The fifty-year long neoliberal era has been marked by working-class reverses and moribund unions. Grounded in the authorâs own experiences as a transit worker participating in a decades-long effort to fight management and austerity economics, Take Back the Power presents a new perspective on what activists can do to revitalize the labor movement. Marc Kagan uses his unionâs story to illuminate key dilemmas their efforts face, among them: fight the boss or fight the union to fight the boss; the tension between leadership and participatory democracy; and the costs and benefits of risk aversion. This book encourages us to think introspectively about the choices we make as we attempt to build a better world.
Marc Kagan is a former transit worker, a life-long union and shopfloor activist, and sometime union officer. He has taught American, NYC, and Labor History, and is co-author of Gains and Losses: How Protestors Win and Lose (Oxford, 2022).
Acknowledgements
List of Figures
PART 1: Introduction
1 The Fall of the House of Labor, and the New Directions Project
â1 Transformational Efforts and Union Dilemmas
â2 Three Theories on the Decline of American Trade Unions â and Their Implications
â3 Challenging and Changing the Structure and Culture of American Unions
â4 The âLongâ History of TWU Local 100 and the New Directions Project in the Neoliberal Era
â5 An Outline of the Book
2 Local 100, the Transit Industry, and New York Cityâs Fiscal Crisis
â1 Life as a Transit Worker
â2 The First Decades of Transport Workers Union Local 100
â3 Union Reorganization(s)
â4 Distinctions across Transit and Local 100
â5 Local 100 in the Long 1960s
â6 The Taylor Law, New York Cityâs Fiscal Crisis, and Austerity
â7 Conclusion: Priming the Fall
PART 2: Fall
3 A Bottle-Rocket that Led to Only a Wage Increase
â1 1978 Contract Ratification
â2 The 1979 Election
â3 The 1980 Strike: Victory or Defeat?
â4 Controlling the Narrative of the Strike; and After
â5 Conclusion: the Dilemmas of Oppositionist Organizations
4 The Fall of TWU Local 100
â1 The Fight at 207th St.
â2 Managementâs Agenda, Union Complicity, 1982â1999
â3 Conclusion: Neither the Army Nor the Town Hall
PART 3: Rise
5 Divisional Efforts at âShop-Floorâ Struggle
â1 Sort-of Top-Down Militancy in Structure
â2 Mass Action in Car Equipment
â3 Sort-of Bottom-Up in Track
â4 RTO Spawns New Directions
â5 Conclusion: Four Different Countriesv
6 The Rise of New Directions
â1 The Early Years of HoW-ND
â2 Toward Electoralism, 1989â1995
â3 Staving Off New Directions
â4 Democracy in New Directions; New Blood and New Questions, 1996â1998
â5 Success? 1998â2000
â6 Conclusion: the Blemishes on the Golden Apple
7 The Trials and Tasks of Running a Union, 2001â02
â1 Not a âProductive Bargaining Relationshipâ
â2 The Successes and Limits of Fighting Back within the Web of Rules
â3 A Case Study in Bargaining: Local 100âs Health Benefit Crisis
â4 Union and Worker Action
â5 Problems of Union and Workplace Democracy in Theory and Local 100 Practice
â6 The Officers Replicate the Stewards
â7 Management at the Union Hall
â8 The Break-Up of New Directions
â9 Conclusion: Big Gains and Squandered Opportunities
8 Negotiating a Contract
â1 Goals and Priorities
â2 Organizational Preparations for Negotiations
â3 Lots of Expectations: Bargaining Begins
â4 Outside Pressures
â5 Down from the Pinnacle: the 2002 Contract
â6 Final Contract and Fallout: Why No Strike?
â7 Ratification and Objections
â8 Conclusion: a Better Bargain?
PART 4: Fall
9 The Union on the Defensive
â1 Contract Implementation Bogs Down
â2 Accountability, the 2003 Elections, and the Final Demise of the New Directions Left
â3 Union Building â¦
â4 ⦠And Union Unbuilding
â5 Fighting Transit?
â6 Conclusion: a House Divided
10 The 2005 New York City Transit Strike
â1 Contract Preparations and Messaging
â2 Final Pre-Strike Negotiations and Agreements
â3 A Deadline Is a Deadline?
â4 The Strike
â5 The Rejection of the Contract
â6 I Hate the Members; and Contract Arbitration, after All
â7 Conclusion: an Odd Strike, an Odder Ending
11 The End, and âBack to Normalcyâ
â1 The 2006 Elections and New Rounds of Internal Warfare
â2 Amending the Taylor Law, and Other Political Efforts
â3 Cooperation with Transit
â4 Bad Decisions: the Union Bleeds Money, and Members
â5 By-Laws Changes
â6 A Very Bizarre Contract Round
â7 2009 Election
â8 Conclusion: Back to Normalcy
12 The Dilemmas of Union Revitalization
â1 Dilemma: Fight the Boss, or Fight the Union to Fight the Boss
â2 Dilemma: Educational Campaigns or First Win
â3 Dilemma: Leadership, or Participatory Democracy, in the New Directions Caucus
â4 Dilemma: the Army or the Democratic Town Meeting at the Union Hall
â5 Dilemma: the Union Caucus after Victory
â6 Dilemma: Things, or Industrial Democracy
â7 Dilemma: Urgent, or Important? 4348 Dilemma: Risk, or Is Another World Possible?
Appendix A: The Problems and Possibilities of Writing Contemporary and Presentist History
Appendix B: Marxist-Leninist Party Leaflets
Appendix C: Transition Issues for Local 100 (December 2000)
Bibliography
Index
This book is especially relevant for union education and training programs, university courses focused on labor, employment relations, organizational studies, economics, political science, sociology, and history. It will also appeal to union and social movement activists, as well as enthusiasts of New York City and mass transit.