The Foundations of Modern International Law on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples
The Preparatory Documents of the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, and Its Development through Supervision. Volume 2: Human Rights and the Technical Articles
Also available as a print set of two, see isbn 9789004373754
The International Labour Organization is responsible for the only two international Conventions for the protection of the rights and cultures of indigenous and tribal peoples - the Indigenous and Tribal Populations Convention, 1957 (No. 107) and the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169) that revised and replaced it, and Convention No. 169 is the only one that can now be ratified. This volume, together with its companion published in 2015, make clear that the basic concepts and the very vocabulary of international human rights on indigenous and tribal peoples derives from these two Conventions. The adoption in 2007 of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), and the ongoing discussions in the international human rights community about the relative merits, impact and legal validity of the UN and ILO instruments, make it all the more important to understand how Convention 169 was adopted. The author of this unique study was responsible for many years for the supervision of both Conventions by the ILO, and was intimately involved in the adoption of the 1989 instrument, as well as in international discussions on the subject. In writing this two-volume study, he foregoes a strict âtravauxâ approach, and discusses the organizational precedents and the subsequent practice under these instruments. The supervision of the application of these Conventions is very largely unknown in the wider human rights community, and even in the more specialized âindigenous communityâ that forms a special subset of human rights activists. This guide may be of some help in redressing that situation.
Lee Swepston is the Former Senior Advisor on Human Rights of the International Labour Office (ILO), and is now a teacher (University of Lund, Sweden and Raoul Wallenberg Institute, inter alia) and consultant. He attended the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and took his Juris doctor degree at Columbia University in New York. He joined the ILO in 1973, where his posts included being Regional Adviser on International Labour Standards in Africa, Human Rights Coordinator and Chief of the Equality and Employment Branch. He has written numerous books and articles on various aspects of human rights and international labour law, forced labour and child labour, freedom of association, discrimination, HIV and AIDS, migrant workers and indigenous and tribal peoples. His latest work includes a textbook on international labour law and human rights, and the first volume of the present book.
From 1973 until 2004 he was responsible in the ILO for the supervision of the Indigenous and Tribal Populations Convention, 1957 (No. 107) and for participating for the ILO in international discussions on this emerging issue. He was also responsible in the ILO for the adoption of the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169) and for its supervision for the first 15 years after its adoption. He remains concerned with promoting the implementation and further ratification of the Convention.
âIntroduction
Part 1: Introductory Materials
âAâContents of This Volume
âBâHow the ILO Adopts Standards
ââ1âTripartism
ââ2âAdoption Process
ââ3âVoting in the ILO Conference
âCâSupervision of the Application of ILO Standards
ââ1âRegular Supervisory Mechanism
ââ2âComplaint Procedures
âââaâRepresentations under Article 24 of the ILO Constitution
âââbâComplaints under Article 26 of the ILO Constitution
âDâCitation of Materials in This Volume
ââ1âSupervisory Comments
ââ2âPreparatory Materials
âââaâOffice Reports and Written Consultations
âââbâReports of Discussions in the International Labour Conference
Part 2: The Articles of Convention No. 169
1âArticle 3 of Convention No. 169 â Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
2âArticle 4 of Convention No. 169 â Special Measures
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
3âArticle 5 of Convention No. 169 â Respect for Values, Practices and Institutions
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
4âArticle 8 of Convention No. 169 â Customs and Customary Laws
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
5âArticles 9 and 10 of Convention No.169 â Dealing with Offenses, and Penalties
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision of Articles 8, 9 and 10
6âArticle 11 of Convention No. 169 â Compulsory Personal Services
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
7âArticle 12 of Convention No. 169 â Right to Take Legal Proceedings
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
8âArticle 20 of Convention No. 169 â Recruitment and Conditions of Work
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
ââ1âSupervision under Convention No. 169
ââ2âSupervision under Other ILO Conventions
9âArticles 21, 22 and 23 of Convention No. 169 â Vocational Training, Handicrafts and Rural Industries
âAâVocational Training
ââ1âAdoption of Convention No. 107
ââ2âAdoption of Convention No. 169
âââaâThe 1988 Conference Discussion
âââbâThe 1989 Conference Discussion
ââ3âDevelopment through Supervision
âBâHandicrafts and Rural Industries
ââ1âAdoption of Convention No. 107
ââ2âAdoption of Convention No. 169
âââaâThe 1988 Conference Discussion
âââbâThe 1989 Conference Discussion
ââ3âDevelopment through Supervision
10âArticles 24 and 25 of Convention No. 169 â Social Security and Health
âAâSocial Security
ââ1âAdoption of Convention No. 107
ââ2âAdoption of Convention No. 169
âââaâThe 1988 Conference Discussion
âââbâThe 1989 Conference Discussion
ââ3âDevelopment through Supervision
âBâHealth
ââ1âAdoption of Convention No. 107
ââ2âAdoption of Convention No. 169
âââaâThe 1988 Conference Discussion
âââbâThe 1989 Conference Discussion
ââ3âDevelopment through Supervision
11âArticles 26 to 31 of Convention No. 169 â Education and Means of Communication
âAâDifferent Contexts for the Adoption of the Two Conventions
ââ1âAdoption of Convention No. 107
ââ2âAdoption of Convention No. 169
âBâAdoption of Each Article of Conventions Nos. 107 and 169
ââ1âArticle 21 of C107 and Article 26 of C169
âââaâArticle 21 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 26 of Convention No. 169
ââ2âArticle 22 of C107 and Article 27 of C169
âââaâArticle 22 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 27 of Convention No. 169
ââ3âArticle 23 of C107 and Article 28 of C169
âââaâArticle 23 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 28 of Convention No. 169
ââ4âArticle 24 of C107 and Article 29 of C169
âââaâArticle 24 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 29 of Convention No. 169
ââ5âArticle 25 of C107 and Article 31 of C169
âââaâArticle 25 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 31 of Convention No. 169
ââ6âArticle 26 of C107 and Article 30 of C169
âââaâArticle 26 of Convention No. 107
âââbâArticle 30 of Convention No. 169
âCâConcluding Comments on Education
âDâDevelopment through Supervision
12âArticle 32 of Convention No. 169 â Contacts and Co-operation across Borders
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 169
13âArticle 33 of Convention No. 169 â Administration
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision
14âArticle 34 of Convention No. 169 â Flexibility of Application
âAâAdoption of Convention No. 107
âBâAdoption of Convention No. 169
ââ1âThe 1988 Conference Discussion
ââ2âThe 1989 Conference Discussion
âCâDevelopment through Supervision and Implementation
15âConcluding Comments
Appendices
âIâIndigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169)
âIIâIndigenous and Tribal Populations Convention, 1957 (No. 107)
âIIIâHow the ILO Adopts Standards
âIVâMajor Documents Consulted and Citation in This Volume
âVâInterpretation of Convention No. 169
Index