Möchten Sie über diese Zeitschrift informiert bleiben? Klicken Sie bitte auf die Buttons, um unsere Alerts zu abonnieren.
Möchten Sie über diese Zeitschrift informiert bleiben? Klicken Sie bitte auf die Buttons, um unsere Alerts zu abonnieren.
Ilyenkovâs Dialectics of the Ideal and Engelsâs Dialectics of Nature
On Ilyenkovâs Supposed Affinity with Western Marxism
in Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Rogney Piedra Arencibia in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
Within the current resurgence of interest in E.V. Ilyenkov, the influence of Engels on Ilyenkovâs work is either overlooked or denied, making Ilyenkov seem closer to Western Marxism than he actually is. In this paper, by considering Engelsâs place in his philosophy, I show that Ilyenkovâs approach is fundamentally hostile to many of Western Marxismâs main views. Ilyenkov, like Engels, conceives philosophy as Logic and affirms the âallianceâ between philosophy and the natural sciences against speculative metaphysics. In this regard, he develops an original cosmological hypothesis based on Engelsâs insights on the hierarchy of matterâs forms of movement and provides a remarkable account of the ideal as an attribute of nature that reproduces its concrete universality through social labour, the active transformation of natureâs phenomena into objects stamped with the seal of our subjectivity.
Kauf
Sofortzugang erwerben (PDF-Download und unbegrenzter Online-Zugang):
Institutszugang
Melden Sie sich mit Open Athens, Shibboleth oder Ihren institutionellen Anmeldedaten an.
Persönliche Anmeldung
Melden Sie sich mit Ihrem brill.com-Konto an
-
Althusser, Louis 2006, Philosophy of the Encounter: Later Writings, 1978â87, edited by Oliver Corpet and François Matheron, translated by G.M. Goshgarian, London: Verso.
-
Anderson, Perry 1989, Considerations on Western Marxism, London: Verso.
-
Arthur, Christopher J. 2004, The New Dialectic and Marxâs âCapitalâ, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Bakhurst, David 2001, âIlyenkov on Aesthetics: Realism, Imagination, and the End of Artâ, Mind, Culture and Activity, 8, 2: 187â199.
-
Bakhurst, David 2019, âPunks versus Zombies: Evald Ilyenkov and the Battle for Soviet Philosophyâ, in Philosophical Thought in Russia in the Second Half of the 20th Century: A Contemporary View from Russia and Abroad, edited by Vladislav A. Lektorsky and M. Bykova, pp. 53â78, London: Bloomsbury Academic.
-
Bakhurst, David and Carol Padden 1991, âThe Meshcheryakov Experiment: Soviet Work on the Education of Blind-Deaf Childrenâ, Learning and Instruction, 1: 201â215.
-
Benjamin, Walter 2008, Tesis sobre la historia y otros fragmentos, México, D.F.: Itaca.
-
Candioti, Miguel 2014, âEl carácter enigmático de las Tesis sobre Feuerbach y su secretoâ, IsegorÃa, 50: 45â70.
-
Carrión, VÃctor Antonio 2017, âEvald Iliénkov: vida e ideasâ, in Dialéctica de lo abstracto y lo concreto en âEl Capitalâ de Marx, edited by Evald VasÃlievich Iliénkov, Quito: Edithor.
-
Colletti, Lucio 1973, Marxism and Hegel, London: NLB.
-
Coulter, Jeff 1971, âMarxism and the Engels Paradoxâ, in Socialist Register 1971, edited by Ralph Milibandand John Saville, pp. 129â156, London: The Merlin Press.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1976a, âLudwig Feuerbach and the End of German Classical Philosophyâ, in Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Selected Works in Three Volumes, Volume 3, pp. 335â376, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1976b, âSocialism: Utopian and Scientificâ, in Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Selected Works in Three Volumes, Volume 3, pp. 93â151, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1987a, âAnti-Dühringâ, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 25, Engels: Anti-Dühring & Dialectics of Nature, New York: International Publishers.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1987b, âDialectics of Natureâ, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 25, Engels: Anti-Dühring & Dialectics of Nature, New York: International Publishers.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1987c, âPrefacio a la primera edición alemana [Preface to the First German Edition]â, in Miseria de la filosofÃa [The Poverty of Philosophy], edited by Karl Marx, México, D.F.: Siglo XXI.
-
Engels, Friedrich 1990, âLudwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophyâ, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 26, Engels: 1882â89, New York: International Publishers.
-
Fromm, Erich 2004, Marxâs Concept of Man, London: Continuum.
-
Goldmann, Lucien 2009, Lukács and Heidegger: Towards a New Philosophy, translated by William Q. Boelhower, New York: Routledge.
-
Gramsci, Antonio 1966, El materialismo histórico y la filosofÃa de Benedetto Croce, La Habana: Edición Revolucionaria.
-
Heinz Holz, Hans 2004, Reflexión y Praxis. Estudios para la teorÃa marxista hoy, La Habana: Editorial de Ciencias Sociales.
-
Hoffman, John 1975, Marxism and the Theory of Praxis, London: Lawrence and Wishart.
-
Holloway, John 2005, Change the World Without Taking Power: The Meaning of Revolution Today, London: Pluto Press.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 1997, âDe Ãdeolos e idealesâ, Contracorriente, 10.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 2009, La dialéctica antigua como forma de pensamiento, Las Villas: Centro de Documentación e Información CientÃfico Técnica Universidad Central âMarta Abreuâ.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 2014a, âDialéctica y cosmovisión [Dialectics and Worldview]â, in La dialéctica leninista y la metafÃsica del positivismo [Dialectics and the Metaphysics of Positivism], Quito: Edithor.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 2014b, La dialéctica leninista y la metafÃsica del positivismo, Quito: Edithor.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 2017a, La dialéctica de lo abstracto y lo concreto en âEl Capitalâ de Marx, Quito: Edithor.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich 2017b, âLo universalâ, in Dialéctica de lo abstracto y lo concreto en âEl capitalâ de Marx, edited by Evald VasÃlievich Iliénkov, pp. 425â435, Quito: Edithor.
-
Iliénkov, Evald VasÃlievich, V.V. Davydov and Vladislav A. Lektorsky 2017, âInteracciónâ, in Dialéctica de lo abstracto y lo concreto en âEl capitalâ de Marx, edited by Evald VasÃlievich Iliénkov, pp. 420â422, Quito: Edithor.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 1974 [1967], âFrom the Marxist-Leninist Point of Viewâ, available at: <https://www.marxists.org/archive/ilyenkov/works/articles/marxist-leninist.htm>, accessed April 2020.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 1975, âHumanism and Scienceâ, in Progress, available at: <https://www.marxists.org/archive/ilyenkov/works/articles/humanism-science.htm>, accessed April 2020.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 2002, Shkola dolzhna uchitâ myslit [Schools Must Teach How to Think], Moscow-Voronezh: Modek.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald Vasilyevich 2007, âOur Schools Must Teach How to Think!â, Journal of Russian and East European Psychology, 45, 4: 9â49.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 2009, The Ideal in Human Activity, Pacifica, CA: Marxists Internet Archive.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 2014, âDialectics of the Idealâ, in Levant and Oittinen (eds.) 2014, pp. 25â78.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald Vasilyevich 2017, âCosmology of the Spiritâ, Stasis, 5, 2: 164â190.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald V. 2018a, âGeorg Lukach. «K (voprosu ob) ontologii obshchestvennogo bytiya. Lozhnaya i podlinnaya ontologiya Gegelya» [Georg Lukács. Ontology of Social Being. Hegelâs False and True Ontology]â, in Idealânoe. I realânostâ. 1960â1979, edited by Elena I. Illesh, pp. 491â495, Moscow: Kanon+.
-
Ilyenkov, Evald Vasilyevich 2018b, Intelligent Materialism: Essays on Hegel and Dialectics, edited and translated by Evgeni V. Pavlov, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Jacoby, Russell 1981, Dialectic of Defeat: Contours of Western Marxism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Kangal, Kaan 2020a, âEngelsâs Emergentist Dialecticsâ, Monthly Review, 72, 6: 18â27.
-
Kangal, Kaan 2020b, Friedrich Engels and the Dialectics of Nature, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Kohan, Néstor 1998, Marx en su (Tercer) Mundo, Buenos Aires: Biblos.
-
Lenin, Vladimir Ilyich 1977, Collected Works, Volume 14, Materialism and Empiriocriticism, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Levant, Alex 2014a, âE.V. Ilyenkov and Creative Soviet Marxism: An Introduction to Dialectics of the Idealâ, in Levant and Oittinen (eds.) 2014, pp. 4â23.
-
Levant, Alex 2014b, âEmancipating Open Marxism: E.V. Ilyenkovâs Post-Cartesian Anti-Dualismâ, in Levant and Oittinen (eds.) 2014, pp. 184â200.
-
Levant, Alex 2015, âThe Ideal and the Dream-World: Evald Ilyenkov and Walter Benjamin on the Significance of Material Objectsâ, in The Practical Essence of Man: The âActivity Approachâ in Late Soviet Philosophy, edited by Andrey Maidansky and Vesa Oittinen, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Levant, Alex and Vesa Oittinen 2014, âIlyenkov in the Context of Soviet Philosophical Culture: An Interview with Sergey Mareevâ, in Levant and Oittinen (eds.) 2014, pp. 81â96.
-
Levant, Alex and Vesa Oittinen (eds.) 2014, Dialectics of the Ideal, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Long, Anthony Arthur and David N. Sedley 1987 (eds.), The Hellenistic Philosophers, Volume 1, Translations of the Principal Sources, with Philosophical Commentary, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Losurdo, Domenico 2019, El marxismo occidental: Cómo nació, cómo murió, y cómo puede resucitar, Madrid: Editorial Trotta.
-
Lukács, Georg 1966, Estética, Volume I, Barcelona: Grijalbo.
-
Lukács, Georg 1971a, History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics, translated by Rodney Livingstone, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
-
Lukács, Georg 1971b, The Theory of the Novel: A Historico-Philosophical Essay on the Forms of Great Epic Literature, translated by Anna Bostock, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
-
Lukács, Georg 1975, The Young Hegel, translated by Rodney Livingstone, London: The Merlin Press.
-
Lukács, Georg 1978, Ontology of Social Being, Volume 1, Hegelâs False and his Genuine Ontology, translated by David Fernbach, London: The Merlin Press.
-
Lukács, Georg 1980, The Destruction of Reason, translated by Peter R. Palmer, London: The Merlin Press.
-
Maidansky, Andrey 2005, âMetamorphoses of the Idealâ, Studies in East European Thought, 57, 3: 289â304, <doi:10.1007/s11212-11005-1413-1413>.
-
Maidansky, Andrey 2013, âThe Dialectical Logic of Evald llyenkov and Western European Marxismâ, in Russian Thought in Europe, edited by Teresa Obolevich, Tomasz Homa and Józef Bremer, Kraków: Akademia Ignatianum.
-
Maidansky, Andrey and Evgeni Pavlov 2018, âEvald Ilyenkovâs âCreative Marxismâ. A Review of E.V. Ilyenkov: ZhitâFilosofiei [To Live by Philosophy] by Sergey Mareevâ, Historical Materialism, 26, 4: 214â226.
-
Mareev, Sergei 1996, âA Philosopher Under Suspicionâ, Socialist Future, 5, 1, available at: <http://www.aworldtowin.net/resources/Ilyenkov.html>.
-
Mareev, Sergey 2008, Iz Istorii Sovetskoi Filosofii: Lukach â Vygotskii â Ilâenkov [From the History of Soviet Philosophy. Lukács â Vygotsky â Ilyenkov], Moscow: Kulâturnaia revoliutsiia.
-
Mareev, Sergey 2016, âLifshits and Ilyenkov on the Nature of the Idealâ, Studies in East European Thought, 68, 4: 319â329, <doi:10.1007/s11212-11016-9264-9267>.
-
Mareyev, Sergei 2005, âCosmology of Mindâ, Studies in East European Thought, 57, 3: 249â259, <doi:10.1007/s11212-005-1412-4>>.
-
Marx, Karl 1988, Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, translated by Martin Milligan, New York: Prometheus Books.
-
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice 1973, Adventures of the Dialectic, translated by Joseph Bien, Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
-
Miller, John 2015, Spinoza and the Stoics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Mondolfo, Rodolfo 1940, El materialismo histórico en Federico Engels, Rosario: Ciencia.
-
Nietzsche, Friedrich 1978, Thus Spoke Zarathustra, translated by R.J. Hollingdale, New York: Penguin Books.
-
Oittinen, Vesa 2000, âIntroduction: Paradoxes of Ilyenkov and the Soviet Philosophyâ, in Evald Ilyenkovâs Philosophy Revisited, edited by Vesa Oittinen, Helsinki: Kikimora Publications.
-
Oittinen, Vesa 2005, âIntroductionâ, Studies in East European Thought, 57, 3: 223â231, <doi:10.1007/s11212-005-1415-1>.
-
Oparin, Alexander I. 1979, âOn the Essence of Lifeâ, Soviet Studies in Philosophy, 18, 3: 19â39.
-
Penzin, Alexei 2018, âContingency and Necessity in Evald Ilyenkovâs Communist Cosmologyâ, e-flux, 88: 1â13.
-
Petrovic, Gajo 1979, âThe Philosophical Concept of Revolutionâ, in Praxis: Yugoslav Essays in the Philosophy and Methodology of the Social Sciences, edited by Mihailo Markovicand Gajo Petrovic, pp. 151â165, Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing Company.
-
Piedra Arencibia, Rogney 2018a, âEl papel del trabajo en el desarrollo del pensamiento humanoâ, Hybris, 9, 2: 173â206.
-
Piedra Arencibia, Rogney 2018b, âUn enfoque marxista de la relación entre lo cognoscitivo y lo valorativoâ, Estudios del Desarrollo Social: Cuba y América Latina, 6, 2: 221â239.
-
Piedra Arencibia, Rogney 2019, Marxismo y dialéctica de la naturaleza [Marxism and Dialectics of Nature], Second Edition, Quito: Edithor.
-
Polishchuk, F. 1995, âVspominaya Igorya Alekseyeva [Remembering Igor Alekseev]â, in Deyatelânostnaya kontseptsiya poznaniya i realânosti [The Active Conception of Knowledge and Reality], edited by Igor S. Alekseev, Moscow: Russo.
-
Prestipino, Giuseppe 1977, El pensamiento filosófico de Engels, México, D.F.: Siglo XXI.
-
RodrÃguez Ugidos, Zaira 1985, FilosofÃa, ciencia y valor, La Habana: Editorial de Ciencias Sociales.
-
RodrÃguez Ugidos, Zaira 1986, Problemas de lógica dialéctica, La Habana: Editorial de Ciencias Sociales.
-
Rosental, M. 1963, Los problemas de la dialéctica en El Capital de Carlos Marx, La Habana: Editora PolÃtica.
-
Rosental, M. and P. Iudin 1946, Diccionario Filosófico Marxista, Montevideo: Ediciones Pueblos Unidos.
-
Rosental, M.M. and E.V. Ilyenkov 1969, âV.I. Lenin y los problemas actuales de la lógica dialécticaâ, available at: <https://www.marxists.org/espanol/ilienkov/1969-lenin-prob-log-dialect.pdf>.
-
Sartre, Jean-Paul 1963, CrÃtica de la razón dialéctica, Buenos Aires: Losada.
-
Sartre, Jean-Paul 1976, âDialectics and Scienceâ, Man and World, 9, 1: 60â74.
-
Sartre, Jean-Paul 2004, Critique of Dialectical Reason, Volume 1, Theory of Practical Ensembles, translated by Alan Sheridan-Smith, London: Verso.
-
Schmidt, Alfred 1971, The Concept of Nature in Marx, London: NLB.
-
Semenov, Nykolay N. 1973, Nauka i obshchestvo [Science and Society], Moscow: Nauka.
-
Spinoza, Benedict 1994a, âA Critique of Traditional Religionâ, in A Spinoza Reader, edited by Edwin Curley, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
-
Spinoza, Benedict 1994b, âEthicsâ, in A Spinoza Reader, edited by Edwin Curley, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
-
van der Linden, Marcel 2007, Western Marxism and the Soviet Union: A Survey of Critical Theories and Debates since 1917, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Vivaldi, Giuliano 2017a, âA Commentary on Evald Ilyenkovâs Cosmology of the Spiritâ, Stasis, 5, 2: 192â203.
-
Vivaldi, Giuliano 2017b, âRethinking Soviet Marxism: The Case of Evald Ilyenkovâ, Historical Materialism, 25, 2: 180â195.
-
Voznyak, Volodymyr and Vira Lymonchenko 2020, âEvald Ilyenkovâs Cosmological Reflectionsâ, Philosophy and Cosmology, 24: 159â169.
-
Vv.Aa. 1986, Estética y marxismo, Barcelona: Planeta-De Agostini.
-
Žižek, Slavoj 2020, Sex and the Failed Absolute, London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
| Insgesamt | Letzte 365 Tage | In den letzten 30 Tagen | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aufrufe von Kurzbeschreibungen | 2799 | 370 | 30 |
| Gesamttextansichten | 141 | 5 | 1 |
| PDF-Downloads | 381 | 14 | 3 |
Ilyenkovâs Dialectics of the Ideal and Engelsâs Dialectics of Nature
On Ilyenkovâs Supposed Affinity with Western Marxism
in Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Rogney Piedra Arencibia in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
Within the current resurgence of interest in E.V. Ilyenkov, the influence of Engels on Ilyenkovâs work is either overlooked or denied, making Ilyenkov seem closer to Western Marxism than he actually is. In this paper, by considering Engelsâs place in his philosophy, I show that Ilyenkovâs approach is fundamentally hostile to many of Western Marxismâs main views. Ilyenkov, like Engels, conceives philosophy as Logic and affirms the âallianceâ between philosophy and the natural sciences against speculative metaphysics. In this regard, he develops an original cosmological hypothesis based on Engelsâs insights on the hierarchy of matterâs forms of movement and provides a remarkable account of the ideal as an attribute of nature that reproduces its concrete universality through social labour, the active transformation of natureâs phenomena into objects stamped with the seal of our subjectivity.
| Insgesamt | Letzte 365 Tage | In den letzten 30 Tagen | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aufrufe von Kurzbeschreibungen | 2799 | 370 | 30 |
| Gesamttextansichten | 141 | 5 | 1 |
| PDF-Downloads | 381 | 14 | 3 |
