Ontologies of Violence provides a new paradigm for understanding the concept of violence through comparative interpretations of French philosopher Jacques Derrida, philosophical theologians in the Mennonite pacifist tradition, and Grace M. Jantzenâs feminist philosophy of religion. By drawing out and challenging the remarkably similar priorities shared by its three sources, and by challenging the assumption that differences necessarily lead to displacement, Ontologies of Violence provides a critical theory of violence by treating it as a diagnostic concept that implies the violation of value-laden boundaries.
Maxwell Kennel, Ph.D. (2021), McMaster University, is a Senior Research Associate in the Centre for Social Accountability at the Northern Ontario School of Medicine University. He is the author of Postsecular History: Political Theology and the Politics of Time (Palgrave Macmillan, 2022).
In Ontologies of Violence Maxwell Kennel renews conversations about the nature of violence by charting a course through Derrida and Mennonite political theology toward Grace Jantzen's celebration of life and beauty. In doing so, Kennel offers a positive vision - or story - of peace that refuses to subordinate difference to a predetermined harmony. The importance of this approach becomes especially clear in the book's conclusion, where Kennel brilliantly engages with intersectional theories of violence and the question of public health. â Jamie Pitts, Associate Professor Anabaptist Studies, Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary
In this refreshingly original book, Maxwell Kennel carefully guides the reader through complex texts, elucidates thorny philosophical and theological problems, and demonstrates the vitality of Mennonite thinking. Tackling the imposing question of violenceâs meaning with sophistication and care, Kennel successfully moves between developing his own voice as a constructive interdisciplinary thinker and charting often-overlooked connections between Continental philosophy and Mennonite theology. It is such a joy to read a book in which each chapter surprises you with unexpected insights. â Vincent Lloyd, Associate Professor of Theology and Religious Studies, Villanova University
Kennelâs Ontologies of Violence does not offer a definition that can become the cornerstone of a political vision. Instead, it undoes easy sloganeering and even challenges the headiest of theorizing in order to bring to the fore what is left unsaid when the term âviolenceâ is said. â Guy Lancaster, Marx & Philosophy Review of Books (November 2023)
Kennelâs work provides indispensable insights into the landscape of political theology, philosophy, and social theory. â¦While Kennel shares Radical Orthodoxyâs critique of the privatization of religion and the myth of purely secular spaces, he does so with a humble dispossession, care, and nuance absent from scholars such as Milbank⦠Overall, Kennel provides a strong case for an intersectional and nonviolent approach to knowing, thinking, and being in the world. â Andrew Banacos in Reading Religion
Acknowledgments
Introduction: What Is Violence?
â1 Political Theology
â2 Ontological Violence
â3 Plan of the Work
â4 Approaches to Violence
2 Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology and Ontological Peace
â1 Radical Reformation
â2 Radical Orthodoxy
â3 Mennonites, Milbank, and Derrida
â4 The Philosophical Turn in Mennonite Pacifism
â5 Radical Reformation Responses
â6 Chris K. Huebnerâs Precarious Peace
â7 Excursus on Yoderâs Patience as Method and Pacifist Epistemology
â8 Peter C. Blumâs Impossible Peace
â9 Pacifist Epistemology Revisited
â10 Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology and Derridaâs Original Violence
3 Grace Jantzenâ Critique of Violent Displacement
â1 What Is Violence?
â2 Grace Jantzen
â3 Derrida, Jantzen, and Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology
â4 The Problem of Metanarratives
â5 Jantzen, the Mennonites, and Derrida
â6 Violence in Death and the Displacement of Beauty
â7 Violence and Displacement
â8 Violence, History, and Master Narratives
â9 Foundations of Violence
â10 Violence to Eternity
â11 A Place of Springs
â12 Violence and History
Conclusion: Violence as the Violation of Value-Laden Boundaries
â1 Derridaâs Original Violence
â2 Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology
â3 The Problem of Displacement
â4 Violence Is the Violation of Value-Laden Boundaries
â5 Violent Intersections
â6 Social Accountability, Violence, and Public Health
Bibliography
Index
The book is relevant to scholars and graduate students interested in ontologies and epistemologies of violence within and beyond French philosophy and deconstruction, philosophical theologies in the Mennonite pacifist tradition, and Grace Jantzenâs feminist philosophy of religion.