Writing is not the only notation system used in literate societies. Some visual communication systems are very similar to writing, but work differently. Identity marks are typical examples of such systems, and this book presents a particularly well-documented marking system used in Pharaonic Egypt as an exemplary case.
From Single Sign to Pseudo-Script is the first book to fully discuss the nature and development of an ancient marking system, its historical background, and the fascinating story of its decipherment. Chapters on similar systems in other cultures and on semiotic theory help to distinguish between unique and universal features. Written by Egyptologist Ben Haring, the book addresses scholars interested in marking systems, writing, literacy, and the semiotics of visual communication.
"With this publication, the author exemplified how a close familiarity with a subject enables research in areas of Egyptian society that had not been touched until now and how the resulting insight is presented properly." - Eva-Maria Engel, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, in: Bibliotheca Orientalis 76.1-2 (2019)
"This work should certainly become a guidebook to scholars wishing to publish ostraca of this sort, who have in the past shied away from the complex task due to the enigmatic nature of the materials. The time has arrived for this study of this hitherto neglected facet of Egyptian writing, to find its fitting place in the history of literacy and script in Ancient Egypt, as well as in the history of workmenâs signs in general." - Orly Goldwasser, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, in: Journal of Near Eastern Studies (2019, 78/2)
"The technical data and Egyptological scholarship of the book are deliberately made very accessible to be of assistance in the understanding of identity marks in other periods and cultures. This is a remarkable work of social history." - George J. Brooke, in: Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 43.5 (2019)
"With this publication, the author exemplified how a close familiarity with a subject enables research in areas of Egyptian society that had not been touched until now and how the resulting insight is presented properly." - Eva-Maria Engel, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, in: Bibliotheca Orientalis 76.1-2 (2019)
"Over one thousand ostraca are assessed, together with other objects from the workmenâs settlement and tombs, especially pottery vessels, and hundreds of graffiti in the Theban mountains. The technical data and Egyptological scholarship of the book are deliberately made very accessible to be of assistance in the understanding of identity marks in other periods and cultures. This is a remarkable work of social history." - George J. Brooke, in: Society for Old Testament Study Book List 2019
Preface List of Figures
Prologue
Ancient Egyptian Identity Marks in Theoretical and Comparative Perspective
1 Making Sense of Funny Signs
â1.1âAn Ancient Text from Berlin
â1.2âDocumentary Texts, Hieratic and Otherwise
â1.3âThe Research History of the Necropolis Workmenâs Marks
â1.4âA Quick Lesson in Hieroglyphs
â1.5âMarks and Hieroglyphs
â1.6âThe Aim of the Present Book
2 Identity Marks, Egyptian and Other
â2.1âA Unique Document
â2.2âAncient Egyptian Pot Marks
â2.3âBuildersâ Marks, from Teams to Individuals
â2.4âMarking Systems Worldwide
â2.5âMasonsâ Marks in Europe, Medieval and Later
â2.6âThe Morphology of Masonsâ Marks
â2.7âWhy Were Masonsâ Marks Applied?
â2.8âMasons and Masters
â2.9âMasonsâ Marks in Families and Workshops
â2.10âGeneral Characteristics of Marking Systems
3 Writing and Other Sign Systems
â3.1âTheories of the Sign
â3.2âThe Sign in Structuralism: Paradigm and Syntagma, Signifier and Signified
â3.3âThe Sign According to Peirce: Referentiality and Semiosis
â3.4âVisual and Material Communication: To Write, or Not to Write?
â3.5âWriting and Other Graphic Systems, Independently and Together
â3.6âLiteracy: Mastering Writing ⦠and Much More
The Deir el-Medina Marking System
4 The Setting: The Workmen of the Royal Tomb and Their Textual Legacy
â4.1âAn Exceptional Village
â4.2âThe Early History of the Royal Necropolis and Its Workmen
â4.3âGreat Changes for Egypt and for the Royal Necropolis
â4.4âRamesside Necropolis Administration, and Administrators
â4.5âThe End of the Royal Necropolis
â4.6âHieratic Necropolis Records ⦠by the Thousands
â4.7âThe Nature of the Documentary Texts
â4.8âLocal Knowledge and Output, Textual and Visual
5 The Use of the Workmenâs Marks: Historical Overview
â5.1âThe Earliest Marks of the Royal Necropolis Workmen
â5.2âThe Origin of the Marking System
â5.3âA Break in the History of the Marking System?
â5.4âNineteenth-Dynasty Ostraca with Marks
â5.5âMarks and Families
â5.6âThe Function of the Nineteenth-Dynasty Marks
â5.7âThe Twentieth-Dynasty Duty Rosters
â5.8âOther Types of Record from the Twentieth Dynasty
â5.9âThe Late Twentieth Dynasty
6 How the Men Came by Their Marks, and Vice Versa
â6.1âMarks and Their Users
â6.2âLong- and Short-Lived Marks: Pomegranate, Lotus and Jackal
â6.3âLong-Lived Marks and Their Graphic Variety: The Families of Qaha and Sennedjem
â6.4âShort-Lived Marks: Name, Reputation and Status
â6.5âMark, Family and Position
â6.6âMorphology: Distinctive Forms versus Allomorphs
â6.7âSign Categories and Fuzzy Borders
â6.8âThe Role of Writing and Literacy
â6.9âMorphology and Semiosis: Anything Goes?
â6.10âHistorical and Functional Context: Graphic Communication and Literacy
Epilogue: The Alphabet
Bibliographical Essay
References Timetable Index
Scholars interested in marking systems, writing, literacy, and the semiotics of visual communication, as well as those interested in Ancient Egyptian writing and visual culture.