âThe Legal Obligation of the Protection of Civilians Mandate
â1.1âThe Positive Obligation to Protect on tccâs and UN
â1.2âThe Obligation on the UN
â1.3âThe Obligation of the Host State
â2âThe Content of the Obligation to Protect
â2.1âObligation to Protect under ihl
â2.2âObligation to Protect in ihrl
â3âProtection of Civilians and Humanitarian Intervention
â4âConclusion
2âThe Interpretation of Protection
â1âWhat Is Protection?
â2âInterpreting the Impossible Mandate
â2.1âMulti-Dimensional Peacekeeping
â3âThe Language of the Protection of Civilians Mandate
â3.1âProtection from Physical Violence
â4âQualifications to the Obligation to Protect
â4.1âPreventive Protection
â4.2âProactive Protection and the Rise of Protection Forces
â5âProtection and Promotion of Human Rights
â5.1âHuman Rights Protection in UN Peacekeeping
â5.2âSocial, Political and Economic Rights
3âProtection from threats of Physical Violence and ihl
â1âCentral Theme of Physical Violence
â1.1âThe Focus on the Use of Force to Protect
â1.2âA Legal Indicator to the Use of Force
â2âThe Application of ihl in UN Peace Missions
â3âClassification of Conflict Involving UN Peace Missions
â3.1âStatus of Peacekeepers in Armed Conflict
â3.2âScope and Duration of ihl
â4âThe Obligation to Protect and ihl
â4.1âCounter-Terrorist Measures
â5âPriority of Protection and Self-Defence
â6âConclusion
4âLaw Enforcement under the Protection of Civilians Mandate
â1âunpol in UN Peacekeeping
â2âProtection of Civilians Mandate for unpol
â2.1âProtection against Sexual and Gender-Based Violence
â3âLaw Enforcement and Detention in UN Peace Missions
â4âDetentions Made by Peacekeepers
â4.1âLegal Grounds for Detention
â4.2âTreatment of Security Detainees
â5âTransferring and Releasing Detainees
â5.1âThe Principle of Non-refoulement
â6âConclusion
5âThe Protection of Women and Children
â1âWomen and Children as âVulnerableâ Civilians
â2âProtection under the Maintenance of International Peace and Security
â3âThe Protection from Conflict-Related Sexual Violence
â4âChild Protection
â4.1âThe Protections Afforded to Children in Armed Conflict
â4.2âDefining the âChildâ under the Law
â4.3âProtection Provided to Child Soldiers
â4.4âddr Process and Child Soldiers
â4.5âIncidental Removal of Children from Armed Groups
â4.6âUse of Force against Child Soldiers
â5âProtection against Child Soldiers
â6âProtection Advisors and Training
â7âConclusion
6âThe Protection of idpâs
â1âProtection of idpâs
â2âProtection of idp Camps
â2.1âUN Effective Control over Individuals and idp Camps
â2.2âSecurity Risks Due to Lack of Planning of idp Camps
â2.3âSecurity Risk from Poor Design of idp Camps
â3âProtection of Human Rights in idp Camps
â3.1âThe Right to Food and Water
â3.2âThe Right to Education
â3.3âProtection of Access to Health Care
â4âConclusion
7âAccountability for Failure to Protect
â1âAccountability of Peacekeepersâ Actions
â1.1âUN Operational Control and tcc/pcc Disciplinary Responsibility
â2âLaw of State and Organisational Responsibility
â2.1âEffective Control Test
â2.2âJoint Responsibility of UN Peace Operations
â2.3âCivilian Peacekeepers
â3âImmunity of the UN
â4âIndividual Peacekeeper Accountability
â4.1âImmunity from Host State Jurisdiction
â4.2âAccountability under tcc/pcc Military Code
â5âThe Responsibility of the tcc/pcc under International Law
â6âObligation on the UN Leadership
â7âConclusion
Conclusion
Appendix 1âTimeline of Protection of Civilians in Peacekeeping
Appendix 2âSummary of Peacekeeping Missions from 1999 to April 2024
Appendix 3âList of Questions Asked to Participants
Bibliography
Index
This monograph will be of interest to peacekeeping practitioners , academics and students in international law, specifically international humanitarian law and human rights law, but international relations, and peacebuilding and the United Nations.