This book provides a series of challenges to Jorge J. E. Graciaâs views on metaphysics and categories made by realist philosophers in the Aristotelian and Thomistic traditions. Inclusion of Graciaâs responses to his critics makes this book a useful companion to Graciaâs Metaphysics and its Task: The Search for the Categorial Foundation of Knowledge.
âA valuable contribution to current metaphysics. The studies of Graciaâs important book Metaphysics and its Task are insightful, and his replies to them are meticulous. One of the many merits of the book is the respect evident throughout for the essential place of Aristotle and Aquinas in serious metaphysical inquiry.â â Panayot Butchvarov
Foreword by Ralph M. McInerny
Editorâs Introduction
Acknowledgments
One: Thomas D. SULLIVAN and Russell PANNIER: The Bounds of Metaphysics
Two: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Being as Being, the Transcendentals, the Divine, and Metaphysics: Response to Sullivan and Pannier
Three: Josef SEIFERT: What is Metaphysics and What are its Tasks?: An Attempt to Answer this Question with Critical Reflections on Graciaâs Book
Four: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Being as Being and the Tasks of Metaphysics: Response to Seifert
Five: Jonathan J. SANFORD: An Aristotelian Critique of Graciaâs Metaphysics
Six: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Metaphysics and Meta-Metaphysics: Response to Sanford
Seven: Robert A. DELFINO: Neo-Thomism and Graciaâs Metaphysics
Eight: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Thomas, Thomists, and the Nature of Metaphysics: Response to Delfino
Nine: Peter A. REDPATH: Gracia and His Task
Ten: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: The Nature of Philosophy: Response to Redpath
Eleven: John D. KRONEN: Spirits and âThingsâ: Ritschlâs Critique of Metaphysics in Light of Graciaâs Definition of Metaphysics
Twelve: Daniel D. NOVOTNY: Is Hume A Metaphysician?: Aristotle vs. Gracia.
Thirteen: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Making Sense of the History of Metaphysics: Response to Kronen and Novotny
Fourteen: Russell PANNIER and Thomas D. SULLIVAN: Gracia on the Ontological Status of Categories
Fifteen: Jorge J. E. GRACIA: Categorial Neutralism: Response To Pannier, Sullivan, Seifert, and Ingala
Afterword by Jorge J. E. GRACIA
About the Contributors
Index