Can international law reconcile the paradox between sovereign equality, the prohibition on the use of force, and the moral imperative to prevent mass atrocity crimes?
This book offers a rigorous analysis of the legality of humanitarian intervention and evaluates the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) as a normative alternative to unilateral force. Drawing on UN Charter interpretation, state practice, case law, and developments from Kosovo to Libya and Syria, it examines how law, power, and legitimacy interact in such interventions. By proposing lawful pathways for collective action when the Security Council is deadlocked, the book advances a principled framework for atrocity prevention within the UN system.
Wasantha Seneviratne is Senior Professor and Chair of Public and International Law at the University of Colombo, Sri Lanka. She has authored numerous book chapters and journal articles on public international law, humanitarian law and human rights, and has edited academic volumes. She serves as the Sri Lanka State Volume Editor for the Encyclopaedia of International Law in Asia (Brill, 2023) and is the Sri Lanka State Rapporteur for the Asian Yearbook of International Law. Professor Seneviratne currently serves as a Member of the Law Commission of Sri Lanka.
Contents
Preface Acknowledgements List of Tables
1 Framing the Debate
â1 The Humanitarian Paradox in the Use of Force
â2 Setting the Context: From Non-intervention to Protection-Based Intervention
â3 Unfolding the Debate: Reconciling Humanity and Sovereignty
â4 Core Argument of the Book
â5 Lines of Inquiry
â6 Aim of the Book
â7 Scope and Focus of the Book
â8 Methodological Approach
â9 Scholarly Contribution and Relevance of the Book
â10 Scholarly Context and Rationale
â11 Scope and Delimitations of the Book
â12 Structure of the Book
â13 Conclusion
2 Founding the Framework
â1 Introduction
â2 Tracing the Roots: Exploration of the Historical and Contextual Foundations of Humanitarian Interventions
â3 Examining the Key Definitions of Humanitarian Interventions
â4 Contested Legacies: Historical Perceptions of Humanitarian Interventions
â5 Shift of Paradigm: From âNon-interventionâ to âHumanitarian Interventionâ
â6 Emergence of Humanitarian Interventions in the PostâCold War World
â7 Scholarly Opinions on Humanitarian Interventions
â8 Conclusion
3 âProhibition against the Use of Forceâ
â1 Introduction
â2 Birth of the United Nations and the Changed Parameters of the Legality of International Interventions
â3 Provisions of the United Nations Charter Relating to Humanitarian Interventions
â4 Appraising the Drafting History of Article 2(4)
â5 Article 2(7) of the United Nations Charter
â6 Authorised âExceptionsâ to the General Rule of Non-intervention
â7 Resolutions and Declarations Governing International Interventions in the PostâUN Charter Period
â8 Humanitarian Interventions and Case Law Jurisprudence in the PostâUN Charter World Related to the Use of Force
â9 Conclusion
4 âCrossing the Grey Areaâ
â1 Introduction
â2 The Place of Customary Law in Contemporary International Law
â3 From Kosovo to a New Norm? Examining the Potential Role of Customary International Law in Determining the Legality of Humanitarian Intervention
â4 Examining NATOâs Claim of Legality in Kosovo and Its Norm Creating Character as a Precedent for the Future
â5 ECOWAS Interventions in the PostâCold War World
â6 Need for Effective International Responses to Humanitarian Catastrophes
â7 Conclusion
5 From Humanitarian Intervention to âResponsibility to Protectâ
â1 Introduction
â2 âResponsibility to Protectâ Doctrine: A Brief Overview
â3 International Responses towards the New Initiative
â4 From Consensus to Action: Implementing the Responsibility to Protect in the PostâWorld Summit World
â5 Evolution of the âResponsibility to Protectâ from Theory to Practice: Ensuing Challenges and Opportunities for the Future
6 Conclusion 2756 Prudence of Opening the âPandoraâs Boxâ
â1 Introduction
â2 Unleashing âHopeâ from Pandoraâs Box: Finding Solutions within the Framework of the UN Charter
â3 âIn the Shadow of the Vetoâ: Exploring Alternative Mechanisms to Implement âResponsibility to Protectâ
â4 Reinvigorating the Pillar System: The Way Forward
â5 Conclusion
7 âUntying the Gordian Knotâ
â1 Unveiling the Core Findings: Synthesising the Principal Insights
â2 Summary of the Recommendations
â3 Conclusion: Assessing the Legality of Humanitarian Interventions in the PostâCold War World under the UN Charter
â4 Final Thought and Avenues for Future Research
Bibliography Index
Important for academic libraries, researchers, postgraduate students, and legal and policy professionals working on international law, humanitarian intervention, human rights, UN studies, and global security governance.