Reform versus Transformation: Reflections on the Legacy of Corbynismâs Economic Programme
In: Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Mary Robertson in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
In the context of divisive disagreements about how the British left should orient itself towards the current Labour Party, this intervention uses the Gorzian category of non-reformist reforms to critically evaluate the 2017â19 policy programme developed by the Corbyn-led Labour Party and draw out the implications for current strategic debates. It argues that the radical core of the Corbynite economic programme lay in its proposals for widening ownership and extending economic democracy, but that there was a tension between commodified and decommodifying visions of these proposals. Exploring the different conceptions of political transformation implicit within each vision, the paper argues that only the latter had the potential to be non-reformist in the Gorzian sense. However, Gorz was concerned not merely with a reformâs content but also with how it was formulated and pursued. The paper ends by arguing that the transformative potential of the economic programme was not reflected in its political strategy and that this has important lessons for strategy today.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Akbar, Amna A. 2020, âDemands for a Democratic Political Economyâ, Harvard Law Review, 134, 90: 90â118.
-
Alperowitz, Gar 2013, What Then Must We Do? Straight Talk about the Next American Revolution, Vermont: Chelsea Green Publishing.
-
Anon. 2020, âWeâll Own It, Kind Of, Maybe, One Day: Nationalisation in the Labour Leadership Contestâ, New Socialist, 22 February, available at: <https://newsocialist.org.uk/well-own-it-kind-maybe-one-day-nationalisation-labour-leadership-contest/>.
-
BBC News 2023, âKeir Starmer: Labour Wonât Spend its Way out of Tory âMessââ, 5 January, available at: <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64166870>.
-
Beckett, Andy 2019, âThe New Left Economics: How a Network of Thinkers Is Transforming Capitalismâ, The Guardian, 25 June, available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/news/2019/jun/25/the-new-left-economics-how-a-network-of-thinkers-is-transforming-capitalism>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Berry, Christine 2019, âLabourâs Promise to Democratiseâ, International Politics and Society, 26 November, available at: <https://www.ips-journal.eu/regions/europe/labours-promise-to-democratise-3895/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Berry, Christine 2020, âLabourâs Rival Factions Do Share Common Ground, Which Is Where the Partyâs Future Liesâ, The Guardian, 3 February, available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/feb/03/labour-factions-common-ground-localised-politics>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Berry, Christine and Joe Guinan 2019, People Get Ready! Preparing for a Corbyn Government, London: OR Books.
-
Bhattacharyya, Gargi 2020, âFive (Bad) Habits of Nearly Successful Political Projectsâ, in Futures of Socialism: The Pandemic and the Post-Corbyn Era, edited by Grace Blakely, pp. 41â49, London: Verso.
-
Bolton, Matt and Frederick Harry Pitts 2018, Corbynism: A Critical Approach, Bingley: Emerald Publishing Ltd.
-
Clarke, Simon 1991, âState, Class Struggle, and the Reproduction of Capitalâ, in Clarke (ed.) 1991, pp. 183â203.
-
Clarke, Simon (ed.) 1991, The State Debate: Capital and Class, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Corbyn, Jeremy 2018, âJeremy Corbyn Speech at the EEFâ, 20 February, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/press/jeremy-corbyn-speech-eef/>.
-
Fine, Ben and Alfredo Saad-Filho 2016, âThirteen Things You Need to Know About Neoliberalismâ, preprint, available at: <https://eprints.soas.ac.uk/22614/1/Fine_Saad-Filho_22614.pdf> [appearing in Critical Sociology, Volume 43, Issue 4â5, pp. 685â706].
-
Fine, Ben and Alfredo Saad-Filho 2019, âEconomic Policies for the Many, Not the Few: Assessing the Economic Strategy of the Labour Partyâ, Theory and Struggle, 120: 76â88.
-
Gindin, Sam 2016, âChasing Utopiaâ, Jacobin, 3 October, available at: <https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/03/workers-control-coops-wright-wolff-alperovitz>.
-
Gorz, André 1964, Strategy for Labour: A Radical Proposal, Boston: Beacon Press.
-
Gorz, André 1968, âReform and Revolutionâ, in The Socialist Register 1968: A Survey of Movements & Ideas, edited by Ralph Miliband and John Saville, pp. 111â143, London: The Merlin Press.
-
Guinan, J. and T. Hanna 2018, âDemocratic Ownership in the New Economyâ, in McDonnell (ed.) 2018, pp. 108â25.
-
Hanieh, Adam 2021, âThe Commodities Fetish? Financialisation and Finance Capital in the US Oil Industryâ, Historical Materialism, 29, 4: 70â113.
-
Harris, Max 2022, âChildcare, Criminal Justice, and Some Ways of Thinking about Public Ownershipâ, The Round-Up, 13 November, available at: <https://maxharris.substack.com/p/childcare-criminal-justice-and-some>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Hirsch, Joachim 1991, âThe Fordist Security State and the New Social Movementsâ, in Clarke (ed.) 1991, pp. 142â56.
-
Holloway, John and Sol Picciotto 1991, âCapital, Crisis and the Stateâ, in Clarke (ed.) 1991, pp. 109â41.
-
Institute for Fiscal Studies 2019, âLabour Manifesto: An Initial Reaction from IFS Researchersâ, 21 November, available at: <https://election2019.ifs.org.uk/article/labour-manifesto-an-initial-reaction-from-ifs-researchers>.
-
Jacobs, Michael 2023, âA Keir Starmer Government Might Be More Radical Than You Thinkâ, The Guardian, 4 January, available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/04/keir-starmer-government-labour-leader>.
-
Jessop, Bob 1991, âAccumulation Strategies, State Forms and Hegemonic Projectsâ, in Clarke (ed.) 1991, pp. 157â82.
-
Keucheyan, Razmig 2020, âEconomic Planning Can Succeed when the Market Failsâ, Tribune, 26 April, available at: <https://tribunemag.co.uk/2020/04/democratic-planning-can-succeed-where-the-market-fails>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Klug, Adam and Emma Rees 2019, âHow Big Organising Worksâ, in Corbynism from Below, edited by Mark Perryman, pp. 120â135, London: Lawrence and Wishart.
-
Knox, Robert 2021, âNeoliberalism, Labour Law and New Labourâs Turn to Constitutionalismâ, in The New Labour Constitution Twenty Years On, edited by Michael Gordon and Adam Tucker, Oxford: Hart Publishing.
-
Lawrence, Mathew 2022, âLabour Is Right: Itâs Time for Britain to Profit from its Own Renewablesâ, The Guardian, 28 September, available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/28/labour-public-ownership-affordable-energy-net-zero-britain>.
-
Lawrence, Mathew 2019, âThe Financial Times is Right â Labourâs Ownership Funds Will Transfer Wealth and Powerâ, openDemocracy, 2 September, available at: <https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/the-financial-times-is-right-labours-ownership-funds-will-transfer-wealth-and-power/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Marx, Karl 1991, Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume Three, translated by David Fernbach, London: Penguin.
-
Massey, Doreen 2007, World City, Cambridge: Polity Press.
-
McDonnell, John 2019, âFull Text of John McDonnellâs Speech on the First 100 Days of a Labour Governmentâ, 9 December, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/press/full-text-of-john-mcdonnells-speech-on-the-first-100-days-of-a-labour-government/>.
-
McDonnell, John (ed.) 2018, Economics for the Many, London: Verso.
-
Meadway, James 2020, âLabourâs Legal Turnâ, The Social Review, 5 April, available at: <https://www.thesocialreview.co.uk/2020/04/05/labours-legal-turn/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Miliband, Ralph 1960, âThe Sickness of Labourismâ, New Left Review, I, 1, available at: <https://newleftreview.org/issues/i1/articles/ralph-miliband-the-sickness-of-labourism>.
-
Miliband, Ralph 1969, The State in Capitalist Society, London: Quartet Books.
-
Miliband, Ralph 1977, Marxism and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Murray, Andrew 2022, Is Socialism Impossible in Britain?, London: Verso.
-
Panitch, Leo and Colin Leys 2020, Searching for Socialism, London: Verso.
-
Poulantzas, Nicos 1969, âThe Problem of the Capitalist Stateâ, New Left Review, I, 58: 67â78, available at: <https://newleftreview.org/issues/i58/articles/nicos-poulantzas-the-problem-of-the-capitalist-state>.
-
Robertson, Mary 2020, âLeft Economics from Below? Defending the Programme after Corbynâ, New Socialist, 25 August, available at: <http://newsocialist.org.uk/left-economics-below-defending-programme-after-corbyn/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Robertson, Mary 2022, âGreat British Energy Falls Far Short of What the Public and the Planet Needâ, Labour List, 29 September, available at: <https://labourlist.org/2022/09/great-british-energy-falls-far-short-of-what-the-public-and-the-planet-need/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
Seymour, Richard 2016, Corbyn: Against All Odds, London: Verso.
-
Sharzer, Greg 2017, âCooperatives as Transitional Economicsâ, Review of Radical Political Economics, 49, 3: 456â476.
-
The Guardian 2022, âLabour MP Apsana Begum Alleges âHarassmentâ from Partyâ, 28 September, available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/sep/28/labour-mp-apsana-begum-alleges-harassment-from-party>.
-
The Independent 2020, âAnti-Corbyn Labour Officials Worked to Lose General Election to Oust Leader, Leaked Dossier Findsâ, The Independent, 13 April, available at: <https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-leak-report-corbyn-election-whatsapp-antisemitism-tories-yougov-poll-a9462456.html>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2017a, For the Many Not the Few, London: The Labour Party.
-
The Labour Party 2017b, Richer Britain, Richer Lives, London: The Labour Party.
-
The Labour Party 2017c, Alternative Models of Ownership, London: The Labour Party, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Alternative-Models-of-Ownership.pdf>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2019a, Itâs Time for Real Change: The Labour Party Manifesto 2019, London: The Labour Party.
-
The Labour Party 2019b, Labourâs Green Transformation Fund, London: The Labour Party, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Green-Transformation-Fund.pdf>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2019c, Regional Manifestos, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/page/regional-manifestos/>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2019d, Democratising Local Public Services: A Plan for 21st Century Insourcing, London: The Labour Party, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Democratising-Local-Public-Services.pdf>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2019e, Universal Public Services: The Right to a Good Life, London: The Labour Party, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/12730_19-Universal-Basic-Services_v5.pdf>, accessed 3 January 2023.
-
The Labour Party 2019f, Funding Real Change, November, available at: <https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Funding-Real-Change-1.pdf>.
-
Williams, Alex 2016, âCorbynism and the Parameters of Powerâ, in Corbyn and the Future of Labour, London: Verso.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 695 | 0 | 0 |
| Full Text Views | 1132 | 576 | 13 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1455 | 880 | 8 |
Reform versus Transformation: Reflections on the Legacy of Corbynismâs Economic Programme
In: Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Mary Robertson in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
In the context of divisive disagreements about how the British left should orient itself towards the current Labour Party, this intervention uses the Gorzian category of non-reformist reforms to critically evaluate the 2017â19 policy programme developed by the Corbyn-led Labour Party and draw out the implications for current strategic debates. It argues that the radical core of the Corbynite economic programme lay in its proposals for widening ownership and extending economic democracy, but that there was a tension between commodified and decommodifying visions of these proposals. Exploring the different conceptions of political transformation implicit within each vision, the paper argues that only the latter had the potential to be non-reformist in the Gorzian sense. However, Gorz was concerned not merely with a reformâs content but also with how it was formulated and pursued. The paper ends by arguing that the transformative potential of the economic programme was not reflected in its political strategy and that this has important lessons for strategy today.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 695 | 0 | 0 |
| Full Text Views | 1132 | 576 | 13 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1455 | 880 | 8 |
