Existence and the Problem of AḥwÄl: The Quiddity and Ontological Status of Existence in Avicenna and His Islamic Reception
In: OriensSearch for other papers by Francesco Omar Zamboni in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
The Avicennian distinction between quiddity and existence opens the way to several derivative issues concerning the quiddity of existence (what existence is) and the ontological status of existence (whether and how existence is). This paper presents a fine-grained account of the positions and arguments developed by post-Avicennian authors on these matters, showing how the debates on states (aḥwÄl) and grounding (taÊ¿lÄ«l) feed into the picture. The discussions on the quiddity of existence revolve around the features of its knowability and its connection to a ground (Ê¿illa), or lack thereof. As for the ontological status of existence, the standard idea of a clash between realism (existence is an extramental existent) and conceptualism (existence is a purely mental existent) calls for further refinement. First, realism itself encompasses two distinct positions when it comes to the relation between the second-order existence of existence and existence itself (sameness, additionality). Second, the tradition presents other doctrines not easily classifiable within the realism-conceptualism framework (the existential non-assertability of existence, the non-existence of existence).
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
AbharÄ«, AthÄ«r al-DÄ«n al-. Kashf al-ḥaqÄʾiq fÄ« taḥrÄ«r al-daqÄʾiq. MSTehran, KitÄbkhÄna-yi majlis-i shÅ«rÄ-yi millÄ«, 9:2752.
-
AbharÄ«, AthÄ«r al-DÄ«n al-. MaqÄá¹£id al-marÄá¹£id. MSIstanbul, Ragıp paá¹£a kitaplıÄı, 682.
-
AbharÄ«, AthÄ«r al-DÄ«n al-. MuntahÄ l-afkÄr fÄ« ibÄnat al-asrÄr. MSTehran, KitÄbkhÄna-yi majlis-i shÅ«rÄ-yi millÄ«, 9:2752.
-
DawÄnÄ«, JalÄl al-DÄ«n al-. ḤÄshiya Ê¿alÄ Sharḥ al-TajrÄ«d. In Ê¿AlÄ l-DÄ«n al-QÅ«shjÄ«. Sharḥ TajrÄ«d. MSCambridge [Massachusetts], Harvard College Library, Widener Library, OL22800.10.5f.
-
KÄtibÄ«, Najm al-DÄ«n al-QazwinÄ« al-. JÄmiÊ¿ al-daqÄʾiq fÄ« kashf al-ḥaqÄʾiq. MS Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, Département de manuscrits, Arabe 2370.
-
KÄtibÄ«, Najm al-DÄ«n al-QazwinÄ« al-. al-Munaṣṣaá¹£ fÄ« sharḥ al-Mulakhkhaá¹£. MSIstanbul, Ragıp paá¹£a kitaplıÄı, 714.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. al-Mulakhkhaá¹£ fÄ« l-ḥikma wa-l-maná¹iq. MSBerlin, Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin, ms. or. Oct. 623.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. RisÄla fÄ«-l-khalq wa-l-baÊ¿th. MSIstanbul, Köprülü kütüphanesi, 816.
-
QÅ«shjÄ«, Ê¿AlÄ l-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-Ê¿aqÄʾid. MSCambridge [Massachusetts], Harvard College Library, Widener Library, OL 22800.10.5f.
-
AbharÄ«, AthÄ«r al-DÄ«n al-. TaḥrÄ«r al-dalÄʾil fÄ« taqrÄ«r al-masÄʾil. In MahdÄ« Ê¿AáºÄ«mÄ«, âTaḥṣīṣ va taḥqÄ«q risÄla-yi TaḥrÄ«r al-dalÄʾil fÄ« taqrÄ«r al-masÄʾil Athar-i AthÄ«r al-DÄ«n al-AbharÄ«.â Falsafa va kalÄm-i islÄmÄ« 47, no.1 (Spring/Summer 2014): 113â143.
-
Aná¹£ÄrÄ«, AbÅ« l-QÄsim al-. al-Ghunya fÄ« l-kalÄm. Ed. by Muá¹£á¹afÄ á¸¤. Ê¿Abd al-HÄdÄ«. Cairo: DÄr al-salÄm, 2010.
-
Avicenna. al-ShifÄʾ, al-MaqÅ«lÄt. Ed. by IbrahÄ«m MadkÅ«r, Georges Sh. QanawatÄ«, MaḥmÅ«d M. al-ḪudayrÄ«, and Aḥmad F. al-IhwÄnÄ«. Cairo: al-Hayʾa al-Ê¿Ämma li- shuÊ¿Å«n al-maá¹ÄbiÊ¿ al-amÄ«riyya, 1959.
-
Avicenna. al-ShifÄ, al-IlÄhiyyÄt. Ed. by IbrahÄ«m MadkÅ«r, SulaymÄn DunyÄ, Muḥammad Y. MÅ«sÄ, Georges QanawÄtÄ«, and SaÊ¿Ä«d ZÄyid. Cairo: al-Hayʾa al-Ê¿Ämma li-shuÊ¿Å«n al-maá¹ÄbiÊ¿ al-amÄ«riyya, 1960.
-
Avicenna. al-MubÄḥathÄt. Ed. by Muḥsin BidÄrfar. Qum: IntishÄrÄt BÄ«dÄr, 1992.
-
Avicenna. al-IshÄrÄt wa-l-tanbÄ«hÄt. Ed. by MujtabÄ al-ZÄriÊ¿Ä«. Qum: BÅ«stÄn-i kitÄb, 2002.
-
ÄmidÄ«, Sayf al-DÄ«n al-. GhÄyat al-marÄm fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-kalÄm. Ed. by Ḥasan M. Ê¿Abd al-Laá¹Ä«f. Cairo: Lajnat ihÌ£yÄʾ al-turÄth al-islÄmÄ«, 1971.
-
ÄmidÄ«, Sayf al-DÄ«n al-. AbkÄr al-afkÄr fÄ« uṣūl al-dÄ«n. Ed. by Aḥmad M. al-MahdÄ«. Cairo: DaÌr al-kutub wa-l-wathaÌʾiq al-qawmiyya, 2004.
-
BaghdÄdÄ«, AbÅ« l-BarakÄt al-. KitÄb al-muÊ¿tabar fÄ« l-ḥikma. Hyderabad, 1938â39.
-
BahmanyÄr, Ibn MarzubÄn. al-Taḥṣīl. Ed. by Murtaá¸Ä Moá¹ahharÄ«. Tehran: DÄnishgÄh-i TihrÄn, 1996.
-
BÄqillÄnÄ«, AbÅ« Bakr al-. TamhÄ«d al-awÄʾil wa-talkhÄ«á¹£ al-dalÄʾil. Ed. by AhÌ£mad HÌ£aydar. Beirut: Muʾassasat al-kutub al-thaqÄfiyya, 1993.
-
Bayá¸ÄwÄ«, NÄá¹£ir al-DÄ«n al-. ṬawÄliÊ¿ al-anwÄr min maá¹ÄliÊ¿ al-anáºÄr. Ed. by Ê¿AbbÄd SulaymÄn. Cairo-Beirut: al-Maktaba al-azhariyya li-l-turÄth â DÄr al-jÄ«l, 1991.
-
JurjÄnÄ«, al-SharÄ«f al-. Sharḥ al-MawÄqif. Istanbul[?]: DÄr al-á¹ibÄÊ¿a al-Ê¿Ämira, 1894.
-
JuwaynÄ«, AbÅ« l-MaÊ¿ÄlÄ« al-. al-ShÄmil fÄ« uṣūl al-dÄ«n. Ed. by Ê¿AlÄ« S. al-NashshÄr, Fayá¹£al B. Ê¿Awn, and Suhayr M. MukhtÄr. Iskandariyya: Manshaʾat al-maÊ¿Ärif, 1969.
-
JuwaynÄ«, AbÅ« l-MaÊ¿ÄlÄ« al-. al-IrshÄd ilÄ qawÄá¹iÊ¿ al-adilla fÄ« uṣūl al-iÊ¿tiqÄd. Ed. by Ê¿AlÄ« Ê¿Abd al-ḤamÄ«d and Muḥammad Y. MÅ«sÄ. Cairo: Maktabat al-KhÄnijÄ«, 1950.
-
GhazÄlÄ«, AbÅ« ḤÄmid al-. TahÄfut al-falÄsifa. Ed. and transl. by Michael E. Marmura. Provo: Brigham Young University Press, 2000.
-
ḤillÄ«, al-Ê¿AllÄma al-. Kashf al-murÄd fÄ« sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-iÊ¿tiqÄd. Ed. by Ḥasan Ḥ. al-AmulÄ«. Qum: Muʾassasat al-nashr al-islÄmÄ«, 1986.
-
ḤillÄ«, al-Ê¿AllÄma al-. al-AsrÄr al-khafiya fÄ« l-Ê¿ulÅ«m al-Ê¿aqliyya. Qum: Muʾassasa-yi bustÄn-i kitÄb, 2009.
-
KhayyÄm, Ê¿Umar al-. RisÄla fÄ« l-wujÅ«d. In JamshÄ«dnižad A. Ghulamriá¸Ä. âSukhani darbara-yi RisÄlat fi l-wujud az ḤakÄ«m Ê¿Umar b. IbrahÄ«m ḪayyÄm.â Farhang 29â32 (Winter 1999), 101â135.
-
KhayyÄm, Ê¿Umar al-. RisÄla fÄ« jawÄb Ê¿an thalÄtha masÄʾil. In JÄmiÊ¿ al-badÄʾiÊ¿. Ed. by Muḥammad Ḥ. IsmÄÊ¿Ä«l. Beirut: DÄr al-kutub al-Ê¿ilmiyya, 2004, 134â141.
-
KhayyÄm, Ê¿Umar al-. RisÄla fÄ« l-á¸iyÄʾ al-Ê¿aqlÄ« fÄ« mawá¸Å«Ê¿ al-Ê¿ilm al-kullÄ«. In JÄmiÊ¿ al-badÄʾiÊ¿. Ed. by Muḥammad Ḥ. IsmÄÊ¿Ä«l. Beirut: DÄr al-kutub al-Ê¿ilmiyya, 2004, 142â146.
-
Ibn GhaylÄn, Afá¸al al-DÄ«n al-BalkhÄ«. ḤudÅ«th al-Ê¿Älam. Ed. by MahdÄ« Muḥaqqiq. Tehran: Anjuman-i ÄthÄr va mafaÌkhir-i farhangÄ«, 2005.
-
Ibn KammÅ«na, Ê¿Izz al-Dawla. al-KÄshif al-jadÄ«d fÄ« l-ḥikma. Ed. by ḤÄmid N. Iá¹£fahÄnÄ«. Tehran: Muʾassasa-yi pazÌuÌhisÌiÌ-yi ḥikmat va falsafa-yi IÌraÌn, 2008.
-
Ibn al-MalÄḥimÄ«, Rukn al-DÄ«n. Tuḥfat al-mutakallimÄ«n fÄ« l-radd Ê¿alÄ l-falÄsifa. Ed. by Hassan Ansari and Wilferd Madelung. Tehran: Iranian Institute of Philosophy & Institute of Islamic Studies Free University of Berlin, 2008.
-
Ibn al-TilimsÄnÄ«, Sharaf al-DÄ«n. Sharḥ MaÊ¿Älim uṣūl al-dÄ«n. Ed. by NizaÌr HÌ£ammaÌdiÌ. Ê¿AmmaÌn: DaÌr al-fathÌ£ li-l-diraÌsaÌt wa-l-nashr, 2010.
-
ĪjÄ«, Aá¸ud al-DÄ«n al-. al-MawÄqif fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-kalÄm. Beirut: Ê¿Älam al-kutub, [?].
-
Iá¹£fahÄnÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. Maá¹ÄliÊ¿ al-anáºÄr Ê¿alÄ matn á¹awÄliÊ¿ al-anwÄr. Cairo[?]: DÄr al-kutub, 2008.
-
Iá¹£fahÄnÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. TasdÄ«d al-qawÄÊ¿id fÄ« sharḥ TajrÄ«d al-Ê¿aqÄʾid. Ed. by ḪÄlid al-Ê¿AdwÄnÄ«. Kuwait: DÄr al-á¸iyÄʾ, 2012.
-
KÄtibÄ«, Najm al-DÄ«n al-QazwinÄ« al-. Ḥikmat al-Ê¿ayn. Ed. by á¹¢Äliḥ ÄydÄ«n. Cairo: [?], 2002.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. al-MabÄḥith al-mashriqiyya fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-ilÄhiyyÄt wa-l-á¹abÄ«Ê¿iyyÄt. Hyderabad: DÄʾirat al-maÊ¿Ärif al-niáºÄmiyya, 1924.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. al-Maá¹Älib al-Ê¿Äliya mina l-Ê¿ilm al-ilÄhÄ«. Ed. Aḥmad Ḥ. al-SaqqÄ. Beirut: DÄr al-kitÄb al-Ê¿arabÄ«, 1987.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ Ê¿UyÅ«n al-ḥikma. Tehran: Muʾassasat al-á¹¢Ädiq li-l-á¹abÄÊ¿a wa-l-nashr, 1994.
-
RÄzÄ«, Fakhr al-DÄ«n al-. al-IshÄra fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-kalÄm. Ed. by HÄnÄ« M. ḤÄʾiz Muḥammad. Cairo: al-Maktaba al-azhariyya li-l-turÄth, [?].
-
SamarqandÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. al-á¹¢aḥÄʾif al-ilÄhiyya. Ed. by Aḥmad Ê¿A. al-SharÄ«f. Kuwait, 1985.
-
SamarqandÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. al-MaÊ¿Ärif fÄ« sharḥ al-á¹¢aḥÄʾif. In Ê¿Abd al-RaḥmÄn S. AbÅ« á¹¢uÊ¿aylÄ«k, âKitÄb al-MaÊ¿Ärif fÄ« sharḥ al-á¹¢aḥÄʾif taʾlÄ«f Shams al-DÄ«n Muḥammad b. Ashraf al-ḤusaynÄ« al-SamarqandÄ« al-mutawaffÄ baÊ¿da 705h â TaḥqÄ«q wa-DirÄsa.â PhD dissertation, JÄmiÊ¿at al-Ê¿ulÅ«m al-islÄmiyya al-Ê¿Älamiyya, Amman, 2012.
-
SuhrawardÄ«, ShihÄb al-DÄ«n al-. Ḥikmat al-ishrÄq. Ed. by Henry Corbin. Tehran: PižuÌhishgaÌh-i Ê¿uluÌm-i insaÌniÌ va mutaÌlaÊ¿aÌt-i farhangiÌ, 1993.
-
SuhrawardÄ«, ShihÄb al-DÄ«n al-. KitÄb al-MashÄriÊ¿ wa-l-muá¹ÄḥarÄt (al-Ê¿ilm al-thÄlith). In MawsÅ«Ê¿at muá¹£annafÄt al-SuhrawardÄ«. Ed. by Muḥsin Ê¿AqÄ«l. [?]: DÄr RawÄfid, 2018.
-
SuhrawardÄ«, ShihÄb al-DÄ«n al-. KitÄb al-muqÄwamÄt (al-Ê¿ilm al-thÄlith). In MawsÅ«Ê¿at muá¹£annafÄt al-SuhrawardÄ«. Ed. by Muḥsin Ê¿AqÄ«l. [?]: DÄr RawÄfid, 2018.
-
SuhrawardÄ«, ShihÄb al-DÄ«n al-. KitÄb al-talwīḥÄt al-lawḥiyya wa-l-Ê¿arshiyya (al-Ê¿ilm al-thÄlith). In MawsÅ«Ê¿at muá¹£annafÄt al-SuhrawardÄ«. Ed. by Muḥsin Ê¿AqÄ«l. [?]: DÄr RawÄfid, 2018.
-
ShahrastÄnÄ«, AbÅ« l-Fatḥ al-. NihÄyat al-aqdÄm fÄ« Ê¿ilm al-kalÄm. Ed. by Alfred Guillaume. Cairo: Maktabat al-thaqÄfa al-dÄ«niyya, 2009.
-
ShahrazÅ«rÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. RasÄʾil al-shajara al-ilÄhiyya fÄ« Ê¿ulÅ«m al-ḥaqÄʾiq. Ed. by NajafqalÄ« ḤabÄ«bÄ«. Tehran: Muʾassasa-yi pižuÌhishiÌ-yi ḥikmat va falsafa, 2004.
-
ShahrazÅ«rÄ«, Shams al-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ Ḥikmat al-ishrÄq. Ed. by Aḥmad Ê¿A. SÄyihÌ£. Cairo: Maktabat al-thaqÄfa al-dÄ«niyya, 2012.
-
ShirÄzÄ«, Quá¹b al-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ Ḥikmat al-ishrÄq. Ed. by Ê¿Abdallah NÅ«rÄnÄ« and MahdÄ« Muḥaqqiq. Tehran: Anjuman-i ÄthÄr va mafÄkir-i farhangÄ«, 2005.
-
TaftazÄnÄ«, SaÊ¿d al-DÄ«n al-. Sharḥ al-MaqÄá¹£id. Ed. by Ê¿Abd al-RaḥmÄn Ê¿Umayra. Beirut: Ê¿Älam al-kutub, 1998.
-
ṬūsÄ«, Naṣīr al-DÄ«n al-. Ḥall mushkilÄt al-IshÄrÄt. In Avicenna. al-IshÄrÄt wa-l-tanbÄ«hÄt li-AbÄ« Ê¿Ali ibn SÄ«nÄ maÊ¿a sharḥ Naṣīr al-DÄ«n al-ṬūsÄ«. Ed. by SulaymÄn DunyÄ. Cairo: DÄr al-maÊ¿Ärif, 1957â60.
-
ṬūsÄ«, Naṣīr al-DÄ«n al-. TalkhÄ«á¹£ al-Muḥaṣṣal. Ed. by Ê¿Abdallah NuÌraÌniÌ. Tehran : IntishÄrÄt-i muʾassasah-i mutÌ£aÌlaÊ¿aÌt-i islaÌmiÌ, daÌnishgaÌh-i MiÌkgiÌl, shuÊ¿bah-i TihraÌn, baÌ hamkaÌriÌ-i daÌnishgaÌh-i TihraÌn, 1980.
-
ṬūsÄ«, Naṣīr al-DÄ«n al-. TajrÄ«d al-iÊ¿tiqÄd. Ed. by Muḥammad J. Al-ḤusaynÄ« al-JalÄlÄ«. Qum: Maktab al-iÊ¿lÄm al-islÄmÄ«, 1986.
-
Alami, Ahmed. Lâontologie modale: Ãtude de la théorie des modes dâAbÅ« HÄshim al- JubbÄʾī. Paris: J.Vrin, 2001.
-
Benevich, Fedor. âThe classical AshÊ¿ari theory of aḥwÄl. JuwaynÄ« and his opponents.â Journal of Islamic Studies 27, no.2 (2016): 136â175.
-
Benevich, Fedor. âThe Essence-Existence Distinction: Four Elements of the Post-Avicennian Metaphysical Dispute (11â13th Centuries).â Oriens 45 (2017): 203â258.
-
Benevich, Fedor. âThe Metaphysics of Muḥammad b. Ê¿Abd al-KarÄ«m al-Å ahrastÄnÄ« (d.1153): AḥwÄl and Universals.â In Islamic Philosophy from the 12th to the 14th century. Ed. by Abdelkader al-Ghouz. Göttingen: V&R unipress, 2018, 327â356.
-
Eichner, Heidrun. âEssence and Existence. Thirteenth-Century Perspectives in Arabic-Islamic Philosophy and Theology.â In The Arabic, Hebrew and Latin Receptions of Avicennaâs Metaphysics. Ed. by Dag N. Hasse and Amos Bertolacci. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2012, 123â152.
-
Frank, Richard MacDonough. Beings and their attributes: The teaching of the Basrian school of the Muʿtazila in the classical period. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1978.
-
Rizvi, Sajjad. âAn Islamic Subversion of the Existence-Essence Distinction? Suhrawardiâs Visionary Hierarchy of Lights.â Asian Philosophy 9, no.3 (1999): 219â227.
-
Rizvi, Sajjad. âRoots of an Aporia in Later Islamic Philosophy: the Existence-Essence Distinction in the Philosophies of Avicenna and Suhrawardi.â Studia Iranica 29, no.1 (2000): 61â108.
-
Thiele, Jan. âAbÅ« HÄshim al-JubbÄʾīâs (d.321/933) Theory of âStatesâ (aḥwÄl) and its Adaption by AshÊ¿arite Theologians.â In The Oxford Handbook of Islamic Theology. Ed. by Sabine Schmidtke. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016, 364â383.
-
Wisnovsky, Robert. Avicennaâs Metaphysics in Context. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2003.
-
Wisnovsky, Robert. âEssence and Existence in the Eleventh- and Twelfth-Century Islamic East (MaÅ¡riq): A Sketch.â In The Arabic, Hebrew and Latin Receptions of Avicennaâs Metaphysics. Ed. by Dag N. Hasse and Amos Bertolacci. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2012, 27â50.
-
Zamboni, Francesco O. âIs Existence One or Manifold? Avicenna and his Early Interpreters on the Modulation of Existence.â Documenti e studi sulla tradizione filosofica medievale 31 (2020): 121â150.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1291 | 299 | 10 |
| Full Text Views | 341 | 11 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 557 | 36 | 0 |
Existence and the Problem of AḥwÄl: The Quiddity and Ontological Status of Existence in Avicenna and His Islamic Reception
In: OriensSearch for other papers by Francesco Omar Zamboni in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
The Avicennian distinction between quiddity and existence opens the way to several derivative issues concerning the quiddity of existence (what existence is) and the ontological status of existence (whether and how existence is). This paper presents a fine-grained account of the positions and arguments developed by post-Avicennian authors on these matters, showing how the debates on states (aḥwÄl) and grounding (taÊ¿lÄ«l) feed into the picture. The discussions on the quiddity of existence revolve around the features of its knowability and its connection to a ground (Ê¿illa), or lack thereof. As for the ontological status of existence, the standard idea of a clash between realism (existence is an extramental existent) and conceptualism (existence is a purely mental existent) calls for further refinement. First, realism itself encompasses two distinct positions when it comes to the relation between the second-order existence of existence and existence itself (sameness, additionality). Second, the tradition presents other doctrines not easily classifiable within the realism-conceptualism framework (the existential non-assertability of existence, the non-existence of existence).
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1291 | 299 | 10 |
| Full Text Views | 341 | 11 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 557 | 36 | 0 |
