This book is a comparative theological investigation into the following question: how does one theologically understand the sincere-truth-seeking religious other who rejects oneâs truth claims not out of animosity or ignorance, but rather from a desire to worship God in spirit and in truth? Specifically, this book investigates the extent to which soteriologically exclusivist Muslims and Christians maintain their respective truth claims while maintaining a posture of vulnerability to the revisionary power of the religious otherâs claims. To answer these questions, this book examines comparative theologyâs missiological foundation through a dialogical study of neo-Calvinist and Reformist Sunni understandings of the epistemic status of the religious other. This book is a practice in comparative theology with the goal of rethinking neo-Calvinist theology of religions through Islamic thought to present a missiological comparative theology amenable to exclusivist theological positions within Christianity and Islam.
Alexander E. Massad, Ph.D., is an Assistant Professor of World Religions at Wheaton College (IL) and an Affiliate Faculty in the School of Mission and Theology at Fuller Theological Seminary (CA). He is a comparative theologian whose research and publications focus on Evangelical and Reformed theology in dialogue with the Muslim tradition.
Acknowledgements
Introduction
â1 Purpose and Outline of the Book
â2 Clarifications and Nuances
PART 1: Methods, Comparative Theology, and Missions
1 A Historical Account of Christians Accounting for Non-Christians
â1 Missionaries, the âOldâ Comparative Theology, and the Scientific Study of Religion
â2 The Theology of Religions: a Response to Christian Primacy
â3 The âNewâ Comparative Theology: an A Posteriori Response to Hegemony
â4 Assessing the âDialecticalâ Narrative
â5 Critique of Nicholsonâs Narrative â Overstating the Dialectic
â6 The Missionary Spirit in Comparative Theology
2 The Potential for a Missiological Comparative Theology
â1 Evangelical Concerns: Comparative Theology, Multiple Religious Belonging, and Missions
â2 Hegemonic Discourse: Comparative Theologyâs Amenability to Missiology
ââ2.1 The Promise of a Missiological Comparative Theology
â3 An Aggiornamento for Exclusivism and Comparative Theology
â4 Review of Part One
PART 2:Neo-Calvinism and the Islamic Tradition
3 A Neo-Calvinist Comparative Theology
â1 Neo-Calvinist Soteriology and Epistemology
â2 Neo-Calvinist Comparative Theology and Soteriological Exclusivism
â3 Warranting a Neo-Calvinist Comparative Theology
ââ3.1 Abraham Kuyper: Common Grace and Comparative Theology
ââ3.2 Herman Bavinck: General Revelation and Comparative Theology
ââ3.3 Contemporary Neo-Calvinist Approaches to Common Grace and General Revelation
â4 Developing a Neo-Calvinist Comparative Theological Perspective
â5 Concluding Remarks
4 Neo-Calvinist Approaches to Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
â1 Abraham Kuyperâs Encounter with the Islamic Tradition
â2 Herman Bavinckâs Meditations on Islam
â3 Johan Herman Bavinckâs Preoccupation with Islam
â4 Assessing Early Neo-Calvinist Theological Engagements with Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
â5 Contemporary Neo-Calvinist Approaches to Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
ââ5.1 Contemporary Antithesis-Driven Neo-Calvinist Approaches to Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
ââ5.2 Bartholomew and Strange: a Priori Presuppositionalism
â6 Contemporary Common-Grace-Driven Neo-Calvinist Approaches to Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
ââ6.1 Mouw and Kaemingk: an Unwitting Perpetuation of Binaries
â7 The Need for a Neo-Calvinism Aggiornamento with Muslims and the Islamic Tradition
PART 3: Contemporary Reformist Muslims and the Religious Other
5 RashÄ«d Riá¸Ä and Christianity: the Problem of Christian Missions and Riá¸Äâs ṬarÄ«q al-DaÊ¿wa
â1 Riá¸Ä and ṬaÊ¿n
â2 Riá¸Ä and TaḥrÄ«f
â3 Riá¸Ä and DaÊ¿wa
â4 âMissiologyâ and Riá¸Äâs ṬarÄ«q al-DaÊ¿wa
6 From DaÊ¿wa to ShahÄda: Muslim Religious Imagination and the Religious Other
â1 Nguyenâs Muslim Theology of Imagination and Engagement
ââ1.1 Nguyenâs Muslim Theology of Prostration
ââ1.2 Nguyenâs Muslim Theology of Engagement
ââ1.3 Nguyenâs Muslim Theology of Imagination
â2 Reimagining Anthropology: From al-GhazÄlÄ«âs Epistemological Emphasis to Riá¸Äâs Fiá¹ra Focus
â3 Riá¸Ä â Religious Imagination in al-GhazÄlÄ«âs Soteriological Taxonomy
â4 From DÄr al-IslÄm to DÄr al-Ê¿Ahd to DÄr al-DaÊ¿wa
â5 From DaÊ¿wa to ShahÄda: Tariq Ramadan
ââ5.1 Ramadanâs Call to Western Muslims
ââ5.2 Ramadanâs Fiá¹ra Anthropology
ââ5.3 From Fiá¹ra to ShahÄda
â6 From DÄr al-DaÊ¿wa to DÄr al-ShahÄda
â7 Concluding Remarks
PART 4: Comparative Theological Conclusions: Neo-Calvinism, Islam, and Missiological Comparative Theology
7 Reconfiguring Neo-Calvinism through Islamic Thought
â1 Idenburg: a Case Study in Colonial Neo-Calvinism
â2 Colonial Neo-Calvinism and ṬaÊ¿n
â3 Perpetuating the Problem: a Priori Presuppositionalist Neo-Calvinism
ââ3.1 The Ethical Problems of Antithesis-Driven A Priori Presuppositionalism
â4 Assessing Ethical Implications within Common-Grace Driven Neo-Calvinism
â5 An a Posteriori Autobiographically Vulnerable Neo-Calvinism: Readings Romans 1 with Riá¸Ä
8 Towards a Missiological Comparative Theology
â1 Accadâs Kerygmatic Missiology
â2 Contemporary Muslim ṬarÄ«q al-ShahÄda
â3 Missio Dei and Comparative Theology
References
Index
This book is intended for scholars in comparative theology, Reformed and Evangelical theologians, Christian missiologists, and Muslim scholars who engage in inter-religious dialogue.