A bronze mirror of the fourth century BC shows a she-wolf suckling infant twins. You may think thatâs a familiar story, but who are the other figures in the scene, and why is there a lion so prominent in the foreground? The image typifies the problems involved in studying the history and evolution of mythic stories in the ancient world. This collection of studies, prompted by a famous archaeologistâs quasi-historical reinterpretation of the Romulus legend, seeks to achieve greater clarity by avoiding abstract concepts like âoral traditionâ or âcultural memoryâ and paying close attention to what the primary sources presuppose.
T.P. Wiseman is Emeritus Professor of Classics and Ancient History at the University of Exeter. His books include Remus: A Roman Myth (1995), The Myths of Rome (2004) and The Lost History of Roman Drama (forthcoming).
List of Figures
Introduction
1 The Start of a Long Story
â1âReview of Andrea Carandini, La nascita di Roma
â2âReview of Andrea Carandini, Rome: Day One
2 Reading Carandini
â1âThe exhibition
â2âDivine kings and mythic memory
â3âWhat were the Lares?
â4âTwins and Quirites
â5âThe altar and the trench
â6âGiornale di scavo
3 The Prehistory of Roman Hellenism
â1âRomans and Greeks
â2âGreek in Latin
4 The City that Never Was: Alba Longa and the Historical Tradition
â1âThe city
â2âPliny on archaic Latium
â3âThe dynasty
6 Gods in Roman History
â1âVisible gods
â2âAudible gods
â3âBelievers and agnostics
â4âPopular belief
â5âAmbivalence
7 Memory and Stories: An Anthology
â1âMemory and history
â2âThe historianâs problem
â3âFirst pseudo-solution
â4âSecond pseudo-solution
â5âHistory and fiction
â6âDramatic presentation
â7âInformation and education
â8âRitual and remembrance
8 Alföldiâs Early Rome and the Latins
â1âDogma
â2âEvidence
â3âAuthority
9 Archaeology and Legend: The Grave on the Palatine
â1âA site with a history
â2âThe memory fallacy
â3âWhose grave was it?
â4âMaking it too easy
10 From Romulus to Tarquin: Reconstructing Romeâs Expansion
â1âAn exemplary work
â2ââHypercriticsâ
â3âMultiple foundations
â4âRoma quadrata and the pomerium
â5âGates and walls
â6âThe beginning of Rome
11 The Migrant Queen
â1âTheiosso
â2âElissa
â3âDido
12 Herakles at Hartland
â1âAn unexpected temple
â2âAn ocean-going hero comes to Rome
â3âThe tin route
13 Not the Tomb of Romulus (but perhaps something more interesting)
â1âOssa Quirini
â2âA pignus?
14 Plutarch, Dionysius and the Creation of Romulus
â1âDionysius and Plutarch
â2âThe wars of Romulus
â3âMyth creation
â4âA Latin founder
â5âExpanding the heroâs story
â6âUniting the peoples
â7âContemporary evidence
â8âPlutarchâs perspective
â9âRome before the culture wars
â10âConclusions
15 The Black Stone and the Tomb of Romulus: JanuaryâJune, 1899
â1âFinding it and naming it
â2âThe reaction
â3ââNon è in alcun modo sostenibileâ
â4âFestus (and Verrius Flaccus)
â5âThe Horatian commentators (and Varro)
â6âDionysius of Halicarnassus (and Varro?)
â7âThe lions and the pillar
â8âChronology and stratigraphy
â9âFaustulus and Hostus Hostilius
â10âWhat has been learned?
16 Making Myths: Hostus Hostilius and his Grandson
â1âTwo items in Pliny
â2âAn explanation in Macrobius
â3âA catch-up paragraph in Dionysius
â4âA burnt page in Festus
â5âA battle in Livy and Plutarch
â6âKing Tullus
â7âThe historical Hostilii
â8âWartime festivals
â9âTwo urban praetors
â10âThe backlash
17 Propertius on Triumphs and Tarpeia
â1âThe house-doorâs complaint
â2âTriumphs
â3âTarpeia before Tatius
â4âTarpeia the betrayer
â5âVarro and the Vestal
â6âRoman stories
â7âBack to the house-doorâs complaint
18 Orosius, Justin and the Afterlife of Myth
â1âRewriting Romulus
â2âArtwork captions
â3âTapestries
â4âRomelus and Remelus in Cornwall
â5ââWhere did you learn this story?â
Epilogue 2025
Bibliography Index
Anyone with an interest in the mythology of the Greco-Roman world.