1 Introduction
This chapter calls for greater attention to be paid to the mobility of nurses in order to assess both source and host countries’ abilities to achieve the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (sdgs) during a pandemic. Here, I look at complementary targets: sdg 3 on global health and sdg target 10.7 on ‘orderly, safe, regular and responsible migration and mobility of people’ (UN desa, 2020, para 1). I examine the extent to which healthcare practitioners receive adequate access to healthcare, given the risks experienced by Filipino nurses during the onslaught of covid-19 as local frontliners and as migrant workers at the heart of the global pandemic. This Policy Comment also delves
The chapter starts by providing a background on nursing as a global profession and the mobility of Filipino nurses. Integrated into the Comment are interviews with Filipino nurses working in different parts of the world; these were conducted from January to August 2020, online and using questionnaires. The chapter also captures responses from nurses on the frontlines of the pandemic, before concluding with policy recommendations.
2 Background
On 1 August 2020, over 80,000 doctors and a million nurses from 80 groups sent a collective note to Philippine President Rodrigo Roa Duterte lamenting that the country was on the brink of defeat in its battle against covid-19 (Morales, 2020) and underscoring that it was critical to formulate a cohesive and clear action plan (Hallare, 2020). The note called for the national government to return Metro Manila, which had the most infections, to the stricter enhanced community quarantine (ecq) regime for two weeks. Medical frontliners cautioned that the healthcare system could, without tighter controls, collapse under the continuously escalating number of infections. Following warnings from health workers, the president approved the extension of the quarantine regime (Parrocha, 2020). Effectively, the order to stay at home was back for the Philippine population. During that very month, the number of health workers testing positive for the coronavirus reached 5,008 (Tomacruz, 2020), with most contaminations found among doctors and nurses.
According to McLaughlin (2020), the coronavirus pandemic has revealed the fragility and inequity present in systems and societies around the globe, including in the healthcare sector. In the war against the coronavirus, health workers are the frontline soldiers. Arguably, the risk to health workers has been one of the significant vulnerabilities of the healthcare system during the covid-19 pandemic. Those working in hospitals are handling a massive rush of patients while also usually dealing with a lack of personal protective equipment (ppe) and the worry of acquiring the virus, coupled with an increased workload and less time for rest (ilo, 2020).
Nursing has been identified as an ‘indispensable profession, discipline and occupation’ (Thuon Northrup et al., 2004, 55). In developed countries the
The World Health Organization’s (who) State of the World’s Nursing—2020 reveals that unless appropriate interventions take place there will be a shortfall of 4.6 million nurses worldwide by 2030 (who, 2020b). Over the years, the number of healthcare practitioners in the Philippines has increased. Abrigo and Ortiz (2019) capture this robust growth in their study on healthcare professionals employed in the Philippines, comparing data from 1990, 2010 and 2015 based on the 2012 Philippine Standard Occupational Classification (psoc) and from the Census of Population (see Table 9.1).
Number of selected healthcare workers by year who responded that they were employed in the professions in question (numbers in thousands)
Profession |
1990 |
2010 |
2015 |
|---|---|---|---|
Physicians |
27.3 |
32.3 |
52.0 |
Dentists |
15.1 |
23.6 |
23.9 |
Professional nurses |
54.8 |
253.5 |
351.1 |
Pharmacists |
8.6 |
17.1 |
27.5 |
The 2015 Census of Population, meanwhile, revealed that the Philippines had 488,800 health professionals for a population of over 100 million (2015 census cited in uppi and drdf, 2020), while the 2018 National Migration Survey estimated that under 1 per cent of working Filipinos in the Philippines are employed as health professionals (psa and uppi, 2019). Within this small demographic, the majority (59 per cent) are nurses, 12 per cent are medical doctors, and 11 per cent are midwives (psa and uppi, 2019). If the country fails to invest more in retaining its nursing population, it is looking at a deficiency of 249,843 nurses by 2030 (who, 2020b). The Philippine Nurses Association (pna) has stated that 60 per cent of the 500,000 Filipino registered nurses work in other countries (pna cited in Malig, 2020). Further, in 2014, according to the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (poea), 19,815 nurses emigrated from the country (poea, 2014).
3
Filipino nurses are important frontliners in the Philippines and abroad. At the onslaught of the deadly pandemic, the Philippines tried to curb the rise in infections within its borders while also dealing with reports of infections, even casualties, from overseas. Inside the country, the opportunity to react effectively to those in need of medical treatment and support was hampered as a consequence of insufficient numbers of health professionals, while there was also an increasing demand for facilities.
The Philippine experience is unique because the country is engaged in a balancing act, simultaneously attempting to manage the healthcare personnel shortfall within its borders while meeting the healthcare needs of the global community. The manner in which the Philippines navigates demands for models that respond to new pandemics and the ecology of global health is worth investigating, especially as it relates to attempts to achieve the sdgs.
3.1 Nursing and the Sustainable Development Goals
In 2015, the United Nations General Assembly approved the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, which gives ‘a shared blueprint for peace and prosperity for people and the planet, in the present time and for the future’ (unosd, 2015). Nursing has an essential function with regard to Sustainable Development Goal 3: to ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages (unosd, 2015).
The active mobility of nurses, meanwhile correlates with the sdgs’ aims with regard to migration, and in particular Target 10.7, to ‘facilitate orderly, safe, regular and responsible migration and mobility of people, including implementing planned and well-managed migration policies’ (UN desa, 2020, 1), which is part of sdg 10, ‘to reduce inequality within and among countries’ (unosd, 2015). The intersection of nurse migration with sustainable development and human rights, such as the right to movement, is supported by targets set by the international community.
3.2 The State of Global Nursing
The revival of interest in nurses’ international migration is a consequence primarily of the global shortage of nurses in recent years (Buchan and Calman, 2004). According to the who report on the State of the World’s Nursing—2020, the result of the collaborative effort of 191 countries, nursing is the largest category in the health sector, with nurses accounting for 59 per cent of all health workers. In the period 2013–18, nurse numbers grew by 4.7 million worldwide (who, 2020b). Given nurse-to-population ratios, however, this increase is
The global nursing workforce currently stands at 27.9 million, with 19.3 million of these considered professional nurses (who, 2020b). Around 6.0 million (22 per cent) are associate professional nurses, and 2.6 million (9 per cent) do not fall into either of these two categories (who, 2020b).
These figures reveal that worldwide nursing numbers are not proportionate to the demands of universal healthcare or to the targets regarding inequality reduction set out in the sdgs. The shortfall in the number of nurses worldwide fell slightly from around 6.6 million in 2016 to 5.9 million in 2018 (who, 2020b). Around 5.3 million of that shortfall, however, involves low-income and lower-middle-income countries (who, 2020b). Figure 9.1 shows the diversity of densities of nursing personnel to populations, revealing major shortages in countries in Africa, the eastern Mediterranean, Southeast Asia and Latin America.
Density of nursing personnel per 10,000 population in 2018
source: who (2019a), as cited in WHO (2020b, xiii)
In its report Human Resources for Health: Overcoming the Crisis (2004), the Joint Learning Initiative explains that providing a supportive climate and sharpening human resources for health is vital to efforts to shape ‘sustainable health systems’ globally and to combat healthcare disasters in the world’s most vulnerable countries (Joint Learning Initiative, 2004). The World Health Report 2006: Working Together for Health (who, 2006) underscores this message and encourages efforts to understand what motivates the mobility of health professionals and the effect that this mobility has on society.
The Philippines is the second most populous country in Southeast Asia. Despite this, many of the country’s registered nurses remain either unemployed or ‘mis-employed’ (Dabu, 2019). In 2017, the Philippine Statistics Authority reported that, with 90,308 practising nurses in private and public hospitals, the healthcare system fell short of the target nurse-to-patient ratio (see Table 9.2). In the Philippines, the target ratio in government institutions is 1:60, as revealed by the Philippine Nurses Association (Cortez, 2020). This is some way from the Department of Health’s (doh) ideal ratio of 1:12 (Cortez, 2020).
Population of nurses in the Philippines
Year |
Estimated populationa |
Total number of nursesb |
Ratio of nursesc |
|---|---|---|---|
2017 |
104,218,176 |
90,308 |
8.67 |
2016 |
102,587,042 |
87,482 |
8.53 |
Based on PSA Population Counts and Growth Rates
HRD (human resource development) in hospitals + field healthcare professionals
Per 10,000 population
An irony of the Philippine health sector is that even with the numbers of health professionals the country trains each year, there are not enough staff to cater to the needs of the growing population (uppi and drdf, 2020). Even before the covid-19 pandemic, the Philippines suffered from an estimated shortfall of 23,000 nurses according to the Private Hospitals Association of the Philippines (phap, cited in Maru, 2020). The Philippine situation runs contrary to the who’s Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel (hereafter, who Code), which frowns upon recruiting health personnel from countries that have a shortage (who, 2010). With its lack of nursing personnel, the Philippines is ill-placed to encourage the mobility of its healthcare human resources.
3.3
The presence of Filipino nurses in the United States, writes Dr Catherine Choy in her book Empire of Care: Nursing and Migration in Filipino American History (2003), can be mapped back to the point at which the Philippines became a US territory, when new professions such as nursing were introduced to the country in time making the Philippines ‘the leading exporter of nurses in the world’ (Choy, 2003). Nursing schools sprang up in the Philippines beginning in 1907 and were interlaced with an Americanised medical training that equipped Filipino women to be employed as nurses in the United States, not in the Philippines (Choy, 2003). Today the country is ‘the leading exporter of nurses in the world’ (Lorenzo et al., 2007, 1406).
From 2008 to 2012, close to 70,000 Filipino nurses worked abroad according to government data from the Philippine Statistics Authority (cited in McLaughlin, 2020). In 2017, some 145,800 Filipinos worked as registered nurses in the United States according to the Washington-based Migration Policy Institute (cited in Batalova, 2020). According to government data, around 18,500 Filipinos were employed in the UK National Health Service in 2020 (McLaughlin, 2020). Japan has been recruiting nurses from the Philippines to care for its elderly population. Filipino nurses are also present in great numbers in the Gulf States, including Saudi Arabia (McLaughlin, 2020). Spain, meanwhile, announced in early 2020 that it would fast-track Filipino nurses’ entry to relieve its straining healthcare system, especially during the covid-19 pandemic (Aboy, 2020).
Many nurses leave the Philippines unofficially. Many, moreover, are selected via direct recruitment by overseas employers, while others depart on immigrant visas. These three types of mobility are not reflected in the Philippines’ international employment estimates. Hence, the nurse mobility estimates found in Philippine government must be treated with caution (Pang, Lansang and Haines, 2002). The poea and the Commission on Higher Education estimate that from 2012 to 2016 the country trained an annual total of around 26,000 licensed nurses, while around 18,500 moved overseas each year (Lopez and Jiao, 2020), meaning that the emigration rate for trained nurses was 71 per cent.
The Philippines is a preferred source of nurses because of its exceptionally well-educated workforce, which is a result of the Philippine education system and the quality of training the population receive. The country’s overseas population is an enormous source of remittances, which help the national economy greatly, and thus transnational mobility has enjoyed widespread support. Even at the height of the pandemic, Filipinos living abroad sent usd 2.9 billion
With 233 nursing schools, and producing more than 20,000 graduates per year since 1999, the Philippines’ strategy for healthcare migration is reflected in the country actively training a surplus of registered nurses that cannot be absorbed by the local market, with the intention of providing for the international market (Corcega et al., 2002). The number of nursing schools has increased over time, illustrating the country’s approach of creating a workforce for export with the expectation that the results of this tactic will be instrumental to the country’s progress (Ortiga, 2017).
As noted in a study commissioned by the International Council of Nurses, the local health system in the Philippines needs to support the growth of nursing as a profession and to address the dilemmas present with regard to work environments and pay (Buchan, 2020). A balance must be achieved between assisting in the provision of global healthcare expertise by the relocation of Filipino health workers and ensuring that no capacity gaps exist in the Philippines itself (Buchan, 2020).
Work in a much more advanced society offers many nurses the opportunity to change their lives for the better and to secure the quality of life they aspire to (Xu and Zhang, 2005). Which explains why many nurses consider moving and working overseas as one of their future goals. Over 80 per cent of interviewees of the present study admitted that migration was always a part of their plans (Figure 9.2).
Respondents’ answers to the question, ‘Was migrating to another country a plan from the beginning?’
source: author
In the Philippines as in other source countries, people study nursing with the intention of working abroad, an intention that is not only accepted but is also supported by their families and the government (Dussault, Buchan and Craveiro, 2016). This rationalisation seems to be supported by responses to the question, ‘What was your reason for getting a nursing degree?’
Ever since I was a kid, it was always my dream to become a nurse and work abroad. One of the things that motivated me to pursue a nursing degree is my passion for caring for the sick since when I was growing up I […] [saw] my grandparents suffer from different illnesses. Second is the ongoing demand for nurses all over the world and lastly, the endless learning opportunities. Working as a nurse, we have the opportunity to interact with doctors and other medical staff as well as patients daily, which allow[s] us to learn from other people and allows us to improve our interpersonal skills.
Nurse 1, UK
Nursing was never my choice. It was my mom’s. I just did it for the sake of my parents. I never really liked or loved it at all, even after graduation. Until I was exposed to Emergency Nursing. My perception was changed then [and I] started loving it.
Nurse 2, UK
My mom and sisters are nurses so [there was ]a bandwagon effect
Nurse 3, UK
It was my aunt who was also a nurse who motivates me to become a nurse. Since I was a child, I really wanted to become one to help the sick
Nurse 4, US
[It was my] parent’s choice
Nurse 1, the Philippines
Nurse 5, the Philippines
My mother told me to study nursing
I come from a family of nurses and the nursing profession offers a more stable employment in Europe
Nurse 6, Switzerland
The International Centre on Nurse Migration has stated that there are several ‘push’ factors that encourage nurses to leave their home countries, including constrained access to educational and career opportunities, low pay, a lack of resources, limited social benefits, political instability and the absence of safe and secure conditions, that last of these including the incidence of hiv/aids (Li, Li and Nie, 2014). ‘Pull’ factors that attract nurses to developed countries include better working conditions, job security and advancement, avenues to improve skills, and travel opportunities. (Aiken et al., 2004). It can be argued that these push and pull factors are reflected in the Philippine migration experience, especially as it relates to nurse mobility.
There are more women than men in the diaspora, and this been referred to as the feminisation of migration (Camlin, Snow and Hosegood, 2014). Nurse mobility is no exception to this rule. Around the world 90 per cent of nurses are women (who, 2020b). In the Philippines 74.1 per cent of nurses are female and 25.9 per cent are male (2015 figures) (Figure 9.3) (psa, 2016).
Gender of nurses in the Philippines
source: psa (2016)
Women can play an active role in migration, particularly among healthcare workers. A majority of the world’s nurses are female (Brush and Sochalski, 2007). Women migrants are, however, particularly vulnerable to the ‘dark side’ of migration. While they may have decided on their own mobility pathways, as reported by the who (2019b), a considerable number in the healthcare workforce encounter partiality and discrimination as well as harassment (who, 2019b). Migration is highly gendered and understanding female nurse mobility therefore calls for a gender-responsive approach.
3.4 Filipino Nurses during the covid-19 Pandemic
Through the poea, the government—in its bid to protect healthcare workers—issued Resolution No. 9 on 2 April 2020, stopping nurses from departing the Philippines pending the lifting of the national state of emergency (poea, 2020). Some days after this memorandum was released, the Department of Foreign Affairs Secretary announced that health workers with an existing overseas contract, signed before 8 March, were allowed to leave (Cheng, 2020). New applications for healthcare positions in other countries were, however, halted. Citing Republic Act 8043 or the Migrant Workers and Overseas Filipinos Act of
During the pandemic, a lot of fellow Filipino nurses working here in the UK were affected. Some [even] lost their lives while taking care of covid-19-positive patients. It was a difficult time for us, knowing that every time we [went] to work we [could] be affected by the virus […]. For some of my colleagues working in intensive care units it is […] challenging and difficult for them to work a 12-hour shift with complete personal protective equipment on and [have] only a specific toilet and water break as well as time for them to have their lunch. For me, working in the post-operative cardiac ward, I would say that I am very lucky in […] that [I] can continue taking care of our patients using our comfortable scrubs. Here in the UK, I still feel lucky despite the fact that we are at great risk of being affected by the virus, because we were able to have free transportation for a short while going to work and even free food during our shift provided by our hospital.
Emotionally we are very much affected in [the] way that this is our calling and we have no other choice but to work. Going to work with our anxiety levels […] sky[-high] because we are directly taking care of […] covid-19 patients. We are scared for our [lives] and our family member[s] if we get infected. But on the other side, I believe that this is the only way we can
Nurse 9, UKpay back God’s blessings to us and that he will cover us with his mantle of protection.
Over 25 per cent of the Filipinos in the New York–New Jersey region work in the healthcare sector. According to a report produced by the non-profit ProPublica, in this region alone there were 30 deaths in the community of Filipino frontliners between the end of March and early May 2020 (cited in Martin and Yeung, 2020). Al Jazeera, in its documentary ‘Filipino Nurses: New York’s Frontliners’, reported that at the peak of the outbreak Filipino nurses were fighting to protect Americans on the front lines of New York’s covid-19 disaster, with some risking their lives (Al Jazeera, 2020).
When covid-19 peaked here in the UK, Filipino nurses were placed ahead of all the frontliners. We were sent to the icu and placed in the covid-19 wards with no proper ppe. If you look into the statistics and reports, the highest cases of frontliners that died during the peak of the pandemic were Filipinos. Because of the resilience of our race, we still continue to provide high-quality care to our patients in spite of the fact that our lives are at risk. We need to think about the welfare of our patients before our own.
It affected us in so many ways. We have always been resilient and flexible. However, being in [that] personal protective equipment for hours is no joke. Some of us get pressure sores and end our shift with a terrible headache due to dehydration. Psychologically, very traumatic. As we often say, we feel like we are in a battle without guns, and we can’t see our enemies. It was tough knowing that we can get infected. Especially when we had patients who are also nurses in our hospital. I work in icu, so I’ve seen the worst covid-19 can do. Nevertheless, the bond we have with our fellow nurses became stronger than ever. We looked out for each other every
Nurse 12, UStime we prepare[d] to enter the covid-19 zone. And we see to it that we talk to each other in order to release the stress.
Nurses are dealing with a lot of emotional stress from working in these times. From wanting to stay at home to keep their families safe and working to keep others safe, nurses are battling with mental and emotional stress in dealing with this pandemic. Many nurses were broken-hearted from working tirelessly for others and get little to no assurance from the company/government they are working [for] about the hazard they are dealing with. The uncertainty that this pandemic has brought to light made the nurses rethink how passionate they are about their profession. Some even contracted the disease and got discriminated against at work. I personally encountered discrimination for working in an area catering to patients with moderate-to-severe cases of covid-19. Even inside our workplace, we are sometimes denied […] some basic services just because we work in covid-19 areas and are asked to go back when we are off duty. Nurses’ plans on working abroad had been halted due to restrictions in travel.
Nurse 8, Switzerland
The Philippine Department of Health recognised this problem. In response to the growing mental well-being needs of frontline workers and repatriated overseas Filipino workers (ofws), the Department unveiled its Telemental Health Response programme, a virtual platform that provides psychosocial help (doh, 2020). Even the University of the Philippines’ Psychosocial Services, with its 100 volunteers, has offered free tele-psychotherapy sessions.
Working as a nurse in the Philippines, [one of the] common challenges we’ve encountered [is] working beyond duty hours to complete all necessary paperwork. Sometimes, you offer possible solutions to certain problems encountered in your area that may help in revising old protocols and creating new ones that may benefit the workers and the hospital, but then you get no response or even alternate solutions from the management. Discrimination is one of the challenges any nurse is dealing with at this time of the pandemic.
Even prior to the current pandemic research (Gee et al., 2006) had found that daily experiences of prejudice were linked to Filipino Americans’ chronic health conditions. And de Castro, Gilbert and Takeuchi (2008) had discovered that the self-reporting of occupational discrimination was associated with worse health outcomes among Filipino Americans, the authors concluding that it is important to consider the work setting as a specific source of discrimination when studying health disparities.
As these words are being written, the who-Western Pacific Region covid-19 Incident Manager, Abdi Mahamud, is expressing concern over the infection
3.5 The Evolving Role of Nurses in Global Health
The who, the International Nurses Council and the global campaign Nursing Now emphasise the role of nurses in contributing to national and global health priorities, including the achievement of the sdgs, in their report on the State of the World’s Nursing (who, 2020b).
In an interview carried out for the present study, Nurse 17 (UK), in affirming the role of nurses, confidently shared, ‘We are pretty much the blood that runs [and keeps] the hospitals alive’. Other respondents also stated that nurses are essential. Nurses ‘care for the sick and the dying’ (Nurse 1, the Philippines) and ‘help the community get better, and provide education on prevention of diseases and spread of infection’ (Nurse 11, UK). All respondents believe in nurses’ vital role in the world as ‘role models of health practices and healthy living’ (Nurse 20, the Philippines). Nurses play a vital role in the community. Regardless of race, age group or cultural diversity nurses have the ability and capability to give the best possible care. Nurse 17 shared, ‘nurses are the caregiver[s] of those who are ill and needing hospitalisations; nurses can be agents of change health-wise by providing people [with] […] information regarding health education and prevention of illness’. Nurse 14 (US) stated emphatically: ‘I believe that our role in the global community always focuses on health promotion and disease prevention. And the primary goal for us nurses is always to protect and promote the health of all people from different age group[s], gender[s], race[s], etc.’.
Nurse 15 (UK) said, ‘The role of nurses is crucial, especially in the provision and promotion of the healthcare delivery system to the global community’.
The World Health Assembly (wha) resolution wha64.7 (who, 2011) directs its Member States to support nursing and midwifery through a number of initiatives, such as using nurses’ skills and integrating them into the development of human capital for health policy. Moreover, the framework set by the Global Strategic Directions for Strengthening Nursing and Midwifery 2016–2020 gives the who and other actors the platform to ‘develop, implement and evaluate nursing and midwifery accomplishments to ensure accessible, acceptable, quality, and safe nursing and midwifery interventions’ (who, 2020a, 12).
Recognising the importance of ‘adequate and accessible’ health personnel, the wha has approved a guide to ensuring secure conditions for people taking part in foreign migration. This who Code proposes a series of non-binding guidelines for state and non-state players participating in foreign health
With the pandemic right now, being a nurse has a great impact on the community. We are the frontliners; we are the ones who directly take care of sick patients.
The calling of a nurse is to assess the well-being of individuals, families and the whole community. To be the advocate for all […] patients and to promote justice and equality. To uphold everything mentioned in the ‘Nightingale […] Pledge’ when we took our oath.
A nurse is many things. But for me, the best role of a nurse is being the mediator. You are the only bridge between the patient and the rest of the healthcare team and even to the relatives. The information you relay will be the basis of care plans, therefore expecting good outcomes. Through the nurse, you also protect the patient’s privacy and dignity, ensuring that nobody insignificant to the care of the patient is getting important information.
During times of crisis and disaster, nurses are strategically positioned not only to contribute but to lead. With their experience and education as well as their role in society, they can push for partnerships and collaborations and for a new health paradigm that is more efficient, inclusive and responsive.
4 Policy Recommendations and Moving Forward
Global health has evolved not only due to the emergence of new diseases but also because of our increasingly interconnected and interdependent world. Recognising that policy is an essential part of the ecosystem of health sciences, the following recommendations are offered to the international community, and to the Philippines.
4.1 Recommendations for the International Community
In a study commissioned by the International Council of Nurses (icn), Buchan (2020) mentions three main factors of concern for national nursing associations (nnas): The first is maintaining secure minimum staffing levels while nurses are unavailable due to covid-19 symptoms, and ensuring that personnel and patients are protected. Employers have to ensure that nurses are
In an attempt to respond to the needs of nurses worldwide, the State of the World’s Nursing—2020 lists guidance measures for future nursing staffing policies, including the need for countries with nursing crises to raise investment in order to train and recruit, collectively, at least 5.9 million nurses (who, 2020b). Furthermore, countries should improve their ability to collect, analyse and use health workforce data. Nurses’ mobility must be efficiently supervised and handled professionally and ethically. The same report stresses that leadership and governance are essential (who, 2020b). Authorities should boost nurses’ participation in decision-making on matters that affect their lives and practice. Actions should, in order to ensure decent work for nurses, be harmonised between those in charge of policy, human resources and standards.
Connectedly, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, specifically Article 7, contains guidelines for ‘just and favourable’ working standards, such as the ‘right to secure working conditions’ (unga, 1966). In the General Comment on the Right to Work, respect for workers’ rights and individuals’ fundamental rights, respect for workers’ physical and mental integrity, and appropriate remuneration are elucidated as the main components of decent work (uncescr, 2006). In relation to this, the International Labour Organization’s (ilo) Decent Work Agenda provides four strategic goals: encouraging sustainable jobs, guaranteeing workplace security, promoting dialogue and ensuring social security (ilo, 2016).
Ultimately, the aim is for both origin and source countries to benefit while ensuring the protection and rights of health workers moving abroad (ilo, 2009). Bilateral and multilateral guidelines and codes of ethics have been established in collaboration with partner nations to devise and enforce agreements that specifically discuss standards and policies for the nursing profession. There are also reciprocal arrangements that lay down the rules and regulations, as well as the performance criteria, for health staff hired from source by destination countries. There needs to be a consistent review and monitoring of these arrangements, intertwined with a regular assessment of their implementation.
4.2
Yes. I think the government should step up in its action towards flattening the curve. The community must do its part in preventing the spread of the disease. We must strengthen our campaign towards promoting prevention, starting from our homes. We should all step up in realising that we have to live with the new normal for the next couple of years. The government should start distributing or localising jobs in municipalities so as not to overwhelm cities with people returning for work. The government needs to rebuild the distribution of jobs to promote a safe workplace.
The Philippines’ battle against covid-19 is far from over, and the Department of Health reports that more health personnel will be required for covid-19 facilities. As a result, the Department began an emergency recruitment campaign to treat covid-19 incidents. A guaranteed 20 per cent bonus over the government’s minimum wage levels, accommodation, hospitalisation benefits and even compensation of php 1 million (usd 20,000) in case of loss of life are all on offer (Lopez and Jiao, 2020).
One of the priority measures identified by Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte in his State of the Nation Address (Duterte, 2020) was passing the Advanced Nursing Act, which seeks to modify some aspects of the Philippine Nursing Act of 2002 to create an advanced nursing education program. Senator Bong Go, the bill’s sponsor in the upper chamber, hopes to persuade Filipino nurses to remain in the Philippines rather than work abroad. Senate Bill No. 395 will mandate higher learning institutions approved by the Commission on Higher Education to develop harmonised basic and graduate nursing education programs (House of the Senate, 2019). Lower House Deputy Speaker and Camarines Sur 2nd District Rep. Luis Raymund Villafuerte Jr. provided the lower house version of the bill (House of Representatives, 2020a).
Nurse 24, who had just returned to the Philippines from the Middle East, recommended that the Balik Scientist programme, an existing programme of the Department of Science and Technology, should ‘allow willing Filipino health professionals to return to share their skills and talents gained from experience with[in] the destination country without risk of job loss’ and that this should also be included in the provisions of bilateral agreements with host countries.
Indeed, apart from legislation, there needs to be support given to improving the practice of nursing in the Philippines, support that also includes the
Acknowledging the stories of Filipino nurses on active duty in the Philippines and abroad while taking stock of the frameworks created by the UN, who, and other agencies advances the need not only for a mapping exercise that tracks geographical nurse mobility but also for becoming conscious of the leaky faucets that disturb the career trajectories of nurses. Measures to ensure that standards are followed, codes are committed to, and concerns are addressed must be implemented in partnership with different sectors, but, more importantly, guarantee that the voices of nurses are heard and valued, as they inform both policy and a more inclusive, safe and secure work environment.
5 Conclusion
During the covid-19 pandemic, the profile of the nursing population from the Philippines has shed light on two issues: the challenges the current health system holds for health workers, in particular nurses, seeking to provide services to the country during a crisis such as the pandemic, and the question of Filipino nurses’ ability to work abroad and their working and life conditions as they navigate the uncertainties and vulnerabilities brought about by a deadly virus.
This chapter has attempted to relate the perspectives of nurses themselves in order to understand the impact of migration on their lives through their experiences and to capture their lived realities, hoping to provide solutions that are practical, inclusive and sustainable. These contributions are critical to designing policies for source countries such as the Philippines.
Health workers in the Philippines during the covid-19 outbreak hoped, via their unified call, to convince national governments and receiving nations to look deeper into their daily lives and recognise that improving their conditions, positions and pay would benefit society as a whole.
At the height of the health crisis, the government tried to dissuade nurses from leaving the Philippines, especially given the loss of frontline personnel to the disease, a loss that exacerbated the dearth of responders who would be required if the country was to successfully combat this insidious virus. However, as echoed by nurse respondents to the present study, the international migration of nurses can serve as a means of empowerment, and of providing spaces for nurses’ engagement and collaboration. This has the potential to enable their wider participation, particularly in decision-making.
As is often said, a crisis is a terrible thing to waste. It is hoped that the common experience of dealing with covid-19 ignites a fire in Filipino nurses, encouraging them to take a more active role in global health and migration policy. And that while the world tries to ‘build back better and stronger’, nurses will be able to take the opportunity to address the leaky faucets that impact their careers, and create an enabling environment in which they themselves will flourish, since doing so will proportionately benefit the global health system and the entire environment of care.
References
Aboy, S. (2020) ‘Babysitters No More, Filipino Nurses in Spain Find Place on COVID-19 Frontlines’, abs cbnNews, https://news.abs-cbn.com/overseas/04/10/20/babysitters-no-more-filipino-nurses-in-spain-find-place-on-covid-19-frontlines (accessed on 6 May 2020).
Abrigo, M.R.M. and D.A.P. Ortiz (2019) Who Are the Health Workers and Where Are They? Revealed Preferences in Location Decision among Health Care Professionals in the Philippines, Discussion Paper Series No. 2019–32 (Quezon City: Philippine Institute for Development Studies), https://pidswebs.pids.gov.ph/CDN/PUBLICATIONS/pidsdps1932.pdf (accessed on 10 December 2020).
Adams, J.G. and R.M. Walls (2020) ‘Supporting the Health Care Workforce During the COVID-19 Global Epidemic’, jama, 323(15), pp. 1439–1440, doi: 10.1001/jama.2020.3972.
Aiken, L.H., J. Buchan, J. Sochalski, B. Nichols and M. Powell (2004) ‘Trends in International Nurse Migration’, Health Affairs, 23(3), pp. 69–77, doi:10.1377/hlthaff.23.3.69.
Al Jazeera (2020) ‘Filipino Nurses: New York’s Frontliners’, Al Jazeera, 16 July, https://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/101east/2020/07/filipino-nurses-york-frontliners-200716112741058.html (accessed on 17 July 2020).
Batalova, J. (2020) ‘Immigrant Health-Care Workers in the United States’, Migration Information Source, 14 May, https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/immigrant-health-care-workers-united-states-2018 (accessed on 10 December 2020).
Beine, M., F. Docquier and H. Rapopor (2008) ‘Brain Drain and Human Capital Formation in Developing Countries: Winners and Losers’, The Economic Journal, 118, pp. 631–652, http://econweb.umd.edu/~Lafortune/puc-readings/Beine_Docquier_Rapoport_2008.pdf (accessed on 10 January 2021).
Brush B.L. and J. Sochalski (2007) ‘International Nurse Migration’, Policy Politics Nursing Practice, 8(1), pp. 37–46, doi: 10.1177/1527154407301393.
Buchan, J. (2020) COVID-19 and the International Supply of Nurses (Geneva: International Council of Nurses), https://www.icn.ch/system/files/documents/2020-07/COVID19_internationalsupplyofnurses_Report_FINAL.pdf (accessed on 9 August 2020).
Buchan J. (2006) ‘The Impact of Global Nursing Migration on Health Services Delivery’, Policy Politics Nursing Practice, 7(3), pp. 16S–25S, doi: 10.1177/1527154406291520.
Buchan, J. and L. Calman (2004) The Global Shortage of Registered Nurses: An Overview of Issues and Actions (Geneva: International Council of Nurses), https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241448495_The_Global_Shortage_of_Registered_Nurses_AnOverview_of_Issues_and_Actions (accessed on 7 June 2021).
Camlin, C.S., R.C. Snow and V. Hosegood (2014) ‘Gendered Patterns of Migration in Rural South Africa’, Population, Space and Place, 20(6), pp. 528–551, doi: 10.1002/psp.1794.
Cheng, W. (2020) ‘Locsin Says Nurses with Existing Contract Abroad May Now Leave’, abs-cbnNews, April 13, https://news.abs-cbn.com/overseas/04/13/20/nurses-with-contracts-abroad-exempted-from-poea-ban-due-to-coronavirus-covid19-luzon-lockdown (accessed on 15 July 2020).
Choy, C.C. (2003) Empire of Care: Nursing and Migration in Filipino American History (Durham, NC: Duke University Press).
cnn Philippines (2020) ‘WHO Works with PH on “Worrisome” COVID-19 Infection Rate of Frontliners’, cnn Philippines, 22 April, https://www.cnn.ph/news/2020/4/22/COVID-19-frontliners-healthcare-workers-coronavirus.html (accessed on 15 July 2020).
Corcega, T.T. et al. (2002) ‘Nurse supply and demand in the Philippines’, TheupManila Journal ,5(1), pp. 1–7.
Cortez, G.M. (2020) ‘Public-Hospital Staffing Could Be Universal Health Care’s Biggest Hurdle’, Business World, 23 January, https://www.bworldonline.com/public-hospital-staffing-could-be-universal-health-cares-biggest-hurdle/ (accessed on 29 March 2021).
Dabu, F. (2019) ‘Flight as Fight for Survival’, upForum, 28 May, https://up.edu.ph/flight-as-fight-for-survival/ (accessed 20 May 2020).
de Castro, A., C.G. Gilbert and D.T. Takeuchi (2008) ‘Workplace Discrimination and Health Among Filipinos in the United States’, American Journal of Public Health, 98(3), pp. 520–526, doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2007.110163.
Department of Budget and Management (Philippines) (2020) Budget Circular No. 2020–4, 17 July, https://www.dbm.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/Issuances/2020/Budget-Circular/BUDGET-CIRCULAR-NO-2020-4.pdf (accessed on 29 March 2021).
de Vera, B.O. (2020) ‘Gov’t Nurses Get Pay Hike 18 Years Overdue’, Inquirer, 19 July, https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1308840/govt-nurses-get-pay-hike-18-years-overdue?cv=1 (accessed on 11 August 2020).
doh (Department of Health, Philippines) (2020) Mind Your Mental Health, press release, 9 June, https://doh.gov.ph/press-release/DOH:-MIND-YOUR-MENTAL-HEALTH;-HEALTH-ORGANIZATIONS-OFFER-REMOTE-CARE-SERVICES (accessed on 10 August 2020).
Dussault G., J. Buchan and I. Craveiro (2016) ‘Migration of Nurses and Doctors in the EU and the European Free Trade Association’, in A. Triandafyllidou and I. Isaakyan (eds.) High-Skill Migration and Recession. Migration, Diasporas and Citizenship (London: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 103–123, doi:10.1057/9781137467119_5.
Duterte, R.R. (2020) ‘Fifth State of the Nation Address’, Official Gazette of the Republic of the Philippines, 27 July, https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/2020/07/27/rodrigo-roa-duterte-fifth-state-of-the-nation-address-july-27-2020/ (accessed on 29 March 2021).
Efendi, F., T. Mackey, H. Mei-Chih and C. Chen (2017) ‘IJEPA: Gray Area for Health Policy and International Nurse Migration’, Nursing Ethics, 24, pp. 313–328, doi:10.1177/0969733015602052.
Focus Economics (2021) ‘Philippines: Remittances Drop for the First Time in Four Months in December’, Focus Economics, 14 February, https://www.focus-economics.com/countries/philippines/news/remittances/remittances-drop-for-the-first-time-in-four-months-in (accessed on 5 January 2021).
Gee, G.C., J. Chen, M.S. Spencer, S. See, O.A. Kuester, D. Tran and D. Takeuchi (2006) ‘Social Support as a Buffer for Perceived Unfair Treatment Among Filipino Americans: Differences Between San Francisco and Honolulu’, American Journal for Public Health, 96(4), pp. 677–684, doi:10.2105/AJPH.2004.060442.
Hallare, K. (2020) ‘Medical Frontliners to Gov’t: “Time-out,” Revert Mega Manila back to ECQ’, Newsinfo, 1 August, https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1315204/medical-frontliners-to-govt-time-out-revert-metro-manila-back-to-ecq (accessed on 30 March 2021).
Hart, D.M. (2006) ‘From Brain Drain to Mutual Gain: Sharing the Benefits of High-Skill Migration’, Issues in Science and Technology, 23(1), pp. 1–8, https://davidhart.gmu.edu/pdfs/publications/articles_essays_reports/HartIssuesFall2006.pdf (accessed on 20 March 2021).
Hohn, M., J. Lowry, J. Fernández-Pena and J. Witte (2016) Immigrants in Health Care: Keeping Americans Healthy Through Care and Innovation (Fairfax, VA: Institute for Immigration Research, George Mason University), https://s3.amazonaws.com/chssweb/documents/22231/original/health_care_report_FINAL_20160629.pdf?1467209316 (accessed on 10 August 2020).
House of Representatives (Philippines) (2020a) House Bill 7281: An Act Amending Certain Sections of Republic Act 9173 Otherwise Known as the Philippine Nursing Act of 2002, Providing for an Advanced Nursing Education Program, 5 August, https://www.congress.gov.ph/legisdocs/basic_18/HB07281.pdf (accessed on 15 September 2020).
House of Representatives (Philippines) (2020b) House Bill 6817: COVID-19 Related Anti-Discrimination Act, 6 June, https://www.congress.gov.ph/legisdocs/third_18/HBT6817.pdf (accessed on 15 September 2020).
House of the Senate (Philippines) (2019) Senate Bill 395: An Act Amending Certain Sections of Republic Act 9173 Otherwise Known as the Philippine Nursing Act of 2002, Providing for an Advanced Nursing Education Program, 11 July, http://legacy.senate.gov.ph/lis/bill_res.aspx?congress=18&q=SBN-395 (accessed on 15 September 2020).
Hu, D., Y. Kong, W. Li, Q. Han, X. Zhang, L.X. Zhu, S.W. Wan, Z. Liu, Q. Shen, J. Yang, H. He and J. Zhu (2020) ‘Frontline Nurses‘ Burnout, Anxiety, Depression, and Fear Statuses and Their Associated Factors during the COVID-19 Outbreak in Wuhan, China: A Large-Scale Cross-Sectional Study’, eClinicalMedicine, 24, pp. 1–10, DOI: 10/1016/j.eclinm.2020.100424.
ilo (International Labour Organization) (2020) Managing Work-related Psychosocial Risks During the COVID-19 Pandemic (Geneva: ilo), https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_protect/---protrav/---safework/documents/instructionalmaterial/wcms_748638.pdf (accessed on 30 March 2021).
ilo (2016) Decent Work (Geneva: ilo), http://www.ilo.org/global/topics/decent-work/lang--en/index.htm (accessed on 1 December 2016).
ilo (2009) Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers: A Shared Responsibility (Geneva: ilo), https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/labour-migration/publications/WCMS_180060/lang--en/index.htm (accessed on 7 June 2021).
Joint Learning Initiative (2004) Human Resources for Health: Overcoming the Crisis (Boston: Harvard Global Equity Initiative), https://www.who.int/hrh/documents/JLi_hrh_report.pdf (accessed on 29 March 2021).
Kisely S., N. Warren, L. McMahon, C. Dalais, I. Henry and D. Siskind (2020) ‘Occurrence, Prevention, and Management of the Psychological Effects of Emerging Virus Outbreaks on Healthcare Workers: Rapid Review and Meta-analysis’, British Medical Journal, 369, doi: 10.1136/bmj.m1642.
Li, H., J. Li and W. Nie (2014) ‘The Benefits and Caveats of International Nurse Migration’, International Journal of Nursing Sciences, 1(3), pp. 314–317, doi:10.1016/j.ijnss.2014.07.006.
Lopez, D. and C. Jiao (2020) ‘Supplier of World’s Nurses Struggles to Fight Virus at Home’, Bloomberg, 24 April, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-04-23/philippines-sends-nurses-around-the-world-but-lacks-them-at-home (accessed on 30 March 2021).
Lorenzo F.M., J. Galvez-Tan, K. Icamina and L. Javier (2007) ‘Nurse Migration from a Source Country Perspective: Philippine Country Case Study’, Health Services Research, 42(3 Pt 2), pp. 1406–1418, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1955369/ (accessed on 25 August 2020).
Mackey, T.K. and B.A. Liang (2012) ‘Rebalancing Brain Drain: Exploring Resource Reallocation to Address Health Worker Migration and Promote Global Health’, Health Policy, 107(1), pp. 66–73, doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2012.04.006.
Malig, K. (2020) ‘Only 40% of Registered Nurses Work in the Philippines; Org Calls for Mass Hiring’, gmaNews Online, 12 May, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/737958/only-40-of-registered-nurses-work-in-the-philippines-org-calls-for-mass-hiring/story/ (accessed on 10 October 2020).
Martin, N. and B. Yeung (2020) ‘“Similar to Times of War”: The Staggering Toll of COVID-19 on Filipino Health Care Workers’, ProPublica, 3 May, https://www.propublica.org/article/similar-to-times-of-war-the-staggering-toll-of-covid-19-on-filipino-health-care-workers (accessed on 10 July 2020).
Maru, D. (2020) ‘As Coronavirus Rages, Metro Manila Private Hospitals Face Shortage of Staff, Medical Supplies’, abs cbnNews, 3 April, https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/04/03/20/as-coronavirus-rages-metro-manila-private-hospitals-face-shortage-of-staff-medical-supplies (accessed on 29 March 2021).
McFarling, U.L. (2020) ‘Nursing Ranks Are Filled with Filipino Americans. The Pandemic Is Taking an Outsized Toll on Them’, Statnews, 28 April, https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/28/coronavirus-taking-outsized-toll-on-filipino-american-nurses/ (accessed on 15 July 2020).
McGannon, C. (2020) ‘Coping with COVID-19: How Filipino Nurses and Their Communities Support Frontline Healthcare Workers’, Asianmedia, 16 July, https://asiamedia.lmu.edu/2020/07/16/coping-with-covid-19-how-filipino-nurses-and-their-communities-support-frontline-healthcare-workers/ (accessed on 17 July 2020).
McLaughlin, T. (2020) ‘The Fragility of the Global Nurse Supply Chain’, The Atlantic, 30 April, https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2020/04/immigrant-nurse-health-care-coronavirus-pandemic/610873/ (accessed on 20 August 2020).
Morales, N. (2020) ‘Losing battle: Philippine doctors, nurses urge new COVID-19 lockdowns as infections surge’, Reuters, 1 August, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronarvirus-philippines-idUSKCN24X3IA (accessed on 15 July 2020).
Ortiga, Y.Y. (2017) ‘The Flexible University: Neoliberal Education and the Global Production of Migrant Labor’, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 38(4), pp. 485–499, doi:10.1080/01425692.2015.1113857.
Pang, T., M.A. Lansang and A. Haines (2002) ‘Brain Drain and Health Professionals’, British Medical Journal, 324(499), doi: 10.1136/bmj.324.7336.499.
Parrocha, A. (2020) ‘PRRD Heeds Front-Liners’ Call’, Philippine News Agency, 3 August, https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1110889 (accessed on 15 September 2020).
poea (Philippine Overseas Employment Administration) (2020) Governing Board Resolution No. 9 Series of 2020 (Mandaluyong City: poea), https://www.poea.gov.ph/gbr/2020/GBR-09-2020.pdf (accessed on 2 July 2020).
poea (2014) Annual Report (Mandaluyong City: poea), https://www.poea.gov.ph/annualreports/annualreports.html (accessed on 29 March 2021).
psa (Philippine Statistics Authority) (2016) Census of Population 2015, Public-Use File (Quezon City: Philippines).
psa and uppi (University of the Philippines Population Institute) (2019) 2018 National Migration Survey, https://psa.gov.ph/content/national-migration-survey (accessed on 30 March 2021).
Republic of the Philippines (2010) Republic Act No. 10022: An Act Amending Republic Act No. 8042, Otherwise Known as the Migrant Workers and Overseas Filipinos Act of 1995, Section 5, 10 March, https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/2010/03/10/republic-act-no-10022-s-2010/#:~:text=%E2%80%93%20Notwithstanding%20the%20provisions%20of%20Section,the%20deployment%20of%20migrant%20workers.%E2%80%9D (accessed on 10 May 2020).
Santos, A.P. (2020) ‘Attacked & Underpaid: Medics in Philippines Battle Stigma, Virus’, Al Jazeera, 2 April, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/4/2/attacked-underpaid-medics-in-philippines-battle-stigma-virus (accessed on 10 August 2020).
Smiley, S. (2020) ‘Developed Countries are the Largest Importers of Healthcare Professionals’, Global Trade Mag, 4 May, https://www.globaltrademag.com/developed-countries-are-the-largest-importers-of-healthcare-professionals/ (accessed on 11 August 2020).
Thoun Northrup, D., C.L. Tschanz, V.G. Olynyk, K.L. Schick Makaroff, J. Szabo and H.A. Biasio (2004) ‘Nursing: Whose Discipline is it Anyway?’, Nursing Science Quarterly,17, pp. 55–62, doi:10.1177/0894318403260471.
Tomacruz, S. (2020) ‘PH Health Workers Infected with Coronavirus Reach 5,008’, Rappler, 3 August, https://www.rappler.com/nation/health-workers-coronavirus-cases-philippines-august-3-2020 (accessed on 10 December 2020).
uncescr (United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights) (2006) General Comment No. 18: The Right to Work (Art. 6 of the Covenant), 6 February, e/c.12/gc/18.
UN desa (United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs), Population Division (2020) SDG indicator 10.7. 2: Data Booklet (st/esa/ ser. A/441) https://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/publications/pdf/sdg/SDG_10.7.2_2019_Data%20Booklet.pdf (accessed on 20 August 2020).
unga (United Nations General Assembly) (1966) International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and
Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 16 December, a/res/2200. unosd (United Nations Office for Sustainable Development) (2015) Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs ), https://unosd.un.org/content/sustainable-development-goals-sdgs (accessed on 20 August 2020).
up covid-19 Pandemic Response Team (2020) Estimating Local Healthcare Capacity to Deal with COVID-19 Case Surge: Analysis and Recommendations, University of the Philippines Research and Breakthroughs, 20 April, https://up.edu.ph/estimating-local-healthcare-capacity-to-deal-with-covid-19-case-surge-analysis-and-recommendations/ (accessed on 7 June 2021).
uppi and drdf (Demographic Research and Development Foundation, Inc.) (2020) Human Resource for Health in the Time of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Does the Philippines Have Enough?, uppi/drdf Research Brief No. 8, https://www.uppi.upd.edu.ph/sites/default/files/pdf/COVID-19-Research-Brief-08.pdf (accessed on 7 June 2021).
who (World Health Organization) (2020a) Global Strategic Directions for Strengthening Nursing and Midwifery, 2016–2020 (Geneva: who), pp. 1–56, https://www.who.int/hrh/nursing_midwifery/global-strategic-midwifery2016-2020.pdf (accessed on 15 October 2020).
who (2020b) State of the World’s Nursing—2020 (Geneva: who), https://www.who.int/publications-detail-redirect/9789240003279 (accessed on 30 July 2020).
who (2020c) A Guide to Preventing and Addressing Social Stigma (Geneva: who), https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/covid19-stigma-guide.pdf (accessed on 30 July 2020).
who (2019a) National Health Workforce Accounts: Better Data and Evidence on Health Workforce (Geneva: who), https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/national-health-workforce-accounts (accessed on 15 October 2020).
who (2019b) Delivered by Women, Led by Men: A Gender and Equity Analysis of the Global Health and Social Workforce, Human Resources for Health Observer Series No. 24 (Geneva: who), https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/311322/9789241515467-eng.pdf?ua=1 (accessed on 15 October 2020).
who (2011) Strengthening Nursing and Midwifery, Sixty Fourth World Assembly, Agenda Item 13.4, 24 May, wha 64.7.
who (2010) WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel (Geneva: who), http://www.who.int/hrh/migration/code/practice/en/ (accessed on 19 July 2020).
who (2006) The World Health Report: 2006: Working Together for Health (Geneva: who), https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/43432 (accessed on 19 July 2020).
Xu, Y. and J. Zhang (2005) ‘One Size Doesn’t Fit All: Ethics of International Nurse Recruitment from the Conceptual Framework of Stakeholder Interests’, Nursing Ethics, 12(6), pp. 571–581, doi:10.1191/0969733005ne827oa.