Reforming the United Nations - Fit for Purpose at 75? - examines the efforts of Secretary-General, António Guterres, to improve the aging organisation during 2017-2019. On development, the global network was repositioned better to assist countries. On peace and security, the Secretariat was reorganised with a focus on conflict prevention. On management, the paradigm centred on decentralisation and accountability. Other priorities addressed sexual exploitation in peacekeeping and gender parity. The detail analysis of the reform process highlights the positions of the United States, Russia, China, the Group of 77 and the European Union. Official records are used. The Guterres reform was respectable by improving efficiency and effectiveness. Reform proposals did not, however, address fundamental problems including Security Council reform.
Joachim Müller, D.Phil. (1988), Oxford University, is a former senior official of the United Nations system. He has published extensively on change management in international organisations, including the series on Reforming the United Nations (Brill, 1997, 2001, 2006, 2010, 2016).
Preface Abbreviations List of Figures
1âShort History of UN Reform
â1.1âEarly Years, 1946â1953
ââ1.1.1âTrygve Lie of Norway
â1.3âRediscovery and Challenges, 1992â2016
ââ1.3.1âBoutros Boutros-Ghali of Egypt
ââ1.3.2âKofi Annan of Ghana
ââ1.3.3âBan Ki-moon of South Korea
â1.4âReform of the Security Council
2âSecretary-General António Guterres: A Difficult Start and Early Reform Priorities
â2.1âUS President Donald Trump
â2.2âGuterresâs Early Reform Initiatives
â2.3âSexual Exploitation and Abuse
ââ2.3.1âNew Approach
ââ2.3.2âFifth Committee Review and the Member Statesâ Position
ââ2.3.3âApproval of the ga Resolution on Sexual Exploitation and Abuse
ââ2.3.4âVoluntary Compact and Circle of Leadership
â2.4âGender Parity
ââ2.4.1âSystem-Wide Strategy on Gender Parity
â2.5âTowards a Comprehensive Reform Agenda
ââ2.5.1âDeclaration on UN Reform
3âDevelopment Pillar
â3.1âQuadrennial Comprehensive Policy Review (QCPR)
ââ3.1.1âIndependent Team of Advisors
ââ3.1.2âQCPR Landmark Resolution 71/243
â3.2âRepositioning the UN Development System: First Report (A/72/124-E/2018/3)
ââ3.2.1âECOSOC and the Second Committee of the GA Consider the First Report on the UN Development System
â3.3âRepositioning the UN Development System: Second Report (A/72/684âE/2018/7)
ââ3.3.1âECOSOC Review of Reform Proposals
ââ3.3.2âIntergovernmental Consultations within the Framework of the ga
ââ3.3.3âReform Resolution 72/279
ââ3.3.4âUNCT
ââ3.3.5âUNRC
ââ3.3.6âRegional Approach
ââ3.3.7âFunding the UN Development System
ââ3.3.8âFollow-up on the Repositioning Efforts of the UN Development System
â3.4âMember Statesâ Positions
â3.5âFunding Compact
â3.6âDESA and Regional Commissions
4âThe Peace and Security Pillar
â4.1âThe High-Level Advisory Board on Mediation
â4.2âBudget Pressure
â4.3âRestructuring of the Peace and Security Architecture: First Report (A/72/525)
ââ4.3.1âIntergovernmental Consultations
ââ4.3.2âApproval of the First Report by ga Resolution 72/199
â4.4âRestructuring the Peace and Security Architecture: Second Report (A/72/772)
ââ4.4.1âReview by the acabq
ââ4.4.2âApproval of the Second Report
â4.5âMember Statesâ Positions
â4.6âAction for Peacekeeping (A4P)
ââ4.6.1âThe Secretary-General Launched A4P
ââ4.6.2âThe Declaration of Shared Commitments on UN Peacekeeping Operations
ââ4.6.3âA Peacekeeping Task Force to Support A4P
ââ4.6.4âA4P Champions
5âThe Management Pillar
â5.1âA New Management Paradigm: First Reports (A/72/492, A/72/492/Add.1)
ââ5.1.1âStaff Were Briefed on Management Reform
ââ5.1.2âThe New Management Paradigm and Planning and Budget Process Are Issued
ââ5.1.3âReview by the acabq
ââ5.1.4âThe Assembly Endorses the New Management Paradigm and Approves the New Planning and Budgetary Process
â5.2âThe New Management Paradigm: Second Report (A/72/492/Add.2)
ââ5.2.1âThe Second Report on the New Management Paradigm Is Issued
ââ5.2.2âACABQ Review of the New Management Architecture
ââ5.2.3âThe Secretary-General Briefs Member States on the New Management Paradigm
ââ5.2.4âThe Assembly Approves the New Management Paradigm
â5.3âMember Statesâ Positions
â5.4âOutstanding Issues: Information and Communication Technology (ICT), The Global Service Delivery Model and Human Resources Management
ââ5.4.1âInformation Technology (IT)
ââ5.4.2âThe Global Service Delivery model
ââ5.4.3âHuman Resources Management
6âImplementation of Reform
â6.1âThe Implementation Plan
â6.2â1 January 2019: Commencement of the Reform
â6.3âThe Development Pillar
ââ6.3.1âThe Second Implementation Report, April 2019
ââ6.3.2âECOSOC Reviews the Second Implementation Report
ââ6.3.3âThe Third Implementation Report, April 2020
â6.4âThe Member Statesâ Position
â6.5âThe Peace and Security Pillar
â6.6âThe Management Pillar
7âReforming the United Nations: Fit for Purpose at 75?
â7.1âReform Issues
â7.2âThe Reform Process and Member Statesâ Position
â7.3âConclusion
Appendix IâShort Introduction to the UN
â1âGoverning Bodies (the GA, the Security Council, ECOSOC, the ACABQ)
â2âThe Secretariat and Peacekeeping
â3âFunds, Programmes, Specialised Agencies and Related Organisations
â4âThe UN System and the UN Development System
Appendix IIâChronology of UN Reform Process
Appendix IIIâUN Documents
â1âSecretary-Generalâs Reports
ââ1.1âGA-ECOSOC Report A/72/124-E/2018/3, Repositioning the United Nations Development System to Deliver on the 2030 Agenda: Ensuring a Better Future for all, Report of the Secretary-General, 11 July 2017 [See Chapter 3.2]
ââ1.2âGA Report A/72/492, Shifting the Management Paradigm in the United Nations: Ensuring a Better Future for all, Report of the Secretary-General, 27 September 2017 [See Chapter 5.1]
ââ1.3âGA Report A/72/525, Restructuring of the United Nations Peace and Security Pillar, Report of the Secretary-General, 13 October 2017 [See Chapter 4.1]
â1.4âGA-ECOSOC Report A/74/73âE/2019/14, Implementation of General Assembly Resolution 71/243 on the Quadrennial Comprehensive Policy Review of Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations system, 2019, Report of the Secretary-General, 15 April 2019 [See Chapter 6.1]
â2.âResolutions
â2.1âGA Resolution 71/243, Quadrennial Comprehensive Policy Review of Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 21 December 2016, Issued 1 February 2017 [See Chapter 3.1]
â2.2âGA Resolution 72/199, Restructuring of the United Nations Peace and Security Pillar, Adopted 20 December 2017, Issued 19 January 2018 [See Chapter 4.1]
â2.3âGA Resolution 72/236, Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 20 December 2017, Issued 18 January 2018 [See Chapter 3.2]
â2.4âGA Resolution 72/266 A, Shifting the Management Paradigm in the United Nations, Adopted 24 December 2017, Issued 15 January 2018 [See Chapter 5.1]
â2.5âGA Resolution 72/279, Repositioning of the United Nations Development System in the Context of the Quadrennial Comprehensive Policy Review of Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 31 May 2018, Issued 1 June 2018 [See Chapter 3.3]
â2.6âGA resolution 72/262 C iii, Revised Budget Estimates for the Period from 1 July 2018 to 30 June 2019 Related to the Peace and Security Reform, Adopted 5 July 2018, Issued 18 July 2018 [See Chapter 4.2]
â2.7âGA Resolution 72/266 B, Shifting the Management Paradigm in the United Nations, Adopted 5 July 2018, Issued 17 July 2018 [See Chapter 5.2]
â2.8âGA Resolution 73/248, Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 20 December 2018, Issued 14 January 2019 [See Chapter 3.1]
â2.9âECOSOC Resolution 2019/15, Progress in the Implementation of General Assembly Resolution 71/243 on the Quadrennial Comprehensive Policy Review of Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 8 July 2019, Issued 12 July 2019 [See Chapter 6.1]
â2.10âGA Resolution 74/238, Operational Activities for Development of the United Nations System, Adopted 19 December 2019, Issued 10 January 2020 [See Chapter 6.1]
â2.11âGA Resolution 75/1, Declaration on the Commemoration of the Seventy-Fifth Anniversary of the United Nations, 21 September 2020 [See Chapter 7]
â3.âACABQ Reports
â3.1âGA Report A/72/7/Add.24, Shifting the Management Paradigm in the United Nations: Ensuring a Better Future for all: Improving and Streamlining the Programme Planning and Budgeting Process, Report of the acabq, 22 November 2017 [See Chapter 5.1]
â3.2âGA report A/72/859, Revised Budget Estimates for the Period from 1 July 2018 to 30 June 2019 Related to the Peace and Security Reform, Report of the acabq, 8 May 2018 [See Chapter 4.2]
â3.3âGA Report A/72/7/Add.49, Shifting the Management Paradigm in the United Nations: Implementing a New Management Architecture for Improved Effectiveness and Strengthened Accountability, Report of the acabq, 25 May 2018 [See Chapter 5.2]
Bibliography
Index
All interested in international organisations and their management, specifically UN and UN system. Political scientists, experts on organisation studies and international law. Academic and international law libraries, UN institutions, diplomatic services, UN practitioners, post-graduate students.