Three Republics of Armenia: The Soviet Past and the Politics of Memory in Post-Soviet Armenia (1991â2018)
In: Caucasus SurveySearch for other papers by Mikayel Zolyan in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
Deciding how to relate to the Soviet past is a key question in the politics of memory for the societies and political elites of the post-Soviet countries. Throughout the post-Soviet decades Armenian political and intellectual elites tried to form a complex attitude to the Soviet past, neither rejecting, nor appropriating the Soviet legacy completely, but assimilating it within the paradigm of national history. Within this paradigm Soviet Armenia is viewed as a stage in the development of Armenian nationhood, as âthe second republicâ, which links the first âattemptâ at building a nation-state, âthe first republicâ of 1918â1920, to the â3rd republicâ, i.e. the post-Soviet state of Armenia. This paradigm, in which the Soviet past is neither completely rejected, or accepted, but certain elements of it are integrated into the national history narrative, is optimal for post-Soviet Armenia, given both the peculiarity of Armeniaâs historical experience (particularly the role played by Russia/USSR in the context of Armenian-Turkish relations), as well as the current geopolitical setting, in which Armenia and Russia are formal allies. This attitude, which can be described as âmnemonic ambiguityâ, allows the assertion of an independent and sovereign Armenian state as legitimate, while at the same time avoiding a confrontation with an ally in the realm of memory politics.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
A1Plus. 2017. âHHK Vote Against YELK proposalâ A1Plus, A1Plus, September 5, https://en.a1plus.am/1263091.html, retrieved August 12, 2018.
-
Ablazhei, Natalya. 2011. Deportatsiya Armyan v Altaiskij Krai v 1949 godu [Deportation of Armenians into Altai Region in 1949]. Gumanitarnye Nauki v Sibiri, 1, 116â121. (in Russian).
-
Abrahamian, Levon. 1998. âMother Tongue: Linguistic Nationalism and the Cult of Translation in Postcommunist Armeniaâ, Berkeley Program in Soviet and Post-Soviet Studies Working Paper Series, Berkeley Program in Soviet and Post-Soviet Studies, Berkeley, University of California.
-
Abrahamian, Levon. 2006, Armenian Identity in a Changing World, Costa Mesa, California: Mazda Publishers.
-
Aravot Daily. 2016. V Yerevane Otkryt Paymatnik Amazaspu Babajanyanu [A Monument to Hamazasp Babajanyan was Opened in Yerevan] 23 May, available at http://www.aravot-ru.am/2016/05/23/210759/ (in Russian).
-
Areshev, Andrey. 2017. Armyane Protiv Armyan: Komu I Zachem Nuzhno Pereimenovanie Ulits v Erevane? [Armenians vs. Armenians: Who and Why Needs to Rename Streets in Yerevan?] October 6, available at https://regnum.ru/news/2331214.html (in Russian).
-
Arslanian, Beatriz. 2022. âDespite Everything, Artsakh Celebratesâ, EVN Report, 16 May, 2022.
-
Azg Daily. 2009. Viktor Hambardzumyani Ardzany Ghukas Ghukasyani Ardzani Teghum. [The Statue of Viktor Hambardzumyan in Place of the Statue of Ghukas Ghukasyan] 18 November.
-
Barkhudaryan, Vladimir, ed. 2007. Hayots Patmutyun: 8rd dasarani dasagirq [Armenian History: Textbook for 8th Grade] Yerevan: McMillan Armenia (in Armenian).
-
Barkhudaryan, Vladimir, ed. 2008. Hayots Patmutyun: 9rd dasarani dasagirq [Armenian History: textbook for 9th Grade], Yerevan: McMillan Armenia (in Armenian).
-
Bosswell, David and Jessica Evans, eds. 1999. Representing the Nation: Histories, Heritage and Museums. Routledge: London and New York.
-
Champord.am. 2017 Ov e Fuchiky [Who is FuÄÃk], August 9, (in Armenian) https://champord.am/ove-fuchiky/.
-
Dadrian, Vahakn. 1977. âNationalism in Soviet Armenia â A case Study of Ethnocentrismâ. In G. Simmonds (ed). Nationalism in the USSR and Eastern Europe, 202â258. Detroit: University of Detroit Press.
-
Darieva, Tsypylma. 2008. ââThe Road to Golgothaâ: Representing Loss in Postsocialist Armenia.â Focaal. European Journal of Anthropology, 52 (winter): 92â108.
-
Darieva, Tsypylma. 2015. âFrom Silenced to Voiced. Changing Politics of Memory of Loss in Armeniaâ. In Ts. Darieva and W. Kaschuba, eds., Representations on the Margins of Europe. Politics and Identities in the Baltic and South Caucasian States, 65â88. Frankfurt/Main: Campus Verlag.
-
Demoyan, Hayk. 2017. âNew Stalinist Cult in Armenia?â, Armenian Mirror Spectator, September 21, available at https://mirrorspectator.com/2017/09/21/new-stalinist-cult-armenia.
-
de Waal, Thomas, 2003. Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan Through Peace and War. New York University Press: New York and London.
-
Equestrian Statues, 2021. Hovhannes Baghramian. 2021. Available at https://equestrianstatue.org/baghramian-hovhannes/.
-
Eley Geoff and Ronald Grigor Suny, eds. 1996. Becoming National. Oxford University Press: Oxford and New York.
-
EVN Report. 2017, âEclipseâ, September 15, available at https://www.evnreport.com/raw-unfiltered/eclipse retrieved August 12 2018.
-
Jones, Stephen F. 1994. âOld Ghosts and New Chains: Ethnicity and Memory in the Georgian Republicâ. In R. S. Watson, ed., Memory, History and Opposition Under State Socialism, 149â166. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press.
-
Hewsen, Robert. 2001. Armenia: Historical Atlas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
-
Hovannisian, Richard. 1996. The Republic of Armenia, Vol. IV: Between Crescent and Sickle: Partition and Sovietization. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press.
-
Iskandaryan, Aleksandr. 1999. Armenia: âKarabakhizatsiya Natsionalânoy Istoriiâ [Karabakhization of national history]. In K. Aiermacher & G. Bordyugov, eds., Natsionalnye Istorii v Sovetskom i Postsovetskikh Gosudarstvakh [National Histories in Soviet and Post-Soviet States], 147â160. Moscow: Airo-X (in Russian).
-
Kavkazskiy Uzel. 2012. âKommunisticheskaya Partiya Armeniiâ [Communist Party of Armenia] April 25, (in Russian), available at http://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/205150/.
-
Karasyuk, Dmitri. 2018. âPyanoe Prestuplenie Komdiva Gaiaâ [The Drunken Crime of the Head of Divison Gai]. Diletant, 18 January, (in Russian) available at https://diletant.media/articles/38869830/.
-
Khomizuri, Georgiy. 1997. Sotsialnye Potryaseniya v Sudâba Narodov (na primere Armenii) [Social Shocks in the Fate of the nations (case of Armenia)] Moscow: Intellekt (in Russian).
-
Korostelina, Karina. 2010. âPast Imperfect: The Construction of History in the School Curriculum and Mass Media in Post-Communist Russia and Ukraineâ. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 43, 2: 129â137.
-
Korostelina, Karina. 2013. âMapping national identity narratives in Ukraineâ. Nationalities Papers, 41, 2: 293â315.
-
Kucera, Joshua. 2017. âRussian TV Backs Down After Calling Armenian Hero âFascist Collaboratorâ, Eurasianet, November 24, available at https://eurasianet.org/russian-tv-backs-down-after-calling-armenian-hero-fascist-collaborator.
-
Kuzio, Taras. 2001. âIdentity and Nation-Building in Ukraine: Defining the Otherâ. Ethnicities 1, 3: 343â365.
-
Kuzio, Taras. 2006. âNational Identity and History Writing in Ukraineâ, Nationalities Papers, 34, 4., 407â427.
-
Libaridian, Gerard. 1991. Armenia at the Crossroads: Democracy and Nationhood in the Post-Soviet Era. Watertown: Blue Crane Books.
-
Libaridian Gerard. 1999. The Challenge of Statehood: Armenian Political Thinking Since Independence. Watertown: Blue Crane Books.
-
Libaridian, Gerard. 2007. Modern Armenia: People, Nation, State. New Brunswick and London: Transaction Publishers.
-
Malkasian, Mark. 1996. Gha-Ra-Bagh!: The Emergence of the National Democratic Movement in Armenia. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
-
Marutyan, Harutyun. 2009. Hay Inqnutyan Patkeragrutyuny: hator 1, Tseghaspanutyan Hishoghutyuny ev Gharabaghyan Sharzhumy [Iconography of Armenian Identity, vol. 1, the Memory of Genocide and the Karabakh Movement], Yerevan: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences (in Armenian).
-
Melchior, Inge and Oane Visser. 2011. âVoicing past and present uncertainties: The relocation of a Soviet World War II memorial and the politics of memory in Estoniaâ, Focaal: Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 59 (March): 33â50.
-
Melkonyan, Eduard. 2010. âRepressions in 1930s Soviet Armenia.â In Giorgi Kidiashvili, ed., Stalinist Terror in the South Caucasus, Caucasus Analytical Digest, No. 22, December 1, https://www.laender-analysen.de/cad/pdf/CaucasusAnalyticalDigest22.pdf.
-
Mediamax. 2012. âPamyatnik Leninu â Nezhivaya Istoriyaâ [Lenin Statue â History not Alive] 27 November, available at http://www.mediamax.am/ru/news/yerevan-XX-century/6339/ retrieved 12 August 2018 (in Russian).
-
Mediamax. 2022, â1927â, 14 June, https://sovietarmenia.mediamax.am/story/52?fbclid=IwAR3T_9j1bvcXzcYcfY2f5KTwTOw1ovH-11GnEREjSku_XVVBLiEMgQRQ4-gâ(in Armenian).
-
Novaya Gazeta. 2022. âAndrey Sakharov statue disappears from Moscow park, supposedly moved to Artsakh in South Caucasus.â 21 May available at https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2022/05/21/andrey-sakharov-statue-disappears-from-moscow-park-supposedly-moved-to-artsakh-in-south-caucasus-news.
-
Nora, Pierre. 1989. âBetween Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire.â Representations, 26 (Special Issue, Spring): 7â24.
-
Nora, Pierre, ed. 2001. Rethinking France: Les Lieux de mémoire, Volume 1: The State, Chicago and London: Chicago University Press.
-
Panossian, Razmik. 2002. âThe Past as Nation: Three Dimensions of Armenian Identity.â Geopolitics, 7, 2: 121â146.
-
Panossian Razmik. 2006. The Armenians: From Kings and Priests to Merchants and Commissars. New York: Columbia University Press.
-
Photolure. 2005. âA monument for Hero of the great Patriotic War Admiral Hovhanness Isakov has opened in Yerevan today on the occasion of the 111th anniversary of the admiralâ. August 22. Available at https://www.photolure.am/photoset/12294.
-
Poghosyan, Yekaterina. 2014. âStalinâs Man Mikoyan to Get Statue in Yerevanâ. Institute for War and Peace Reporting, 29 May. Available at https://iwpr.net/global-voices/stalins-man-mikoyan-get-statue-yerevan.
-
Regnum. 2017. âZatmeniye Umov v Minkulâte Armeniiâ [Eclipse of Minds in the Armenian Ministry of Culture], September 14, available at https://regnum.ru/news|/2322175.html (in Russian).
-
Savranskaya, Svetlana. 2012. âCuba Almost Became a Nuclear Power in 1962.â Foreign Policy, October 10.
-
Saparov, Arsène. 2012. âWhy Autonomy? The Making of Nagorny Karabakh Autonomous Region 1918â1925.â Europe-Asia Studies 64, 2: 281â323.
-
Shakarian, Pietro. 2022. âCelebrating Victory, Armenian Style.â EVN Report, May 9, available at https://evnreport.com/raw-unfiltered/celebrating-victory-armenian-style/.
-
Shnirelman, Viktor. 2001. The value of the past: myths, identity and politics in Transcaucasia. (Senri Ethnological Studies, 57.) Osaka: National Museum of Ethnology.
-
Smith, Michael. 2001. Pamyatâ ob Utratakh i Azerbaydzhanskoe Obshchestvo [Memory of Losses and Azerbaijani society] in Furman, D.E., ed, Azerbaydzhan i Rossiya: Obshchestva i Gosudarstva. [Azerbaijan and Russia: Societies and States], 88â118. Moscow: Letni Sad (in Russian).
-
Smok, Vadim. 2013. Belarusian Identity: the Impact of Lukashenkaâs Rule, Analytical Paper, December. Minsk-London: Ostrogorski Centre.
-
State Cadaster Committee of Armenia. 2008. Hayastani Hanrapetutyan Bnakavayreri Bararan [Dictionary of the Localities of the Republic of Armenia] Yerevan: State Cadaster Committee (in Armenian).
-
Stepanyan, Albert. 2014. Nor Patmutyun: 9rd Dasarani Dasagirq, [Modern History: 9th Grade] Yerevan: Zangak (in Armenian).
-
Stepanyan, Albert. 2008. Noraguyn Patmutyun: 9rd Dasaran. [Recent Modern History: 9th Grade] Yerevan: Zangak-97 (in Armenian).
-
Suciu, Oana-Valentina. 2018. Confronting Multiple Pasts in Post-Soviet Armenia. In Cynthia M. Horne and Lavinia Stan, Eds., Transitional Justice and the Former Soviet Union: Reviewing the Past, Looking toward the Future, 282â302. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Ter-Petrosyan, Levon. 2006. Yntrani: Yeluytner, Hodvatsner, Hartsazruytsner, [Selected Works: Speeches, Articles, Interviews] Yerevan: Archives of the First President of Armenia (in Armenian).
-
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 1972. The Baku Commune, 1917â1918: Class and Nationality in the Russian Revolution. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
-
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 1993. Looking Toward Ararat: Armenia in Modern History. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.
-
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 2001. Constructing Primordialism: Old Histories for New Nations. The Journal of Modern History 73, 4: 862â896.
-
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 2017. âI Cannot Imagine Armenia Without Russia.â Civilnet. 23 May, available at https://www.civilnet.am/en/news/383994/ronald-suny-i-cannot-imagine-armenia-without-russia/, last accessed on June 2, 2022.
-
Suny Ronald Grigor, Suny, Fatma Müge Göçek, and Norman M. Naimark, eds. 2011. A Question of Genocide: Armenians and Turks at the End of Ottoman Empire. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Wilson, Andrew. 2016, âBelarus: from a Social Contract to a Security Contract?â The Journal of Belarusian Studies 8, 1:78â91.
-
Tokarev, Aleksey. 2017, âOtritsanie, Vstraivanie, Postepennoe Zabvenie: Gosudarstvennye Strategii po Otnoshcheniyu k Sovetskomu Naslediyu v Gruzii, Armenii I Azerbaydzhaneâ [Denial, Integration, Gradual Oblivion: State Strategies Toward the Soviet Past in Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan], Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta, 5, 56: 60â80 (in Russian).
-
Torbakov, Igor. 2011. âHistory, Memory and National Identity: Understanding the Politics of History and Memory Wars in Post-Soviet Lands.â Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 19,3: 209â232.
-
Vagharshyan, Arthur. 2015. Hayastani Ankakhutyan Hrchakagiry ev Zhoghovrdavarakan Iravakan Hasarakutyan Razmavarutyan Orensdrakan Kensagortsumy 1990â1991 tt. [The Declaration of Independence of Armenia and the Legal Realization of the Strategy for Democratic Law-based Society in 1990â1991] Banber Yerevani Hamalsarani, 3,18: 3â15 (in Armenian).
-
Zerubavel, Eviatar. 2003. Time Maps: Collective Memory and the Social Shape of the Past. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
-
Zhirnov, Yevgeni. 2008. Nelepaya i Chudovishnaya Katastrofa [An Absurd and Horrible Catastrophe] Kommersant Vlastâ, 8 September, https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/1020990.
-
Zolyan, Mikayel and Tigran Zakaryan. 2008. âRepresentations of âUsâ and âThemâ in History Textbooks of Post-Soviet Armenia.â Internationale Schulbuchforschung / International Textbook Research, 30, 4: 785â795.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1773 | 931 | 79 |
| Full Text Views | 266 | 54 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 662 | 140 | 3 |
Three Republics of Armenia: The Soviet Past and the Politics of Memory in Post-Soviet Armenia (1991â2018)
In: Caucasus SurveySearch for other papers by Mikayel Zolyan in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
Deciding how to relate to the Soviet past is a key question in the politics of memory for the societies and political elites of the post-Soviet countries. Throughout the post-Soviet decades Armenian political and intellectual elites tried to form a complex attitude to the Soviet past, neither rejecting, nor appropriating the Soviet legacy completely, but assimilating it within the paradigm of national history. Within this paradigm Soviet Armenia is viewed as a stage in the development of Armenian nationhood, as âthe second republicâ, which links the first âattemptâ at building a nation-state, âthe first republicâ of 1918â1920, to the â3rd republicâ, i.e. the post-Soviet state of Armenia. This paradigm, in which the Soviet past is neither completely rejected, or accepted, but certain elements of it are integrated into the national history narrative, is optimal for post-Soviet Armenia, given both the peculiarity of Armeniaâs historical experience (particularly the role played by Russia/USSR in the context of Armenian-Turkish relations), as well as the current geopolitical setting, in which Armenia and Russia are formal allies. This attitude, which can be described as âmnemonic ambiguityâ, allows the assertion of an independent and sovereign Armenian state as legitimate, while at the same time avoiding a confrontation with an ally in the realm of memory politics.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1773 | 931 | 79 |
| Full Text Views | 266 | 54 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 662 | 140 | 3 |
