DawÄnÄ« (d. 1502) and DashtakÄ« (d. 1498) on Primary (awwalÄ«) and Familiar (mutaÊ¿Äraf) Predication
In: OriensSearch for other papers by Khaled El-Rouayheb in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
The present article explores the motivations that led JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-DawÄnÄ« (d. 1502) to draw the distinction between what he called âprimary predicationâ (ḥaml awwalÄ«) and âfamiliar predicationâ (ḥaml mutaÊ¿Äraf or ḥaml shÄʾiÊ¿). These motivations include allowing for the predication of particulars, such as âThis is Zaydâ and accounting for apparently true self-negations, such as âThe [concept] particular is not a particular.â The article also explores some criticisms of this distinction by DawÄnÄ«âs contemporary and rival á¹¢adr al-DÄ«n al-DashtakÄ« (d. 1498). Despite these criticisms, DawÄnÄ«âs distinction was adopted, adapted, and emphasized by the Safavid scholar MÄ«r DÄmÄd (d. 1631). MÄ«r DÄmÄdâs influence, in turn, accounts for the prominence given to the distinction in later centuries among Iranian and Indo-Muslim logicians.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Ahmed, Asad. Palimpsests of Themselves: Logic and Commentary on Post-Classical Muslim South Asia. Oakland, California: University of California Press, 2022.
-
BÄghnawÄ«, MÄ«rzÄ JÄn. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ l-ḤÄshiya al-qadÄ«ma Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-TajrÄ«d. Süleymaniye Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS Ragip 730.
-
Benevich, Fedor. âThe Classical AshÊ¿ari Theory of AḥwÄl: al-JuwaynÄ« and his Opponents.â Journal of Islamic Studies 27(2016): 136â175.
-
DashtakÄ«, á¹¢adr al-DÄ«n al-. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ á¸¤Äshiyat Sharḥ al-Shamsiyya.
-
Süleymaniye Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS ReÅid Efendi 1015.
-
Süleymaniye Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS Carullah 1371.
-
DashtakÄ«, á¹¢adr al-DÄ«n al-. al-ḤÄshiya al-jadÄ«da Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-TajrÄ«d. Bayezit Devlet Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS Veliyüddin 2027.
-
DashtakÄ«, á¹¢adr al-DÄ«n al-. al-ḤÄshiya al-qadÄ«ma Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-TajrÄ«d. Millet Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS Feyzullah 1112.
-
DawÄnÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ á¸¤Äshiyat al-Sayyid al-SharÄ«f.
-
In Shurūḥ al-Shamsiyya: MajmÅ«Ê¿at ḥawÄshÄ« wa-taÊ¿lÄ«qÄt fÄ« l-maná¹iq (Cairo: al-Maá¹baÊ¿a al-azhariyya, 2011 [reprint of 1327/1905 edition]), vol. 2, 256â86.
-
Delhi: al-Maá¹baÊ¿ al-mujtabÄʾī, no date.
-
Istanbul: MatbaÊ¿a-yi IbrÄhÄ«m EfendÄ«, 1309/1891, pp. 2â23.
-
DawÄnÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al. al-ḤÄshiya al-ajadd. Süleymaniye Kütüphanesi, Istanbul, MS Kılıç Ali PaÅa 510.
-
DawÄnÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al. al-ḤÄshiya al-qadÄ«ma Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-TajrÄ«d. Printed with Ê¿AlÄ« al-QÅ«shjÄ«, Sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-Ê¿aqÄʾid. Ed. by Muḥammad Ḥusayn al-ZÄriÊ¿Ä« al-Riá¸ÄyÄ«. Qom: IntishÄrÄt-i rÄʾid, 1393/2014.
-
DawÄnÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ TahdhÄ«b al-maná¹iq. Istanbul: al-ḤÄjj Muḥarram al-BÅ«snawÄ«, 1305/1887.
-
FallÄḥī, AsadollÄh. âḤaml-e avvalÄ« va shÄyiÊ¿ dar maná¹eq-e qadÄ«m va jadÄ«d.â Äyene-ye MaÊ¿refat 19 (1388/2009): 19â46.
-
FallÄḥī, AsadollÄh & Sayyid BahÄʾuddÄ«n Movaḥḥed Abá¹aḥī. âKÄrbordhÄ-ye nÄdorost-e ḥaml-e avvalÄ« va shÄyeÊ¿.â Majalle-ye falsafe va kalÄm-e eslÄmÄ« 43(1389/2010): 103â119.
-
Frank, Richard. âAbÅ« HÄshimâs theory of âstatesâ: Its structure and function.â Biblos 46 (1970): 86â100.
-
GelenbevÄ«, IsmÄÊ¿Ä«l. al-BurhÄn fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-mÄ«zÄn. Istanbul: MatbaÊ¿a-yi Ê¿osmÄniye, 1310/1892.
-
Haaparanta, Leila. âOn Fregeâs Concept of Being.â In The Logic of Being, ed. by Simo Knuuttila and Jaakko Hintikka. Dordrecht: Reidel, 1986, 269â289.
-
Hintikka, Jaakko. âOn the Different Identities of Identity: A Historical and Critical Essay.â In Language, Meaning, Interpretation. Ed. by Guttorm Fløistad. Dordrecht: Springer, 2004, 117â139.
-
ḤusaynÄ« AstarÄbÄdÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n. RisÄla fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-munÄáºara. KitÄbkhÄneh-i Majlis-i ShÅ«rÄ-yi IslÄmÄ«, Tehran, MS 441.
-
Iá¹£fahÄnÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. TasdÄ«d al-qawÄÊ¿id fÄ« sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-Ê¿aqÄʾid. Ed. by KhÄlid al-Ê¿AdwÄnÄ«. Kuwait: DÄr al-á¸iyÄʾ, 2012.
-
JurjÄnÄ«, al-Sayyid al-SharÄ«f al-. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ Mukhtaá¹£ar Ibn al-ḤÄjib. BÅ«lÄq: al-Maá¹baÊ¿a al-amÄ«riyya, 1316â17/1898â1900.
-
JurjÄnÄ«, al-Sayyid al-SharÄ«f al-. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-Shamsiyya. Printed with Quá¹b al-DÄ«n al-RÄzÄ«. TaḥrÄ«r al-qawÄÊ¿id al-maná¹iqiyya bi-Sharḥ al-RisÄla al-Shamsiyya. Cairo: Muá¹£á¹afÄ al-BÄbÄ« al-ḤalabÄ«, 1948.
-
KhÄdimÄ«, EbÅ« SaÊ¿Ä«d. Ê¿ArÄʾis anáºÄr al-abkÄr wa-nafÄʾis maÊ¿din al-asrÄr. Princeton UniverÂsity Library, Princeton, Islamic MS, Garrett Y5310, fols. 117bâ154b.
-
Khaá¹Ä«b al-QazwÄ«nÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-. TalkhÄ«á¹£ al-MiftÄḥ wa-bi-l-hÄmish sharḥuhu l-Mukhtaá¹£ar li-l-TaftÄzÄnÄ«. Cairo: Muá¹£á¹afà al-BÄbÄ« al-ḤalabÄ«, 1938.
-
Knuuttila, Simo. âSupposition and Predication in Medieval Trinitarian Logic.â Vivarium 51 (2013): 260â274.
-
Lakhnawi, Baḥr al-Ê¿UlÅ«m. Sharḥ Sullam al-Ê¿ulÅ«m. Ed. by Ê¿Abd al-Naṣīr al-MÄlibÄrÄ«. Kuwait: DÄr al-á¸iyÄʾ, 2012.
-
Lameer, Joep. âGhayr al-maÊ¿lÅ«m yamtaniÊ¿ al-ḥukm Ê¿alayhi: An Exploratory Anthology of a False Paradox in Medieval Islamic Philosophy.â Oriens 42(2014): 397â453.
-
MÄ«r AbÅ« l-Fatḥ. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-DawÄnÄ«. Printed with DawÄnÄ«, Sharḥ TahdhÄ«b al-maná¹iq. Istanbul: al-ḤÄjj Muḥarram al-BÅ«snawÄ«, 1305/1887.
-
MÄ«r DÄmÄd. al-Ufuq al-mubÄ«n. Ed. by Hamed Naji Esfahani. Tehran: Miras-e maktoob, 2013.
-
Ostertag, Gary. âE.E. Constance Jones on Identity and Predication.â In Women in the History of Analytic Philosophy. Ed. by Jeanne Peijnenburg & Sander Verhaeg. Dordrecht: Springer, 2022, 49â66.
-
QÅ«shjÄ«, Ê¿AlÄ« al-. Sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-Ê¿aqÄʾid. Ed. by Muḥammad Ḥusayn al-ZÄriÊ¿Ä« al-Riá¸ÄyÄ«. Qom: IntishÄrÄt-i rÄʾid, 1393/2014.
-
RÄzÄ«, Quá¹b al-DÄ«n al-. TaḥrÄ«r al-qawÄÊ¿id al-maná¹iqiyya bi-Sharḥ al-RisÄla al-Shamsiyya. Cairo: Muá¹£á¹afÄ al-BÄbÄ« al-ḤalabÄ«, 1948.
-
SabzawÄrÄ«, MullÄ HÄdÄ«. Sharḥ al-LaʾÄlÄ« al-muntaáºama. Lithograph edition, Tehran, 1298/1881.
-
Thiele, Jan. âAbÅ« HÄshim al-JubbÄʾīâs (d. 321/933) Theory of âStatesâ (aḥwÄl) and its Adaption by AshÊ¿arite Theologiansâ. In Oxford Handbook of Islamic Theology. Ed. by Sabine Schmidtke. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014, 225â241.
-
Weiner, Joan. Frege Explained: From Arithmetic to Analytical Philosophy. Chicago: Open Court, 2004.
-
Zimmermann, Fritz. Al-Farabiâs Commentary and Short Treatise on Aristotleâs De Interpretatione. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981.
-
ZirÄÊ¿atpÄ«shah, MaḥmÅ«d. Ḥaml-i avvalÄ« va shÄyiÊ¿: rahyÄftÄ« tÄrÄ«khÄ«. Tehran: Muʾassasah-i pizhÅ«hishÄ«-i ḥikmat va falsafah-i ĪrÄn, 1393/2015.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 960 | 164 | 26 |
| Full Text Views | 49 | 14 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 290 | 33 | 0 |
DawÄnÄ« (d. 1502) and DashtakÄ« (d. 1498) on Primary (awwalÄ«) and Familiar (mutaÊ¿Äraf) Predication
In: OriensSearch for other papers by Khaled El-Rouayheb in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
The present article explores the motivations that led JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-DawÄnÄ« (d. 1502) to draw the distinction between what he called âprimary predicationâ (ḥaml awwalÄ«) and âfamiliar predicationâ (ḥaml mutaÊ¿Äraf or ḥaml shÄʾiÊ¿). These motivations include allowing for the predication of particulars, such as âThis is Zaydâ and accounting for apparently true self-negations, such as âThe [concept] particular is not a particular.â The article also explores some criticisms of this distinction by DawÄnÄ«âs contemporary and rival á¹¢adr al-DÄ«n al-DashtakÄ« (d. 1498). Despite these criticisms, DawÄnÄ«âs distinction was adopted, adapted, and emphasized by the Safavid scholar MÄ«r DÄmÄd (d. 1631). MÄ«r DÄmÄdâs influence, in turn, accounts for the prominence given to the distinction in later centuries among Iranian and Indo-Muslim logicians.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 960 | 164 | 26 |
| Full Text Views | 49 | 14 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 290 | 33 | 0 |
