Dispute resolution reforms in China in the last decade or so have all centred around the strategy of establishing an integrated dispute resolution system as part of Chinaâs modern governance system. This new integrated system, referred to as the âMechanism for Pluralist Dispute Resolution (PDR)â in China, serves as a dispute resolution system as well as a comprehensive social control mechanism. This book is the first academic attempt to explain the methods of civil and commercial dispute resolution in China from the perspective of PDR. It systematically and critically examines the development of Chinaâs dispute resolution system, with each chapter analysing in detail the development and transformation of the different institutions, mechanisms and processes in their historical, politico-economic and comparative context.
Zhiqiong June Wang, Ph.D. (UNSW), is Associate Professor of Law, Western Sydney University, Australia. She specialises in commercial law, comparative law and Chinese law. Prior to her joining academia, she was a practising lawyer in China. She has published widely on Chinese law, as well as on law, technology and legal education.
Jianfu Chen, Ph.D. (Sydney), is Professor of Law, La Trobe University, Australia. He is also an arbitrator with the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission. He has published widely on Chinese law and international trade law.
âPrefaceandAcknowledgements
âAbbreviations
âIntroduction
â1 Legal Culture and Historical Development of Law
â1 Introduction
â2 History as Legacy and Legacies of History
â2.1 History and Tradition in Context
â2.2 Confucianism
â2.3 Legalism
â2.4 Practical PoliticsâConfucianisation of Law
â2.5 The Legacies of History
â3 Evolution and Revolution
â3.1 Efforts towards Westernisation of Law
â3.2 Efforts Tilted towards Modernisation of Law
â4 Socialist Legality and Socialist Legacies
â4.1 From Socialist Legality to Legal Nihilism
â4.2 From Legal Instrumentalism to the Rule of Law
â4.3 The Return of Legal Instrumentalism
â4.4 Chinese Law at a Crossroads
â5 Concluding Remarks
â2 Legal Institutions: The Political and Constitutional Setting
â1 Introduction
â2 Separation of Powers and the Integration of Party and State
â3 Party Control over Institutional Setup and Personnel: The ChineseNomenklaturaSystem
â4 Party Control over Legal Institutions: The Politico-legal Committees
â5 Legal Institutions under the Chinese Constitution
â6 Administrative Responsibilities for Justice and Law
â6.1 An Overview
â6.2 The Ministry of Justice and Its Evolving Functionality
â6.3 Judicial Examination/Qualification Examination for Legal Professions
â7 Concluding Remarks
â3 Judicial Institutions
â1 Introduction
â2 Judicial Development and Reforms: The struggle for status, prestige and identity
â2.1 Judicial Development and Reforms in Context
â2.2 The New Round of Reforms
â2.3 The Consolidation of Reform Results
â3 Organisation and Structure
â4 Judges and Other Personnel of the Peopleâs Courts
â5 The Peopleâs Procuratorates and Civil Dispute Settlement
â6 Concluding Remarks
â4 The Legal Profession
â1 Introduction
â2 Lawyers and Legal Practice
â2.1 The (Incomplete and Hesitant) Transformation of Lawyering as a Profession in China
â2.2 Lawyers: Qualification, Business Scope and Limitations
â2.3 Law Firms
â2.4 Lawyersâ Associations and the Ministry of Justice
â2.5 Foreign Lawyers and Foreign Law Firms in China
â3 Notary System and Authentication
â3.1 The Transformation has Just Started
â3.2 Qualifications, Establishment and Scope of Business
â4 Concluding Remarks
â5 Negotiation and Mediation
â1 Introduction
â2 Negotiation/Consultation
â2.1 Overview
â2.2 Cultural Context and the Limit of Cultural Influence
â2.3 The Essence of Negotiation: Trade-off and Due Diligence
â3 Mediation/Conciliation (Tiaojie/Hejie)
â3.1 Historical Development of Mediation in China
â3.2 An Ever-Expanding Scope and Increasing Importance of Application
â3.3 Peopleâs Mediation
â3.4 Administrative Mediation
â3.5 Mediation in Arbitration
â3.6 Institutional Mediation/Conciliation
â3.7 Court Mediation
â4 Concluding Remarks
â6 Arbitration
â1 Introduction
â2 The Historical Development of Arbitration in China
â2.1 The Introduction of Arbitration to China
â2.2 The Resumption of Domestic Arbitration in Post-Mao China
â2.3 Rapid Development and the New Regime of Arbitration in China
â3 A National Arbitration Framework
â3.1 The Legal Framework and Underlying Principles
â3.2 Arbitration Commissions and Ad Hoc Arbitration
â3.3 The China Arbitration Association, and Arbitrators
â3.4 Arbitration Processes
â3.5 Arbitration Awards, Judicial Review and Enforcement
â3.6 Foreign-Related Arbitration and the Internationalisation of Arbitration
â4 TheCIETACand Arbitration byCIETAC
â4.1 TheCIETACas an Arbitration Commission
â4.2 The Main Features ofCIETACArbitration
â4.3 Specialised Arbitration
â5 Administrative Arbitration
â6 Concluding Remarks
â7 Civil Litigation
â1 Introduction
â2 Historical Development of Civil Litigation in China
â3 Civil Procedure Law and Rules
â3.1 Overall Legal Framework and General Features
â3.2 Jurisdiction
â3.3 Commencement and Pre-trial Preparations
â3.4 Evidence
â3.5 Trial Process
â3.6 Damages, Preservation Measures and Statutory Limitations
â3.7 Special Rules on Foreign-Related Litigation
â3.8 Execution of Judgments and Rulings
â4 False Litigation
â5 Concluding Remarks
â8 Enforcement of Judgments
â1 Introduction
â2 âZhixing NanââA Political, Economic, Socio-legal Phenomenon
â3 Evolving Legal Mechanisms for Enforcement
â4 Execution of Judgments, Rulings and Decisions
â5 Enforcement of Foreign Judgments
â6 Concluding Remarks
âConclusion
âSelect Bibliography
âLegislation and Policy Documents
âIndex
Academics and students interested in Chinese law and society, and legal practitioners and business persons involved in Chinese law and international trade and investment law.