Token Constitutionalism and Islamic Opposition in Tajikistan
In: Journal of Persianate StudiesSearch for other papers by Muriel Atkin in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
Tajikistan is a predominantly Muslim country where the concept of having a constitution is not controversial, but the content of that constitution is. Roughly seventy years of Soviet rule over the territory that became independent Tajikistan at the end of 1991 introduced constitutions as a norm, although the rights the constitutions appeared to accord did not jibe with political reality. The years of Soviet rule also created an environment hostile to Islam, as a result of which some of Tajikistan’s inhabitants ceased to be believers, while many who continued to practice their faith knew little about it other than the rituals of everyday life. In the last years of the Soviet era and the two decades after the breakup of the USSR, Islam was caught up in the political as well as religious controversies that developed in Tajikistan during this upheaval. There was an upsurge of attention to Islam, in a religious sense for some, a cultural and nationalist sense for others, and as a bogeyman for yet others. The Islamic Rebirth Party of Tajikistan (IRPT), the only legal Islamic political party in post-Soviet Central Asia, along with the head of the religious establishment in the republic, the qadi, joined with secular groups advocating reforms that would promote political and economic change. The power struggle between neo-Soviet ruling elites and the opposition led to a civil war (1992-97) in which the neo-Soviets prevailed. Tajikistan’s post-Soviet constitution reflects the emphatic secularism of the neo-Soviets, despite the objections of the IRPT. The post-civil-war government has also enacted legislation reestablishing Soviet-style constraints on Islamic institutions and personnel and has used its power to thwart genuinely pluralistic politics. The IRPT as well as secular opposition parties have felt the effects of the rigged elections and harassment by the regime.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Akobirsho T. “Tazohurot dar Badakhshon” Javononi Tojikiston 1992 March 14 1
-
Amnesty International Amnesty International 1999 Annual Report on Tajikistan www.amnesty.org/ailib/aireport/ar99/eur60.htm
-
Atkin M. The Subtlest Battle. Islam in Soviet Tajikistan 1989a Philadelphia
-
Atkin M. “The Survival of Islam in Soviet Tajikistan,” Middle East Journal 1989b 43 4 605 618
-
Atkin M. Bremmer I. & Taras R. “Tajikistan: reform, reaction, and civil war,” New States, New Politics: Building the Post-Soviet Nations 1997 Cambridge 602 627
-
Atovulloyev D. “Tajiks Head for Stone Age” Moscow News 1999 October 13
-
Azamova A. “S ploshchadi svobody—k svobode?” Moskovskie novosti USSR Today 1991 September 6 39
-
Azamova A. “Ploshchad’ Shokhidon protiv ploshchadi Ozodi” Moskovskie novosti Russia & CIS Today 1992a 18 32
-
Azamova A. “Khodzhiakbar Turadzhonzoda” Moskovskie novosti 1992b August 30 11
-
Azamova A. “The Iranian model of an Islamic republic is probably not likely to fit Tajikistan” Moscow News 1992c September 6
-
Babakhanov U. “Kazhetsia, v Tadzhikistane oboidutsia bez ‘golubykh kasok’,” Komsomol’skaia pravda 1993 January 12 1
-
Babakhanov U. & Ganelin A. “Budet li v Dushanbe ploshchad’ pobedivshei oppozitsii?” Komsomol’skaia pravda 1992 May 22 1
-
Babakhanov U. & Mursaliev A. “Pust’ govoriat ob islamskom Tadzhikistane. A kazi protiv” Komsomol’skaia pravda 1991 October 4 1
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: Authorities targeting IRP and Jehovah’s Witness unregistered worship” Forum 18 News Service, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1511 15 November 2010
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: Your children will become extremists and terrorists” Forum 18 News Service, 2 September 2010, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1483
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: When is a mosque not a mosque?” Forum 18 News Service, 25 January 2011a, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1532
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: Ban on religious education abroad without state permission to be adopted soon?” Forum 18 News Service, 26 May 2011b, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id-1575
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: ‘This is not the first time...’” Forum 18 News Service, 28 June 2011c, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1586
-
Bayram M. & Kinahan J. “Tajikistan: Tajikistan religious freedom survey, March 2011” Forum 18 News Service, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1553, 17 March 2011
-
Bennigsen A. & Lemercier-Quelquejay C. “ ‘Official’ Islam in the Soviet Union” Religion in Communist Lands 1979 Autumn 148 159
-
Bykova V. “Edinstvo protivopolozhnostei” Kommunist Tadzhikistana 1989 5 45 46
-
Carley J. “Massacre haunts Soviet Moslems of Tajikistan” Financial Times 1991 February 15
-
Corley F. “Tajikistan: Ban on children in worship ‘once Ramadan is over’?” Forum 18 News Service, 16 August 2011a, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1602
-
Bayram M. “Tajikistan: ‘Religious activity is only banned up to the age of 18’,” Forum 18 News Service, 21 July 2011b, www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1595
-
Dudoignon S.A. Djalili M.-R. , Grare F. & Akiner S. “Political Parties and Forces in Tajikistan, 1989-1993” Tajikistan: The Trials of Independence 1997 New York 52 85
-
Gretsky S. “Civil War in Tajikistan and its International Repercussions” Critique 1995 Spring 3 24
-
Bayram M. “Qadi Akbar Turajonzoda” Central Asia Monitor 1994 1 16 24
-
Gubarev V. “Instability in Tajikistan” The Moscow Times 1994 November 17
-
Hambly G. Central Asia 1969 New York
-
Hazard J.N. The Soviet System of Government 1980 5th ed. Chicago
-
Heathershaw J. Post-Conflict Tajikistan 2009 London and New York
-
Heathershaw J. & Roche S. “A recipe for radicalisation: the campaign against Islam in Tajikistan” Open Democracy 2011 January 17 www.opendemocracy.net
-
Human Rights Watch World Report 2000. Tajikistan www.hrw.org/wr2k
-
Istad A. “Davlati millī chī guna boyad?” Adabiyot va san”at 1992 June 4 6
-
Jonson L. Tajikistan in the New Central Asia 2006 London
-
Karpov A. “Popytka svergnut’ pravitel’stvo natsional’nogo primireniia Tadzhikistana ne udalas’,” Izvestiia 1992 October 12 1
-
Keldiev I. “Farjomi khudnoshinosī,” Sadoi sharq 1989 7 95 105
-
Keller S. To Moscow, Not Mecca 2001 Westport, Conn.
-
Khalid A. Islam after Communism 2007 Berkeley
-
“Konstitutsiyai RSS Tojikiston,” Entsiklopediyai Sovetii Tojik 1981 III Dushanbe 434 435
-
Larsen “Putch ne udalsia,” Rossiiskie vesti 1992 October 31 2
-
LeVine S. “Tajikistan Slides Deeper Into Political Abyss” The Washington Post 1992 September 7 A20
-
Lukin A. & Ganelin A. “Podpol’nyi obkom deistvuet” Komsomol’skaia pravda 1991 March 23 2
-
MacWilliam I. “Ex-Communist Declared Victor in Disputed Tajik Race” Los Angeles Times 1994 November 8
-
Malashenko A.V. “80-e: Novyi politicheskii start islama,” Vostok 1991 5 52 63
-
McElroy C. “Dapper Islamist cuts revolutionary cord” The Guardian 1998 April 10 via Nexis
-
Missiri M. “Emomali Rakhmonov ‘stroit demokratiiu’,” Segodnia 1993 June 29 4
-
Najibullah F. “Tajikistan: Referendum To Ask Voters To Extend President’s Term” Headlines RFE/RL (Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty), www.rferl.org 14 March 2003
-
Bayram M. “Salafi Ban Reflects Tajik Officials’ Growing Fear” 9 January 2009a, www.rferl.org/content/Salafi_Ban_Reflects_Tajik_Officials_Growing_Fear/1368347.html
-
Bayram M. “Tajiks Target Obscure Islamic Group For Prosecution” 14 May 2009b, www.rferl.org/content/Tajiks_Target_Obscure_Islamic_Group_For_Prosecution?1731761.Html
-
Bayram M. “Presidential Party Wins Tajik Landslide, But Who Came in Second?” www.rferl.org 1 March 2010
-
Bayram M. “Tajik Government To Issue List Of Approved Sermon Topics” www.rferl.org/content/tajikistan_government_orders_mosques/2271961.html 10 January 2011
-
Nuri A. Ānsu-ye siāsat (composed of various writings by Nuri which Mirrahim edited into a volume), n.p. (Komita-ye farhangi-e nehzat-e eslāmi-e Tājikestān), n.d.
-
Nuri A. “Nasihatnoma” Charoghi rūz 1996 91 2 2
-
Nuri A. & Turajonzoda A. “My upolnomocheny zaiavit’ . . .” Charoghi rūz 1993 2 71 2
-
Olimova S. “Politicheskii islam i konflikt v Tadzhikistane” Tsentral’naia Aziia i Kavkaz 1999 4 5 133 142
-
Olimova S. & Olimov M. “Obrazovannyi klass Tadzhikistana v peripetiiakh XX v.” Vostok 1991 no. 5 95 103
-
Pons P. “Communists versus Islam” Manchester Guardian Weekly 1991 October 6 15
-
Pospielovsky D.V. A History of Marxist-Leninist Atheism and Soviet Antireligious Policies 1987 I New York
-
Rajabian “Tajikistan: Islamic Party’s Leader Explains Strategy” 2 October 2006, RFE/RL, www.rferl.org
-
Rakowska-Harmstone T. Russia and Nationalism in Central Asia 1970 Baltimore and London
-
Rotar’ I. “Rakhmon Nabiev khranit svoi sekrety” Nezavisimaia gazeta 1992 November 3 3
-
Roy O. Djalili M.-R. , Grare F. & Akiner S. “Is the Conflict in Tajikistan a Model for Conflicts Throughout Central Asia?” Tajikistan: The Trials of Independence 1997 New York 132 147
-
Saidbaev T.S. Islam i obshchestvo 1984 2nd ed. Moscow
-
Sattorov A. “Taftishi hamdigarii kori ideologī” Kommunisti Tojikiston 1987 6 46 49
-
Schwirtz M. “On the Rise in Tajikistan, Islam Worries and Authoritarian Government” The New York Times 2011 July 16
-
Shermatova S. “We Are Ready For A Dialogue With Russia, And Only With Her” Moscow News 1993 August 11
-
Sodiqov A. “Tajik Authorities Impose Heavier Restrictions on Islamic Education” The Central Asia-Caucasus Analyst 13 13 6 July 2011, www.cacianalyst.org.
-
Tadjbakhsh S. “The Tajik Spring of 1992” Central Asia Monitor 1993 2 21 29
-
Turajonzoda A. “Nel’zia verit’ to, vo chto mozhno zastavit’ narod ne verit’,” Charoghi rūz 1996 92 no. 3 4
-
Turajonzoda A. “Hojī Akbar Turajonzoda: ‘Charo man az Rahmonov pushtibonī mekunam?” RFE/RL, 5 September 2006, www.ozodi.org
-
Ulmasov R. “Kori ateistī: problema va mulohiza,” Zanoni Tojikiston 1989 6 15
-
Wright R. “Report from Turkestan” The New Yorker 1992 6 53 75
-
Yorov H. & Qarshiboev N. “Loihai qaror kujo shud?” Jumhuriyat 1991 October 4 1
-
Yorov H. , Qarshiboev N. & Haidarsho Kh. “Oyo Tajikiston jumhuriyati islomi meshavad?” Jumhuriyat 1991 October 24 2
-
11
ITAR-TASS, 12 August 1999, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 13 August 1999, via World News Connection.
-
13
Radio Tajikistan, 28 February 1998, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 1 March 1998; idem, 8 September 1998, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 11 September 1998; idem, 5 November 1998, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 9 November 1998, via WNC.
-
16
Interfax, 7 October 1999, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 12 October 1999; ITAR-TASS, 4, 5 and 7 November 1999, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 5, 8, and 8 November 1999.
-
27
Idem, 13 March 1986.
-
37
Voice of Free Tajikistan, 19 April 1997, FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 22 April 1997, via WNC.
-
40
Asia-Plus, 2 September 2006, via WNC.
-
41
Khovar-TASS, 27 April 1992, photocopied in Russia & CIS Today, 27 April 1992, p. 17.
-
43
ITAR-TASS, 18 October 1999, via Nexis; Interfax, 12 November 1999, via Nexis; Radio Tajikistan, 12 November 1999, BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, 16 November 1999, via Nexis.
-
49
TadzhikTA-TASS, 30 September 1991, transcript in USSR Today, 30 September 1991, p. 6; al-Hayāt, 11 December 1992.
-
51
Op. cit., pp. 18-19.
-
59
ITAR-TASS, 26 May 1992, Russia & CIS Today, 26 May 1992, p. 28.
-
60
Interfax, 12 June 1992, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 15 June 1992, p. 49.
-
62
Idem, 28 April 1999, FBIS, Daily Report. Near East and South Asia, 30 April 1999, via WNC.
-
63
Idem, 12 January 2000, FBIS, Daily Report. Near East and South Asia, 18 January 2000, via WNC.
-
65
Russian Press Digest, 1 November 1991, via Nexis; Interfax, 6 October 1992, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 7 October 1992, 51-52; Reuters, 1 December 1991, via Nexis; “Gahvora junboni millat,” Firuza, 1991, no. 2 (February), p. 4.
-
66
Istad; Reuters, 12 May 1992.
-
69
Interfax, 11 August 1992, in FBIS, Daily Report. Central Eurasia, 12 August 1992, p. 56.
-
74
Khovar, 13 January 2012, via BBC Monitoring Central Asia Unit, 27 January 2012, via Nexis.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 460 | 60 | 9 |
| Full Text Views | 121 | 2 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 61 | 7 | 0 |
Token Constitutionalism and Islamic Opposition in Tajikistan
In: Journal of Persianate StudiesSearch for other papers by Muriel Atkin in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
Tajikistan is a predominantly Muslim country where the concept of having a constitution is not controversial, but the content of that constitution is. Roughly seventy years of Soviet rule over the territory that became independent Tajikistan at the end of 1991 introduced constitutions as a norm, although the rights the constitutions appeared to accord did not jibe with political reality. The years of Soviet rule also created an environment hostile to Islam, as a result of which some of Tajikistan’s inhabitants ceased to be believers, while many who continued to practice their faith knew little about it other than the rituals of everyday life. In the last years of the Soviet era and the two decades after the breakup of the USSR, Islam was caught up in the political as well as religious controversies that developed in Tajikistan during this upheaval. There was an upsurge of attention to Islam, in a religious sense for some, a cultural and nationalist sense for others, and as a bogeyman for yet others. The Islamic Rebirth Party of Tajikistan (IRPT), the only legal Islamic political party in post-Soviet Central Asia, along with the head of the religious establishment in the republic, the qadi, joined with secular groups advocating reforms that would promote political and economic change. The power struggle between neo-Soviet ruling elites and the opposition led to a civil war (1992-97) in which the neo-Soviets prevailed. Tajikistan’s post-Soviet constitution reflects the emphatic secularism of the neo-Soviets, despite the objections of the IRPT. The post-civil-war government has also enacted legislation reestablishing Soviet-style constraints on Islamic institutions and personnel and has used its power to thwart genuinely pluralistic politics. The IRPT as well as secular opposition parties have felt the effects of the rigged elections and harassment by the regime.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 460 | 60 | 9 |
| Full Text Views | 121 | 2 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 61 | 7 | 0 |
