The 2014 referendum in Scotland, which brought victory for the unionists, was characterised by a high level of involvement of religious organisations in the campaign. Although the Churches chose to be neutral on the referendum dilemma, this was explained by prevailing attitudes among clergy, who objected Scottish independence. In this article, analysing the stance of the Church of Scotland, Roman Catholic Church, Episcopal Church of Scotland, and Free Church of Scotland, I argue that the chosen path of neutrality played more in favour of unionists. The Churchesâ influence on the referendumâs outcome was far beyond statistical errors, and had Churches publicly supported independence, it would have been likely that Edinburgh would now be negotiating the terms of âdivorceâ with London.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
Chrysostomos Archbishop (2011) âThe head of the Church of Cyprus said that the country should leave the European Unionâ. Available at: http://survincity.com/2011/10/the-head-of-the-church-of-cyprus-said-that-the/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Bergin Claire (2014) âScotland: More than 30 Kirk ministers join Christian âYesâ campaignâ. Available at: http://www.indcatholicnews.com/news.php?viewStory=25461Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Bonney Norman (2013) âReligion and the Scottish Independence Referendumâ. The Political Quarterly, Vol. 84, No. 4, pp. 478â485.
Bradley Ian (2014) âTwo kings and two kingdoms: the Church of Scotland, the monarchy, national identity and establishmentâ. International journal for the Study of the Christian Church. 14:2, pp. 156â174.
Brown David (2014) âScotland: religion, culture and national identityâ. International journal for the Study of the Christian Church. 14:2, pp. 88â99.
Bruce Steve (2013) âPost-Secularity and Religion in Britain: An Empirical Assessment.â Journal of Contemporary Religion 28 (3), pp. 369â384.
Casanas Adam Elisenda (2014) âSelf-determination and the Use of Referendums: the Case of Scotlandâ. Int Journal Polit Cult Soc, 27, pp. 47â66.
Chillingworth David (2014) âChurches agnostic on independenceâ. Available at: https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2014/14-march/comment/opinion/churches-agnostic-on-independenceDate of access: 27.02.2017.
Church of England (1972) âNovember 1972 General Synod Motion On Europeâ. Available at: http://www.cofe.anglican.org/info/socialpublic/international/europe/europegsreport.docDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (2014) âMinutes of the Proceedings of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotlandâ. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/21102/Assembly-Minutes-Thurs-2014.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (N.d.) â10,000 voices for changeâ. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/speak_out/10000_voicesDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (N.d.a) âOur vision. Imagining Scotlandâs futureâ. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/23185/ISF-for-web.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (2015) âLiving stones. Annual Report and Accounts 2014â. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/27327/annual_report.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (2015a) âMinutes of the Proceedings of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotlandâ. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/27670/ga_minutes_tuesday_19.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Church of Scotland (2015b) âOutgoing Moderator calls for unityâ. Available at: http://www.churchofscotland.org.uk/news_and_events/news/recent/outgoing_moderator_calls_for_unity_and_reconciliationDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Cushley Leo (2014) âWould the moral consensus be any different in an independent Scotland?â Available at: http://www.scmo.org/index.php?page=briefings&article=archbishop-leo-cushley-opinio&perma=1403435811Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Dunlop Martin (N.d.) âWill independence fuel sectarianism?â Available at: http://www.sconews.co.uk/news/11903/will-independence-fuel-sectarianism/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Forbes John (2014) âThe referendumâWhat they donât tell you in the newsâ. Available at: http://freechurch.org/news/the-referendum-what-they-dont-tell-you-in-the-newsDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Fraser Douglas (2015) âStudy examines referendum demographicsâ. Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-34283948Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Free Church of Scotland (2014) âChurchmen consider independence referendum argumentsâ. Available at: http://freechurch.org/news/churchmen-consider-indyref-argumentsDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland (2014) âScottish IndependenceâSynod says Vote âNoââ. Available at: http://www.fpchurch.org.uk/2014/07/scottish-independence-referendum-synod-resolution/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Gillies Robert (2014) âRespect other peopleâs identitiesâ. Available at: http://www.scotland.anglican.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Respect-other-peoples-identities.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Goldie Annabel (2015). Interview with scpo. Available at: http://www.actsparl.org/media/205643/baroness%20annabel%20goldie%20msp.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Guibernau Montserrat , Rocher Francois and Adam Elisenda Casanas (2014) âIntroduction: A Special Section on Self-Determination and the Use of Referendums: Catalonia, Quebec and Scotlandâ. Int Journal Polit Cult Soc, 27, 1â3.
Hamerly Ivy (2012) âChristian Democratic Parties and the Domestic Parliamentary Response to European Integrationâ. Journal of Church and State, Vol. 54, No. 2, pp. 214â239.
Harkins Daniel (2014) âScotlandâs archbishops urge Catholics to vote in independence referendumâ. Available at: http://www.sconews.co.uk/news/39575/scotlands-archbishops-urge-catholics-to-vote-in-independence-referendum/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Hassan Gerry (2014) âState of independence: the rise of âthird Scotlandââ. Soundings,
Life and Work Magazine (2014) âChurch to host new referendum debateâ. Available at: http://www.lifeandwork.org/news/news/post/260-church-to-host-new-referendum-debateDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Life and Work Magazine (2015) âModerator Launches eu Referendum Blogâ. Available at: http://www.lifeandwork.org/news/news/post/466-moderator-launches-eu-referendum-blogDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Mason Roger (2013) âDis-United Kingdoms? What Lies Behind Scotlandâs Referendum on Independenceâ. Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, Summer/Fall, pp. 139â146.
McOwan Rennie (2014) âA central, moral issue in referendumâ. Available at: http://www.sconews.co.uk/opinion/40023/40023/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Mudrov Sergei (2015) âReligion and the European Union: Attitudes of Catholic and Protestant Churches toward European Integrationâ. Journal of Church and State, Vol. 57, No. 3. pp. 507â528.
Mudrov Sergei (2016) âReligion in the Treaty of Lisbon: Aspects and Evaluationâ. Journal of Contemporary Religion, Vol. 31, Issue 1, pp. 1â16.
Mullen Tom (2014) âThe Scottish Independence Referendum 2014â. Journal of Law and Society, Volume 41, Number 4, pp. 627â640.
B. Nelsen , J. Guth and Ch. Fraser (2001) âDoes Religion Matter? Christianity and Public Support for the European Unionâ. European Union Politics, Vol. 2(2), pp. 191â217.
Ross John (2014) âChurch Establishment in an Independent Scotlandâ.
Stoddart Eric (2014) âPublic Practical Theology in Scotland: with particular reference to the independence referendumâ. International Journal of Practical Theology, 18(2), pp. 317â347.
stv (2014) âChurch of Scotland group pledges support for Scottish independenceâ. Available at: http://news.stv.tv/scotland-decides/289507-church-of-scotland-group-pledges-support-for-scottish-independence/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Thompson Damian (2014) âThe Scottish Catholic bishops and the Nationalists: a scandal is coming to lightâ. Available at: http://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2014/09/the-scottish-catholic-bishops-and-the-nationalists-a-scandal-is-coming-to-light/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Tierney Stephen (2013) âLegal Issues Surrounding the Referendum on Independence for Scotlandâ. European Constitutional Law Review, 9, pp. 359â390.
Torrance David (2013) âThe Battle for Britain. Scotland and the Independence Referendumâ. Biteback Publishing, London.
Torrance David (2014) â100 Days of Hope and Fear. How Scotlandâs Independence Referendum was Lost and Wonâ. Luath Press Limited, Edinburgh.
The Russian Orthodox Church. Department for External Church Relations (N.d.). Available at: https://mospat.ru/en/documents/social-concepts/xvi/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
The Scottish Government (2013) âScotlandâs Future. Executive Summaryâ. Available at: http://www.gov.scot/scotlandsfutureDate of access: 27.01.2017.
The Scottish Government (2013a) âScotlandâs Future. Your guide to an independent Scotlandâ. Available at: http://www.gov.scot/Resource/0043/00439021.pdfDate of access: 27.01.2017.
Vogan Matthew (2014) âReferendum resultâa call to thanksgivingâ. Available at: http://www.fpchurch.org.uk/2014/09/referendum-result-a-call-to-thanksgiving/Date of access: 27.01.2017.
Interview with Arnold 2015. Interview with Bishop John Arnold, Diocese of Salford. Manchester, 29.04.2015.
Interview with Catholic priest 2015. Interview with Catholic priest, Glasgow, 16.03.2015.
Interview with Chillingworth 2015. Interview with David Chillingworth, Primus of the Episcopal Church of Scotland. Perth, Scotland, 14.04.2015.
Interview with Foster-Fulton 2015. Interview with Sally Foster-Fulton, Convener of the Church and Society Council of the Church of Scotland. 24.03.2015.
Interview with Gay 2015. Interview with Douglas Gay, Church of Scotland minister and Lecturer at the University of Glasgow. Glasgow, 21.04.2015.
Interview with Keenan 2015. Interview with Kevin Keenan, Scottish Labour Party Councillor in Dundee City Council. Dundee, 22.04.2015.
Interview with Mackenzie 2015. Interview with Peter Mackenzie, Scottish National Party councillor in East Lothian Council. Edinburgh, 19.03.2015.
Interview with Robertson 2015. Interview with David Robertson, minister of St Peterâs Church, moderator of Free Church of Scotland in 2015â2016. Dundee, 27.03.2015.
E-mail correspondence with Ross. E-mail correspondence with John Ross, Free Church of Scotland minister for Glenurquhart and Fort Augustus. 16.04.2015.
Interview with Shanks 2015. Interview with Norman Shanks, former convener of the Church and Nation Committee of the Church of Scotland. Glasgow, 21.04.2015.
Interview with Thompson 2015. Interview with Dave Thompson. Member of Scottish Parliament, Convener of the âChristians for Independenceâ group. Edinburgh, 19.03.2015.
Interview with Toal 2015. Interview with Bishop Joseph Toal, Diocese of Motherwell. Motherwell, 16.03.2015.
Interview with Treanor 2015. Interview with Bishop Noel Treanor, Diocese of Down and Connor. Belfast, 06.03.2015.
Interview with Wilson 2015. Interview with James Wilson, Clerk of Dundee Presbytery. Dundee, 26.03.2015.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1317 | 51 | 4 |
| Full Text Views | 184 | 0 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 106 | 0 | 0 |
The 2014 referendum in Scotland, which brought victory for the unionists, was characterised by a high level of involvement of religious organisations in the campaign. Although the Churches chose to be neutral on the referendum dilemma, this was explained by prevailing attitudes among clergy, who objected Scottish independence. In this article, analysing the stance of the Church of Scotland, Roman Catholic Church, Episcopal Church of Scotland, and Free Church of Scotland, I argue that the chosen path of neutrality played more in favour of unionists. The Churchesâ influence on the referendumâs outcome was far beyond statistical errors, and had Churches publicly supported independence, it would have been likely that Edinburgh would now be negotiating the terms of âdivorceâ with London.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1317 | 51 | 4 |
| Full Text Views | 184 | 0 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 106 | 0 | 0 |